I honestly think that going 4 years instead of 3 for a traditional student helps them to be more prepared for vet school.
And on the Australian topic- Kids in Australia do not just pop right into vet school correct? They still have to do the classes like chem, orgo, biochem, physics etc. And people who are accepted into the program out of high school have the top testing scores in the country. They are all super smart. I know that if I lived in Australia I would be rejected from the vet program because I would not be considered smart enough.
So you have super smart Australians mixed with Americans with degrees (who have probably taken more classes to prepare them). I would guess that the ratio for gpas etc would be mixed because they are all on the same level. I think thats how it works but feel free to correct me if I am wrong.
Actually, we do pop straight out of highschool and in to vet school. I am one of those kids. We take a few extra classes in vet school (such as nutrition and micro, that i dont think all US vet schools do), but the biggest difference is that our high schooling standards are much higher than that in the US. Yeah, you do have to be "super smart" - but you also need to be "super smart" to make it into vet school in the US - the difference is that the kids that got in straight out of high school did the "hard yards" sooner. I am intelligent - but certainly not the smartest person I know - I just worked super, super hard in highschool to get into vet school. And I'm sure there are many americans just like me, smart, but not that smart, working their butts off in college to get into vet school in the US. I dont think its fair to say that the Australian students in my class are smarter than the US students - not at all!!! I just think its a good example of how much undergrad work you actually DONT nessercerrily need. Therefore I dont think that an extra year is going to make that much of a difference - especially since it saves a lot of people a lot of money.
That's relative... this has been the hardest, most trying year of my life and by far the most difficult things I've ever and probably will ever face. I have made it through the year, and things have definitely gotten easier to manage, but not without a lot of blood, sweat and tears and serious questioning of why I decided to go into this. But it is important to remember that you can do it, and they wouldn't have picked you if you weren't capable of handling the experience.
This is what I meant. I didn't mean for a second that vet school is not super hard. I mean, honestly, I am freaking out right now... I have never felt so stupid in my life and I once showed up drunk to my boyfriends house crying, because "I dont study enough and so I'm going to be a bad vet..." Clinical path is kicking my ass but at the same time sometimes you need a bit of perspective - you really wouldnt get in if you werent good enough to do it.
I think that people who are depressed in vet school are depressed because its super hard. Its overwhelming and they were not prepared for it or they could not adjust. I think most vet students get depressed from time to time but its nothing new to a student who has gone through the 4 years of college.
Taking upper division courses are an important part to prepare you for school.
People who decided to peruse other interests... now that was completely avoidable. The way our system is set up you need hundreds of hours of shadowing. Most people know what they are getting into and what the vet profession is about. Thats why vets advocate shadowing in several different areas as well.
With family illness- I know many schools will let you re-do that year if you have a good reason such as this. In many cases it should not deter you from not getting a DVM.
So all of these things you have some control over. And if its out of your control they will let you redo the year in many schools.
Sorry, I should have clarified. The majority of people who have left my year are now in the year below me - only about 2 have left vet all together. And I think you would find its the same with US schools. There is a very, very low rate of ACTUAL drop out from all vet schools, and I feel this gives more weight to the arguement that its coincidence. People who struggle, for whatever reason, tend to come back and do it over again. People who leave all together, tend to have had something huge and life-changing happen to them.
Re: depression - I'm going to go out on a limb and say that almost every vet student will suffer some form or strength of depression at some point in their degree. I personally feel it matters not whether they have 3 years of college or 4. Not only that, but depression is a hugely multimodal disease which very rarely has one cause. People get homesick, relationships break down, there are financial difficulties, other normal life stuff PLUS you are dealing with a huge overwhelming degree - the best prevention for depression is a good support network, eating well, exercising regularly, and a firm grasp on the bigger picture. I wish more vet schools would do more to help their students with depression. And honestly, the workload is new to everyone.