- Joined
- Aug 5, 2008
- Messages
- 616
- Reaction score
- 2
Just about everything else...
Well, I think autopsy is safe as well.
Although - what is the salary for pathologists at these mega labs? Is it terrible?
Just about everything else...
I was thinking of when surgeons cut out a mass and pathologists have to section and read it immediately bc the surgery will be effected by the results.
What area is easy to outsource?
Agree 100% with this. Path unfortunately has not been viewed as a popular field by many AMGs. Thus, most spots are open for FMGs.
I had said " They seem to flourish COMPARATIVELY." and NOT completely.
Of course we have. Those who would propose to be our advocates are well aware of our issues, but usually just shrug their shoulders as if to say "yeah, life sucks doesn't it".I wish that everyone would stop complaining online/dwelling on the negatives and instead, go out and DO SOMETHING about it. Get on the horn to our advocates. Let them know how you feel. CAP, ASCP, Representatives, Senators...any (or all) and let them know what is happening. Construct the thoughts that you are expressing on this forum into a coherent argument and explain the crisis to our advocates. Take charge to make change for the better.
First of all, I would just like to say that threads like this are seriously depressing. What ever happened to positive thinking and taking initiative?
Secondly, I wish that everyone would stop complaining online/dwelling on the negatives and instead, go out and DO SOMETHING about it. Get on the horn to our advocates. Let them know how you feel. CAP, ASCP, Representatives, Senators...any (or all) and let them know what is happening. Construct the thoughts that you are expressing on this forum into a coherent argument and explain the crisis to our advocates. Take charge to make change for the better.
When stuff gets hard, you should just flee? I don't think so. Together we can make a difference. I love pathology too much to just "flee" when things get tough.
Anything in life worth having doesn't come easy folks. It is time to take a stand, not run away.
Agreed. I know at first blush the concept of a strike seems childish, unrealistic, and/or somehow and admission of giving up, but at this point I see no realistic alternative.Correct me if I am wrong, but from my limited exposure to the field I think pathology tends to attract more socially awkward, introverted individuals with poor political skills and zero desire to be politically active. This, coupled with lots of FMGs among faculty and residents with poor English skills and poor understanding of the political system in medicine, I am not surprised government, insurance, hospital admins roll over pathologists. I feel for the field. I think the field is great, but I am not hugely optimistic about its future
the bloated robber barons you refer to saw that the light at the end of the tunnel was a train; at least I/my group did and knew it was time to exit while the getting was good. anyone who saw what i did and did not do the same if presented with the opportunity regrets it. i know several in that circumstance and they now make 1/2 or less than they did and they will get little or nothing from their practice equity when they retireLet me add there is NO area of medicine in US history that has been worse served by its leadership than Pathology. Beginning in early 1980s leading up to CLIA, the fat and bloated Pathology leadership was only concerned with saving their own hides and enriching themselves in the sell out boom that began in 1988.
CAP and ABP and the such have sold out the entire profession dating back to Virchow.
There is no area in the upper echelons of Pathology that have been left untainted by this rot:
1.) Academics have maintained the massive overtraining in Pathology to fatten their bottom lines and rely less on the Pathology Assts. who in some cases are making much more than actual Pathologists! (I have documented examples of hospital employed PAs making 110K/year while Pathologists are hired at 95K).
2.) The bloated robber barons who sold out to Quest/Ameripath have continued to pillage the marketplace when their own massive fortunes took hit first in the stock downturn in 2000-2001 and then with the RE crash in 2007.
3.) The appointed leadership at CAP have focused more on appeasing elected politicians in Washington with ridiculous QC requirements and absurd reporting formats rather than addressing the fact their members are literally on fire.
I cant even name 1 major force in Healthcare at the moment that is actually on our side.
This is literally a modern Masada. And like Masada, there may be none of us left to tell the tale.
Let me add there is NO area of medicine in US history that has been worse served by its leadership than Pathology. Beginning in early 1980s leading up to CLIA, the fat and bloated Pathology leadership was only concerned with saving their own hides and enriching themselves in the sell out boom that began in 1988.
