Monty Python and the Holy Grail Official WW game thread

SDN Members don't see this ad. (About Ads)

Originally Posted by cuitlamiztli

I totally forgot about that part . So in that case it would pertain to JJ instead.

Anyone else think this is a valid theory?

Sounds accurate to me.

lynch jj

Sent from my DROID RAZR using SDN Mobile

whoops guess i was wrong about hedgie tho
I wish i could lynch jj
boo

lynch jj

***********************************

Boo.

Ahh, people, people, people. Mods, I'm trying to respond to your PM, but none of them are going through. Or if they are, they aren't going through on my end. Getting a database error.

**********************************

I think they are going through despite saying 'database error' - some of my posts are/were doing the same thing. SDN must be having server issues.

lynch JJ

Ugh, guys, I am NOT a wolf/the killer rabbit. Please do not lynch me. I have a pretty important role that you want to keep around. I know it's easy to say that, but I'll reveal my role if I have to. I'd just rather not quite yet.

To answer an earlier question, yes, being a newt does block night actions. But I didn't have any night actions to be blocked!

I can see where this bandwagon is headed. When is the deadline for the lynch?

Originally Posted by jjohnston

Ugh, guys, I am NOT a wolf/the killer rabbit. Please do not lynch me. I have a pretty important role that you want to keep around. I know it's easy to say that, but I'll reveal my role if I have to. I'd just rather not quite yet.

I'm sorry but things aren't adding up. I'm just going with what I know (and acknowledge that it could be way off base).

Can anyone vouch for you? Or do you have an alternate theory as to why the rabbit was not out and about the night after you were newterized?

(I am still awake at 2am because my dog is NOT enjoying the wind/blizzard currently covering the state of Iowa)

Originally Posted by cuitlamiztli

Out of curiosity, why didn't you share this info when you voted for zany? At best it would have increased our index of suspicion, and at worst it would have given us 3 other players to investigate/block/newterize/what-have-you.

I still want to know the answer to this...

vote tally

jj - 6 (orca, cuit, FFM, jam, kaydubs, ec)

Originally Posted by cuitlamiztli

I'm sorry but things aren't adding up. I'm just going with what I know (and acknowledge that it could be way off base).

Can anyone vouch for you? Or do you have an alternate theory as to why the rabbit was not out and about the night after you were newterized?

(I am still awake at 2am because my dog is NOT enjoying the wind/blizzard currently covering the state of Iowa)

I will hold off of the bandwagon until this is answered...

unlynch jj I don't want to jump on a bandwagon and kill a villager. Probably won't be able to get on for a new lynch vote, though, since I have my physics exam and am going riding afterwards.

Originally Posted by jjohnston

To answer an earlier question, yes, being a newt does block night actions. But I didn't have any night actions to be blocked!

I can see where this bandwagon is headed. When is the deadline for the lynch?

No earlier that 1:30 EST unless almost everyone has voted.

There are 13 players... 2 are blocked... 10 legitimate votes would probably call it earlier.

Originally Posted by nohika

***********************************

Boo.

Ahh, people, people, people. Mods, I'm trying to respond to your PM, but none of them are going through. Or if they are, they aren't going through on my end. Getting a database error.

**********************************

I did NOT receive your message. I sent you an e-mail message as well.. but as you have already taken care of the issue.... no worries..

Hi guys. PMs don't appear to be going through. Just wanted to apologize to everyone and the mods- I've had a really rough week and then found out last night a really close friend committed suicide yesterday. I feel really bad about not being active, I hope you all can understand. Go villagers

Originally Posted by that redhead

Hi guys. PMs don't appear to be going through. Just wanted to apologize to everyone and the mods- I've had a really rough week and then found out last night a really close friend committed suicide yesterday. I feel really bad about not being active, I hope you all can understand. Go villagers

So sorry to hear that.
Real life intervenes sometimes (i certainly know from experience)...

Don't feel badly....of course we understand.

Originally Posted by that redhead

Hi guys. PMs don't appear to be going through. Just wanted to apologize to everyone and the mods- I've had a really rough week and then found out last night a really close friend committed suicide yesterday. I feel really bad about not being active, I hope you all can understand. Go villagers

So sorry to hear this. Sending thoughts and prayers your way!

As for lynch, willing to waffle. Will check back in later.

vote tally

jj - 5 (orca, cuit, FFM, jam, kaydubs)

*****************
I can't stop looking at that gif. It just makes me laugh so much!
*****************

Originally Posted by that redhead

Hi guys. PMs don't appear to be going through. Just wanted to apologize to everyone and the mods- I've had a really rough week and then found out last night a really close friend committed suicide yesterday. I feel really bad about not being active, I hope you all can understand. Go villagers

So sorry to hear this You're in our thoughts lady!

