- Joined
- Oct 11, 2008
- Messages
- 972
- Reaction score
- 76
I love this thread @_@
I'm saving everything that is written in this thread in a pdf file so who knows. Maybe I'll polish it up and publish it
Sorry to be a downer here, but is the current state of the economy affecting your decision of which practice to buy, if you buy at all? There are many analysts predicting a "double-dip recession" and/or the Greater Depression. Just wondering what your thoughts are.
Noooooooo! This thread is slipping. So, BUMP!
And, after the explanation behind this is complete, I nominate this for a sticky. I just hope that like most things on the internet, it doesn't disappear; half complete and forgotten.
The Hammer: Great post, and I'm looking forward to the answers. The suspense is killing me. I need that instant gratification!
Sorry I haven't been as vigil on this thread this weekend. In addition to putting my professional life back in order I have been putting my love life back in order as well so I took a mini vacation this weekend. But I should be back answering questions tonight.
I nominate this for a sticky.
The recession isn't affecting what type of practice I'm buying. Once I go through all of the practices you'll understand why. Here is the secret about dental offices and the economy. The economy won't necessarily effect how much work you do as much as it will effect what type of dentistry you do. When the economy when to **** a couple of years ago. I did fewer "smile makeovers" and much more fixed and removable prosth. The trick is to be flexible enough to change as the situation dictates.Sorry to be a downer here, but is the current state of the economy affecting your decision of which practice to buy, if you buy at all? There are many analysts predicting a "double-dip recession" and/or the Greater Depression. Just wondering what your thoughts are.
BTW, according to an article titled "21 Most Recession & Depression Proof Jobs" Dentist was ranked #3 citing,
Dentist: Dental hygiene is very important to Americans. We like our choppers straight and pearly. This is a safe bet, even when moneys tight. While people may not have as much to spend on expensive braces, data from Bureau of Labor Statistics shows that dental offices did increase as much as 2 - 4% during previous economic recessions in 1990, 2001 & 2007. Recession also means people will be eating cheap, rather than healthy. This takes a major toll on the teeth, but creates business for you. Remember, no matter how much people hate dentists, they hate toothaches more.
Still, I can't help but wonder.
The recession isn't affecting what type of practice I'm buying. Once I go through all of the practices you'll understand why. Here is the secret about dental offices and the economy. The economy won't necessarily effect how much work you do as much as it will effect what type of dentistry you do. When the economy when to **** a couple of years ago. I did fewer "smile makeovers" and much more fixed and removable prosth. The trick is to be flexible enough to change as the situation dictates.
Associateships
So what should you be paid? A reasonable amount is 20-25% of your collections minus lab. But if you are being paid a percentage of collections you need to be doing the kind of work that will pay you. If you are doing mostly Medicare then 25% of your collections will be crappy. If you are doing mostly medicare then you should ask for a guaranteed monthly salary and if your 25% of collections exceeds this then you get paid the difference. This is a good idea for several reasons:
.....
I think ....
collections = money taken in/total money billed to patients
(some people don't pay their bills)(might also apply to insurance too)
total income/total billed to patients *100= collections percentage (%)
lab - the amount of money that is paid to a private lab to prepare crowns, inlays, onlays, etc.
Exactly. Another way to definite it is this:
Gross: This is the total amount of production that a dental office does. It is the total of all procedures done. Sometimes this is also just simply called "Production"
Collections: This is how much money is actually collected. Because some people might not pay or you are taking a reduced fee insurance collections are usually a percentage of production. Also since some fees are billed to insurance and you have to wait a month or so to collect your production for a given month will be different than your collections. Here is an example. Let say as an associate you produce $40,000 of dentistry for the month of July. But you are still having money come in from procedures that you did the previous three months so your collections for the month of July might be $35,000. So as an associate you would get say 25% of that $35,000 minus your lab bill for the month of July.
You lab bill is just how much you owe your lab for any crowns, dentures etc that they fabricate for you. So to return to the above example in July you collected $35,000, your lab bill was $3000 so your collections are now $32,000. So you will be paid 25% (or whatever % that you agreed upon) of the $32,000.
Again, this is a awesome thread.
What's your take on chain offices? i.e. Kool Smiles, Small Smiles, Gentle Dental, etc.