Academics have maintained the massive overtraining in Pathology to fatten their bottom lines and rely less on the Pathology Assts. who in some cases are making much more than actual Pathologists! (I have documented examples of hospital employed PAs making 110K/year while Pathologists are hired at 95K).
.
With that kind of chaff income, it would be better to retrain in internal medicine, surgery, etc. than to continue in pathology.
Your field is entirely disrespected and undervalued relative to the worth of your work. You're not professionals, you're commodities; necessary, important, but not rare enough to command any value. Interchangeable parts. Widgets.
It seems no medical students should ever entertain pathology as a career choice.
I think your field is soon dead. The slack will be picked up by PhDs, radiologists and other physicians.
By soon, I hope you don't mean within the next 40 years. I plan on having to work until I am 75.
Nah bro. Ten years tops.
First of all, I would just like to say that threads like this are seriously depressing. What ever happened to positive thinking and taking initiative?
Secondly, I wish that everyone would stop complaining online/dwelling on the negatives and instead, go out and DO SOMETHING about it. Get on the horn to our advocates. Let them know how you feel. CAP, ASCP, Representatives, Senators...any (or all) and let them know what is happening. Construct the thoughts that you are expressing on this forum into a coherent argument and explain the crisis to our advocates. Take charge to make change for the better.
When stuff gets hard, you should just flee? I don't think so. Together we can make a difference. I love pathology too much to just "flee" when things get tough.
Anything in life worth having doesn't come easy folks. It is time to take a stand, not run away.
Well, I think autopsy is safe as well.
Although - what is the salary for pathologists at these mega labs? Is it terrible?
at my retirement i make/made $400k with bonus potential and a $15000 retirement match into qual and deferal retirement accounts.
I wouldn't call your situation a "mega lab" though.
Pathology has some life left in it, ten years may be overly pessimistic. But 30 years out, yeah there is a serious "Gates of Tartarus" situation out on the horizon.
Since this forum is anonymous, I would challenge all the 'Doom and Gloom' pathology attendings (Thrombus, LADoc et al) to provide some information about themselves. Specifically, what are you guys actually earning and how much has your salary decreased over time. I'm guessing that there isn't a single attending in private practice on this forum earning less than $200k and probably most are earning considerably more. Therefore, when you guys tell us that the 'sky is falling' people have to understand the context. DaSein77 had it right, pathology still offers the chance at a very comfortable living and for people who get into top residency/fellowship programs and network it still offers the chance of a very lucrative living ($500k/yr salary).
Yah the bottom seems to have fallen out of Hemepath in such dramatic fashion that if I had seen the future some 13-14 years ago pre-Flow professional component reduction and now this, I would have taken that job for 175K with Bain out in NYC and rolled the bones in finance.
The thing that scares me is what the hell will happen with Hemepath? What if TC providers wake up and realize they are losing money on all this and just fold?
Who the hell will provide these services??
One other thing to notice in the report, nearly 40% of path residents have NO student loans. At least the low-level-pay academic jobs will have a steady stream of debt-free FMGs to keep the wheels turning.
For the benefit of junior people who must read these boards with terror and depression in their hearts, here are my two cents. These comments are not aimed at anyone in particular, by the way.
As with all things on the internet, one must consider the source and take everything with a grain (or handful) of salt. Many of the posters on this forum seem very knowledgeable and offer good insight into both the scientific and business sides of pathology. Yet there is also an ENORMOUS amount of negativity here, and some of it may be overblown. Don't get me wrong: much of this negativity is likely related to problematic issues that are truly happening out there in the real world and that are directly impacting the lives of these negative posters in a serious way. That doesn't mean, though, that an individual person's situation (or contentment and happiness with their situation) can be generalized to all members of our entire specialty. It also doesn't mean that every comment or anecdote on this forum is necessarily 1) completely true, 2) without exaggeration, or 3) without bias. I know when I am upset or frustrated I have a tendency to put a negative spin on things, and I wonder if that might possibly happen on this forum occasionally.