Originally Posted by devyn

vote tally

jj - 5 (orca, cuit, FFM, jam, kaydubs)

Oh look...kaydubs still trying to hop around and attack people.

Don't know when i'll be back so....lynch JJ

Alright, I'll reveal my role, but hope that someone can protect me. I am Patsy, Arthur's servant. Arthur cannot die while I still live. By protecting me, you protect us both.

I have not told anyone this role because I haven't had a reason to trust anyone. So I don't think anyone can vouch for me. And I don't have an alternate theory as to why the rabbit didn't attack, I have no idea. But I am Patsy, a villager, and it's best to keep me alive.

Originally Posted by jjohnston

Alright, I'll reveal my role, but hope that someone can protect me. I am Patsy, Arthur's servant. Arthur cannot die while I still live. By protecting me, you protect us both.

I have not told anyone this role because I haven't had a reason to trust anyone. So I don't think anyone can vouch for me. And I don't have an alternate theory as to why the rabbit didn't attack, I have no idea. But I am Patsy, a villager, and it's best to keep me alive.

Does Arthur even know who you are? Do you know who Arthur is? A simple yes or no will suffice for the second question.

Sent from my DROID RAZR using SDN Mobile

Originally Posted by Jamr0ckin

Does Arthur even know who you are? Do you know who Arthur is? A simple yes or no will suffice for the second question.

Sent from my DROID RAZR using SDN Mobile

I have no idea if Arthur knows who I am, but I do not know who Arthur is. I was only told that I'm Arthur's servant and he cannot die while I still live. I was hoping to try to find him with an investigatory item, but the only item I've received the whole was the shrubbery, which I immediately sent to nyanko because she was blocked by the Knights of Ni at the time.

Originally Posted by jjohnston

I have no idea if Arthur knows who I am, but I do not know who Arthur is. I was only told that I'm Arthur's servant and he cannot die while I still live. I was hoping to try to find him with an investigatory item, but the only item I've received the whole was the shrubbery, which I immediately sent to nyanko because she was blocked by the Knights of Ni at the time.

Don't you think that's odd? That you wouldn't be able to communicate with Arthur? And you could have been converted, despite starting out as Patsy, the villager.

I'm sorry, but there are still a lot of gaps. No rabbit last night, and you were the newt. Its all a little suspect.

Sent from my DROID RAZR using SDN Mobile

Originally Posted by Jamr0ckin

Don't you think that's odd? That you wouldn't be able to communicate with Arthur? And you could have been converted, despite starting out as Patsy, the villager.

I'm sorry, but there are still a lot of gaps. No rabbit last night, and you were the newt. Its all a little suspect.

Sent from my DROID RAZR using SDN Mobile

No, I don't think it's particularly odd. I feel like sometimes roles like this can communicate and sometimes they can't. Up to the mod. In this case, we can't.

Sure, anyone could be converted at any time. But the rabbit has been attacking since the very beginning of the game! If everyone's theory is that there's one person who's the rabbit, then it can't be me. The rabbit would have to be an original wolf role.

I don't know why the rabbit didn't attack - maybe a conversion occurred? But it had nothing to do with my being a newt. Why would announce on the thread to everyone that I was a newt if I was the rabbit and knew I wouldn't be able to perform that action? Obviously it looks pretty suspect.

vote tally

jj - 6 (orca, cuit, FFM, jam, kaydubs, SNS)

What does everyone - especially those who started/are leading JJ's lynch -- think of Kaydubs' joining the bandwagon? Doesn't it make it at least suspicious that Kaydubs, whose death was so desired up to this point, wants JJ to be lynched???

Originally Posted by MrsSOV

What does everyone - especially those who started/are leading JJ's lynch -- think of Kaydubs' joining the bandwagon? Doesn't it make it at least suspicious that Kaydubs, whose death was so desired up to this point, wants JJ to be lynched???

Yes and no. If Kaydbubs voted for someone else, that would kind of prove to me for sure that JJ was a wolf if she didn't want her dead. At least that's how I would look at it. By choosing to vote for her, it kind of leads it up to debate in my mind.

And I'm not 100% on JJ, it was just the best theory I had.

I tend to believe JJ's explanation of her role and if it is true, she cannot be the rabbit. Can anyone explain why JJ is the rabbit without inventing a "new theory" but with the info. we currently have??

The lack of communication seems odd. JJ...were you allowed to contact anyone outside of your location group?

Originally Posted by shortnsweet

The lack of communication seems odd. JJ...were you allowed to contact anyone outside of your location group?

No, I wasn't. I don't know why that seems odd, I feel like it's a common game mechanic.