One of the above recently offered me a contract at a brand new office, another dentist and I will be running the mill:
1. Guarantee $500 minimum, or 22% collection, whichever is higher.
2. It's a full medicaid office.
3. They estimate employee monthly gross billing to be $72k, and from this they would collect 98.5%, 22% of that collection ($14k a month) goes to the associates pocket. Question is, is this actually doable? will I be working like a robot or a human being?
corp FTW, don't want your personal assets to get seized if you get sued.
That offer was from Small Smiles. I had another offer from a different location, 22% production with 10k sign-on bonus. Everyone I spoke with tells me to run for the hills regardless of the offer.Which is it...Kool Smiles or Small Smiles?
What is a typical % for collection of production in a dental practice?
the 35K would include collection from julys 40k gross/production? also, how does an associate verify the collections amount is accurate?
what we just learned: cadillacs are in fact shiney overpriced traps.
If I screw up my math again. please correct it for meSo the loan will be $904,000 at 7% for 7 years. This breaks down to a monthly note of $11,515.24
to expect a 25% drop in production when a new dentist buys a practice.
You can not do those kind of numbers with single tooth dentistry.
I looked at his fee schedule and he is actually charging less than I was for his crowns and other restorations so where is all the money coming from? It is coming from here
Do future ex-owners ever suggest giving some training in the procedures they've been performing extensively?1.He places his own implants. 2. He is doing a lot of ortho both conventional and Invisalign.
Did he, or owners of other dental offices, let you see how they work on daily basis or is it sth you had to figure out based on external info?3. He uses very aggressive high pressure sales techniques to get case acceptance
Have you seen the deals he has with these media companies? Would you care to negotiate those?4. He also has a high profile marketing campaign in radio, TV , billboard and print.
Great breakdown, hammer.
Since you've been in that area for a while, you know it (and the doctors) pretty well.
For someone who is moving and planning to buy straight out, would you recommend associating for a year to know the area/market better?
If not, how else would you be able to tell how he's coming up w/ the large gross (e.g. your points 1-5)?
Associating for a year is a good idea. It makes for a better transition and it gives you time to make sure that the practice you are buying is exactly what it was presented as being
what do practicing dentists think of dentists having done a a year long GPR after graduating? are you more willing to hire them and or pay them more?
So this is why I called this practice the Cadillac. It's big, flashy, expensive and impressive but is it really worth the extra expense?
So let's discuss this practice and then I'll move on to practice 3
I'm not sure how you got that number, same for practice #1.
I use this function in excel:
"=PMT(7%/12;7*12;PRICE)*-1"
which gives -13,640 monthly, that's a ca. 15% difference. I also double checked with some loan calculators. Correct me if I'm mistaken.
Good catch. I went back and saw that I was just using a standard % calculator. I went back and changed my numbers
expect a 25% drop in production when a new dentist buys a practice.
That's going to hurt, in case of this practice - a lot.
Yep. That is quite a dip
You can not do those kind of numbers with single tooth dentistry.
I haven't come across that expression yet. If it means what I think it means - its literal meaning - then I must ask how come. Does it come down to less efficient appointments, i.e. when you schedule 30mins and do only 1 filling? I really don't get it as I don't think of procedures limited to one tooth as sth to be perceived as less profitable (as that would include everything besides dentures, bridges, some surgeries and ortho).
Yes single tooth dentistry takes more time and uses more supplies so it is more expensive and less efficient. Think about it this way, I can do 10 crowns on one patient in about 3 hours start to finish. To do 10 crowns on 10 patients however will take me about 8 hours. Why? The operatory has to be set up and cleaned up 10 times, once for each patient. You have to numb 10 times and wait while the 10 patients each go numb. You will use more than twice the anesthetic, 10 times the amount of impression material and 10 times the number of cotton rolls, burs, suction tips etc.
But the biggest problem is just the time that it takes to see 10 patients over just seeing one or two patients and doing the same amount of dentistry. One time I had a week where I saw 2 patients on Monday and did 18 crowns that day. Tuesday through Friday I saw 3 crown patients a day and only did a total of 14 crowns because these patients only needed one or two teeth crowned. Single tooth dentistry is a time killer and what kills time also kills your productivity and profitability.
I looked at his fee schedule and he is actually charging less than I was for his crowns and other restorations so where is all the money coming from? It is coming from here
How deep can you run your due diligence? Does it go as deep as in other businesses? Are there any areas where you might be tricked or the books somehow cooked?
