- Joined
- Nov 24, 2007
- Messages
- 8,318
- Reaction score
- 9,307
One can be comfortably in that zone in academia, so you might want to consider alternate employers.
What area are you located in and what type of practice?
I go to a state school and have a 50% tuition scholarship and still with random fees etc (since scholarship is only tuition), my loans will amount to over $200k. I come from a low-income family and both my parents need help from me instead of the other way around. The cost of med school has gone up a lot since I started, and the elimination of subsidized loans in my 2nd year means that I've been paying interest on everything the entire time. It's not ideal.
A friend of mine got permission to work outside of school during M1 and M2, she lived at home and used her entire check to pay loan interest, and at the end of the first year she stopped paying, because it was nowhere near enough to cover the interest she had accrued that year and she was depressed that she'd lived like a pauper and paid pretty much nothing back.
Also, I go to a school that prides itself on working with underserved populations and enrolling a diverse class, still over 80% of my entering class came from a family making over $250k (info from an administrator), and I know of several who pay cash each semester. One day I'll pay off my loans so I can invest in my children's college and accrue more loans. The thought of PSLF and blatant denial are the only things keeping me going right now.
I go to a state school and have a 50% tuition scholarship and still with random fees etc (since scholarship is only tuition), my loans will amount to over $200k. I come from a low-income family and both my parents need help from me instead of the other way around. The cost of med school has gone up a lot since I started, and the elimination of subsidized loans in my 2nd year means that I've been paying interest on everything the entire time. It's not ideal.
A friend of mine got permission to work outside of school during M1 and M2, she lived at home and used her entire check to pay loan interest, and at the end of the first year she stopped paying, because it was nowhere near enough to cover the interest she had accrued that year and she was depressed that she'd lived like a pauper and paid pretty much nothing back.
Also, I go to a school that prides itself on working with underserved populations and enrolling a diverse class, still over 80% of my entering class came from a family making over $250k (info from an administrator), and I know of several who pay cash each semester. One day I'll pay off my loans so I can invest in my children's college and accrue more loans. The thought of PSLF and blatant denial are the only things keeping me going right now.
what 250k?? i believe the national average is ~120k family income for medical students.
I highly doubt that knowing the number of my classmates and other colleagues that have doctor/lawyer/businessman parents.
this was published somewhere. i dont remember where though (AAMC?). either way im significantly below that
this was published somewhere. i dont remember where though (AAMC?). either way im significantly below that
I can't speak for every school, and honestly, I don't know the stats for any other class at my current school. As Court said, most students in my class are children of physicians, and that alone will likely put your salary to over 200k, many have parents who are both physicians, others parents who are lawyers and engineers. Those whose parents consist of a mechanic and housewife (like mine) are in the minority.
There are a handful of students at my school (private) that will be in the $400,000-$500,000 debt range from undergrad loans + master's loans + med school loans.
Most are going into primary care. They tell me that money isn't an issue, and that PSLF will pay for it in 10 years. LMAO
I feel your pain bro... and I'm at a public university.Just to chip in my 2 cents... Got my financial aid statement for 3rd year at Tufts: 91,400 is tuition + COL for that year, where the school will NOT be teaching me anything, but rather attendings (patients/insurance pays them) and residents (medicare pays them) will.... Not sure where my $59,000 tuition bill is going...
The other day I saw someone with 450k principal which would be 600k at graduation. That was determined to be the breaking point w here medicine truly wasn't financially a sound decision.
well, in the end it seemed like it would be around 84k a year for 10 years after residency, which means if you make 200k you live a very middle-class lifestyle for a long time (taxes may be around 40% with state, so 120-84 is only 36 lol). 250k is a bit better but not amazing (something like 65k until you're 40). Sure, if you match into neurosurgery life is good, but no one can just "assume" they'll match into some crazy specialty. So you have to assume the possibility of making 200k in IM or something.Why this particular number?
well, in the end it seemed like it would be around 84k a year for 10 years after residency, which means if you make 200k you live a very middle-class lifestyle for a long time (taxes may be around 40% with state, so 120-84 is only 36 lol). 250k is a bit better but not amazing (something like 65k until you're 40). Sure, if you match into neurosurgery life is good, but no one can just "assume" they'll match into some crazy specialty. So you have to assume the possibility of making 200k in IM or something.
People in general are often starting medical school later. I see some people starting when they're like 28 or something, and even if they get some scholarships that's 6 years of practice that's gone. Crazy. But 60% of incoming students are "non-trad" and that number is only rising as it increasingly expected that people take time to do research before matriculation (and after medical school sometimes to get that residency app boost).
I think at this point I would seriously discourage people that are 30 and up from pursuing medicine just because financially it's a bit crazy. Typical 10 year plan might mean they're paying their debts off until they're 50.
BUT.
All that being said the job market sucks in general, and law, vet, opt, pharm, all suck too. If your debt load is more like 300k and you make 250k then the numbers are far more palatable...but we're approaching the 600k debt load every year, and in 10 years I think that it will just not be realistic.