Look, I am Patsy. You know that role has to exist in this game. If I were converted, I would not be the rabbit, since those attacks have been occurring since the beginning of the game. So lynching me based on the fact that I was turned into a newt, and therefore my actions were blocked, and the fact that there wasn't a rabbit attack last night doesn't make logical sense.

Originally Posted by jjohnston

No, I wasn't. I don't know why that seems odd, I feel like it's a common game mechanic.

Look, I am Patsy. You know that role has to exist in this game. If I were converted, I would not be the rabbit, since those attacks have been occurring since the beginning of the game. So lynching me based on the fact that I was turned into a newt, and therefore my actions were blocked, and the fact that there wasn't a rabbit attack last night doesn't make logical sense.

I find it odd only because I know other lines of communication that are similar do exist.

Originally Posted by cuitlamiztli

I still want to know the answer to this...

Out of curiosity, why didn't you share this info when you voted for zany? At best it would have increased our index of suspicion, and at worst it would have given us 3 other players to investigate/block/newterize/what-have-you.


because zany was in that group anyway and there were a bunch of people already on the bandwagon for the lynch. I thought if zany turned out to actually be a wolf, then that information was irrelenvant. But now I'm pretty darn sure frogs=wolves. So it was all irrelevant anyway.

Okay, whatever. I'm obviously going to be lynched because people are here and reading the thread but no one is changing their vote. No one is saying much of anything, really. Even though I've given compelling reasoning for why I'm not a wolf.

When I'm lynched, and you all find out that I'm Patsy, 1) I will lay a huge fat "I told you so" all over this thread and 2) take a good look at those who voted for me and then never even questioned it.

Thanks to MrsSOV, the only one who seemingly even read my arguements. Because I haven't seen a single person respond to the fact that I cannot have started out as a villager AND be the rabbit. And we all know that Patsy has to be role.

I am questioning it but still don't really have a better idea.

My only problem is that there hasn't even really been an inkling of an Arthur which I find odd too.

Unlynch JJ, Lynch FTB

Originally Posted by jjohnston

Okay, whatever. I'm obviously going to be lynched because people are here and reading the thread but no one is changing their vote. No one is saying much of anything, really. Even though I've given compelling reasoning for why I'm not a wolf.

When I'm lynched, and you all find out that I'm Patsy, 1) I will lay a huge fat "I told you so" all over this thread and 2) take a good look at those who voted for me and then never even questioned it.

Thanks to MrsSOV, the only one who seemingly even read my arguements. Because I haven't seen a single person respond to the fact that I cannot have started out as a villager AND be the rabbit. And we all know that Patsy has to be role.

This is what I see
1) there could have been a conversion (possibly you) or
2) you're completely lying about the role, and you're the newterized rabid rabbit or
3) you've been set up by the wolves to make it seem as though you're the rabbit but you're really just Patsy

hmmm

Originally Posted by swingnsave

This is what I see
1) there could have been a conversion (possibly you) or
2) you're completely lying about the role, and you're the newterized rabid rabbit or
3) you've been set up by the wolves to make it seem as though you're the rabbit but you're really just Patsy

hmmm

This is what i'm going on...and will be cranky if JJ fooled me

Since I don't have a better idea, unlynch JJ, lynch FTB since I don't really have anything on you either.

vote tally

jj - 4 (cuit, FFM, jam, kaydubs)
FTB 2 (orca, SnS)

Originally Posted by StartingoverVet

vote tally

jj - 5 (cuit, FFM, jam, kaydubs, SNS)
FTB 1 (orca)

Erm...you missed me...I waffled before orca

I wouldn't be a good enough wolf to pull that kind of thing off. I've never actually played as a wolf, ever (I was assigned a wolf role once, but was killed night 1 by chance by the other wolf group).

I've tried going back through the thread to see who vote for, but no one really stands out. So I'll vote to lynch FTB to save my own skin. I'm not overly suspicious of her, but I know that I'm not a wolf.

Originally Posted by shortnsweet

Erm...you missed me...I waffled before orca

saw the same thing twice... confused me.

vote tally

jj - 4 (cuit, FFM, jam, kaydubs)
FTB 3 (orca, SnS, JJ)

Originally Posted by StartingoverVet

saw the same thing twice... confused me.

It's cool. Cheers, God.

just catching up...glad I checked

unlynch jj

lynch FTB

vote tally

jj - 3 (cuit, jam, kaydubs)
FTB 4 (orca, SnS, JJ, FFM)

Alright, I'm going out to finish my Christmas shopping, so won't be around to defend myself anymore. Although I don't think there's much else I can say. It seems to be in my favor at the moment, but some people haven't voted. I guess I'll find out when I get home.

I can close it now... or keep it open a few minutes if it helps.
A few people missing... not to mention FTB..