At least we can all agree that benzos are problematic
I looked briefly at Saybrook, saw that it was crazy expensive and online (or mostly online) and moved on. I do believe there are some very intelligent and interesting professors there, now and (especially) historically, but those two facts alone make it completely not worth it imo, not counting any other issues in training, poor administration, etc.
I'm in my first year at West Georgia (with a grad assistantship so not paying anything) and couldn't be happier. If humanistic is your thing, I'd recommend UWG or Duquesne or Fordham (although I hear their humanistic stuff is being phased out--we just had one of their head humanistic faculty interview for a position here). There's a couple others too--not sure how humanistic York is, but I believe it has a pretty theoretical/philosophical program, although I think I heard something about it possibly being phased out as well? Don't quote me on that.
As much as I hate to admit it, unless you're REALLY interested in a humanities/philosophy based approach to psychology, I'd probably recommend a more normative program. Maybe one that has a humanistic person or two, like someone mentioned above (Fred Wertz is still at Fordham, at least for now). UWG is decent if you just want to get your LPC (and manage to get an assistantship, which is a limited commodity...although to be fair in-state tuition isn't bad here at all, relatively speaking). We do clinical practicums (off-site) and have some good supervision. Duquesne is solid but decently competitive. I'm doing a thesis and hoping to either get into Duquesne, Rutgers PsyD, or a handful of other places. We'll see. I have some friends who've done this; it's possible, but not for everyone.
One option I forgot to mention is Point Park, they're a bunch of Duquesne alum, nice and smart fellas, with a Masters in Community/Clinical Psychology. They might be branching out into a PsyD in the future, but that's just a rumor I heard. I think it's a pretty affordable school, not sure what the assistantship scene looks like there.