EDIT: thread in question: http://forums.studentdoctor.net/thr...y-acceptance-too-much-in-loans.1132398/page-2
You wouldn't pay that much in tax. The U.S. has a progressive tax system.well, in the end it seemed like it would be around 84k a year for 10 years after residency, which means if you make 200k you live a very middle-class lifestyle for a long time (taxes may be around 40% with state, so 120-84 is only 36 lol). 250k is a bit better but not amazing (something like 65k until you're 40). Sure, if you match into neurosurgery life is good, but no one can just "assume" they'll match into some crazy specialty. So you have to assume the possibility of making 200k in IM or something.
EDIT: thread in question: http://forums.studentdoctor.net/thr...y-acceptance-too-much-in-loans.1132398/page-2
He'll do great ... IF he can stay employed continuously until retirement.CS is where its at. There are so many jobs. All my Cs friends are making 100k plus now 1-4 Yrs after graduating. Many companies offer around 100k as starting. I was speaking to one of my friends who just started working making 105k. A basic calculation shows that he will have farrrrr more for retirement due to compounding and that'd assuming his salary stays at 105k forever w no raises.
I get 122k for 200k as a single doc in California. According to paycheckcity.com. Californian is like 1/6 the population and also has a disproportionate amount of doctors so it's reasonable to use it as an example imo. You can live in Floridia for no income tax but as of right now I think only 7 states don't have income tax.You wouldn't pay that much in tax. The U.S. has a progressive tax system.
He'll do great ... IF he can stay employed continuously until retirement.
CS is a young person's career.
Staying current is a huge issue, far more so than medicine. Recessions hit that industry very hard. Age discrimination can be lethal if you need to make a late career move or are past 50 when coming out of a recession.
CS is where its at. There are so many jobs. All my Cs friends are making 100k plus now 1-4 Yrs after graduating. Many companies offer around 100k as starting. I was speaking to one of my friends who just started working making 105k. A basic calculation shows that he will have farrrrr more for retirement due to compounding and that'd assuming his salary stays at 105k forever w no raises.
People often forget that the debt isn't just a negative but its huge after factoring in compounding.
You're talking about anecdotal exceptions.I know a young person who got his PhD in Computer Science and was offered $255K starting salary. I seriously doubt that person's lifestyle will be WORSE than the Average Anesthesiologist working for an AMC.
Plenty of his friends received offers in the mid 150's with a Masters degree.
You're talking about anecdotal exceptions.
You could say the same thing about law school grads, and be technically correct. That doesn't make law a sure path to the good life for 90%+ of graduates.
$255K start for PhD CS guys is far, far from the norm.
Remember that the post above is starting pay. After 10 years the median is likely above $500,000 and the upper 1/4 exceeds 7 figures annually.
Remember that the post above is starting pay. After 10 years the median is likely above $500,000 and the upper 1/4 exceeds 7 figures annually.
So your solution is: "be brilliant and odds are things'll work out for you"If you graduate from a top 14 law school then law is still a good profession for over 90 percent of those graduates. If you graduate from a law school that isn't in the top 14 then all bets are off.
T14 Law schools only really take applicants with 170+ LSAT. Thats in the 99th percentile of those who take the exam. Its the equivalent of saying that only those who score 38 or higher on the MCAT have a chance of landing at a medical school that gives them a good chance at residency after medical school.
Those figures are only if you manage to grab an associate position at a big law firm no?
To get to the 500k range after 10 years one needs to make partner at those firms. Its very difficult to make partner at those firms and if you don't make it within 3 years (they used to give you 8) they boot you out of the firm and are forced to take a 40-50% pay cut to get another law job at a smaller firm.
Grass always look greener on the other side. @Law2Doc what do you think?
Blade, you have no idea what you are talking about with regards to law prospects. It is in the complete ****ter right now. T14 is not what it used to be and if you are not top quarter or maybe half of most of those classes your chances at biglaw are slim (does not apply to Harvard, Yale, Stanford). Biglaw in major markets (NYC, SF, DC) starts at 160k, 145k for secondary markets (Atlanta, Nashville). The vasy majority of T14 graduates are out of work or working jobs in the 45k-70k range after taking on 100k-200k of debt.
Here is the graph explaining the bimodal salary distribution of the law profession: http://www.nalp.org/class_of_2013_bimodal_salary_curve
Visit lawschooltransparency.com and see how fudged the stats you just naively posted really are. And the ceiling numbers you posted?? Good lord man. Maybe 1% of graduates hit that. You have to grind through years of partnership vetting dodging politics to even have a shot at that. Or get lucky with a successful personal injury firm.
The confidence in which you talk about things that you clearly have no knowledge about is very disconcerting considering how often you make generalizations/statements that I cannot verify.
T14 Law schools only really take applicants with 170+ LSAT. Thats in the 99th percentile of those who take the exam. Its the equivalent of saying that only those who score 38 or higher on the MCAT have a chance of landing at a medical school that gives them a good chance at residency after medical school.
Those figures are only if you manage to grab an associate position at a big law firm no?
To get to the 500k range after 10 years one needs to make partner at those firms. Its very difficult to make partner at those firms and if you don't make it within 3 years (they used to give you 8) they boot you out of the firm and are forced to take a 40-50% pay cut to get another law job at a smaller firm.
Grass always look greener on the other side. @Law2Doc what do you think?