With dental practice software it is harder to "cook the books" and get away with it, especially if you compare it to the selling dentist's tax returns. What you have to look for is to make sure that they have given you an accurate number on active patients (you can check their recall numbers in the computer for this), an accurate percentage of makeup of insurance/cash/medicaid patients in their office (once again check their daily production records against their EOBs and yearly insurance W2's for this).
If you are really obsessive like me you will also go over their lab bills and the number and type of procedures they were billed for, their supply records and also go over their appointment books to see how many hours and days they worked and the number of no-shows and cancellations that they had.
Do future ex-owners ever suggest giving some training in the procedures they've been performing extensively?
Usually not. Especially when you consider the time, skill and diligence that it takes to successfully do implants and ortho. Those are skills that you can really learn while you earn. This doctor slowly integrated these procedures into the practice until they became a major part of it. It would be next to impossible for you to learn these skills and to perform them at the level that the dentist is currently as soon as you buy the practice
Did he, or owners of other dental offices, let you see how they work on daily basis or is it sth you had to figure out based on external info?
In this case does he have a bad reputation going around? Do his former patients resent him?
So as not to get myself in trouble instead of answering this question I am going to tell you a totally fictitious science fiction story that I just made up.
Molar Wars: A New Hope
A long time ago in a galaxy far far away a robot named Hammertron 3000 was looking at buying a space station owned by Darth Molar. Hammertron took his bionic sidekick MacBookPro-tron 3000 and used the Force to run a background check on Darth Molar, to see what other parts of the galaxy Darth Molar might have had a space station in and what kind of trouble he might have run into. Hammertron also sent out his private Jed-eyes knights to talk to people who had been on Darth Molar's space station and even sent one of the Jed-eye knights into the space station to get a first hand report.
Once Hammertron got all of the information back on Darth Molar, he decided to look elsewhere in the galaxy for princesses with hair that looks like cinnabuns.
The End
Have you seen the deals he has with these media companies? Would you care to negotiate those?
What do you mean? I believe that Hammer taught at that school. While his thread didn't imply that he was inquiring about the school as a potential instructor, I'm sure that's what he was doing.
I accepted a job as a clinical instructor there in October 2009. I just wanted to hear from students what they thought about the school without identifying myself as an instructor so I could hopefully get some honest opinions.
Between accepting the position in October and moving to AZ from TN on December 26th my wife left me (on December 13th actually). So I started my new job on Jan 4th and at the same time was trying to manage a divorce that was happening 1800 miles away via text and email. It's not as easy as it sounds.
By February I realized that I was killing myself and something had to give so I resigned from Midwestern and finished the divorce. Once it was finalized in the middle of March I started thinking about what I wanted to do, teach or go back into private practice. I interviewed at UF's dental school in Gainesville.
As much as I loved the students I have to say that I'm a little to "free spirited" to tow the faculty line. Then I drove a brand new bright red turbo 911 at a Scottsdale dealership and I realized that I really missed private practice so here I am.
what we just learned: cadillacs are in fact shiney overpriced traps.
BTW it would be real nice if you were here to help me w/ a 4 unit mand implant supported overdenture case that i'm about to get crackin in our new clinic! hahaha
I accepted a job as a clinical instructor there in October 2009. I just wanted to hear from students what they thought about the school without identifying myself as an instructor so I could hopefully get some honest opinions.
Between accepting the position in October and moving to AZ from TN on December 26th my wife left me (on December 13th actually). So I started my new job on Jan 4th and at the same time was trying to manage a divorce that was happening 1800 miles away via text and email. It's not as easy as it sounds.
By February I realized that I was killing myself and something had to give so I resigned from Midwestern and finished the divorce. Once it was finalized in the middle of March I started thinking about what I wanted to do, teach or go back into private practice. I interviewed at UF's dental school in Gainesville.
As much as I loved the students I have to say that I'm a little to "free spirited" to tow the faculty line. Then I drove a brand new bright red turbo 911 at a Scottsdale dealership and I realized that I really missed private practice so here I am.
lol, it seems like there was a shiney expensive trap and another shiney trap among the 4 practices!
So this trap would be the Cadillac Escalade, and the other would be the GMC Yukon right?
Sorry if I am looking back into the Sure thing practice still, but I was wondering after you took the gross and minused the 65% overhead, you were left with 17,000. A couple posts down you talk about having 11,000 to service student debt when replying to someone's post, what did that 6,000 pay for? The loan you took out for buying the practice? My bad for going back to the 1st practice guys I just caught up on the reading
Right, the GMC wouldn't be shiny though.