Certainly pathology faces some very difficult problems in the coming years, many of which I personally have little exposure to due to my position as a junior academic pathologist (since I post under my real name, anyone can verify where I work and can make judgements about my probable level of expertise or lack thereof on any of these topics). Admittedly, I am an optimist, I have no real personal experience with the challenges of private practice, and I am currently happily employed. So keep in mind that my comments come with that bias attached. But I am happy I chose pathology, happy with my current job, happy with my salary, and happy with my future prospects in our field. Maybe I have it all wrong and will be weeping in a few years. But I'm not weeping today.
If things are so bad in the diagnostic path world, why aren't there more people training and working in the few areas in path that are non-competitive and with decent job markets? Forensic and blood banking come to mind, but there's probably a few others.
I dunno.. When I was interviewing for residency, every interview day it seemed like there was at least one other person interviewing who voiced interest in forensics. That changes for a lot of those people -during- residency, in no small part because most attendings are bitter and not all that knowledgeable about doing them, and tend to have little or no financial motivation for doing them (it may actually cost them), so the cycle continues. It may even mean a few of those folks got put on the "eh" list in part because they were "too" interested in just forensics -- I can't say that doesn't happen. I don't know what the numbers are for applicants and what got them started, though that would be interesting to see. But I suspect the problem of medical schools failing to provide any instruction or exposure to real-world pathology means at least a few folks start looking at it because of the focus on forensics in popular media.
Forensics has to have the worst risk vs. reward equation of anything in all of medicine. The lifestyle is horrible. The pay is among the worst, often lower than the high school grad deputies that surround you and often boss you around like you are poodle on a short leash.
Its horrendous. Constantine's version of hell has nothing on the life of an actual forensic pathologist in modern America. Almost every forensics section is filled with IMGs and if its not IMGs, they have a "consultant" FP who spends little to zero time actually in the department so he/she can remain sane.
I would rather be a grunt in the Army tbh. If people are picking actual careers on the media's fantastical vision of something they are in for one hell of a sad reality down the road.
As I have said before: FORENSICS HAS NO BUSINESS BEING PART OF PATHOLOGY. make it a 2-year masters degree. make it a trade school thing. Get it the hell out of Pathology. There is no connection between Anatomic Pathology, Lab Medicine and actual day to day Forensics. Get it out and get it out now.
As a community college degree or a masters of science or something, the pay these sad folks get will actually start to make sense.
I do 50 forensic cases a year, make 150K, and spend most of my day planning lunch. Don't waste too much time feeling sorry for us.
Reading this thread really scared me as I was thinking about a pathology residency and then doing a medical microbiology fellowship....
If you are willing and committed to work in 'academia' or for a governmental agency (such as the CDC) will it still be that hard to get a job?
What the heck are you eating that it takes you most of the day to plan it? You know there's porn out there to be watched, right?
This is all part of the war on the entrepreneur and the individual. There is only so much cronyism and heavy handed regulation a business can take. sad day in America. The incentive to achieve and stand on ones own feet is being destroyed by those with a lust for power.I don't know anyone "fleeing" pathology. Our lab has, however, seen quite a remarkable uptick in physician retirements and office closures for private practice internists, family practitioners, and surgeons. Not entirely sure what the specific reasons are for each, no doubt some were ready to retire anyway, some are worried about reimbursement and new administrative requirements. But I think this month I have seen more emails from our client reps about "so and so is closing their office etc" than I have in the past 2 years combined.
What I would say is that people are not "fleeing" the practice of medicine in any field. But many do seem to be "fleeing" the pure private practitioner (particularly solo practitioner) environment. Docs are merging with larger physician groups or hospitals. The trend is perhaps even more pronounced in other fields than pathology.
Yeah, but Rural, you're watching porn because you're single.
http://forums.studentdoctor.net/threads/urrrrgh-single.1034968/page-10#post-14649679