About the ads

Milk doesn't do a body good?

Discussion in 'Topics in Healthcare' started by Mr. Adventure, Mar 15, 2006.

  1. SDN is a nonprofit organization. Services are made possible through the generous support of SDN members and sponsors. Thank you.
  1. Mr. Adventure

    Mr. Adventure Oat-Packing Dadaist

    Joined:
    Jul 14, 2005
    Messages:
    178
    Location:
    Getting a soapy...
    Status:
    Pre-Medical
    SDN 5+ Year Member

    SDN Members don't see this ad. (About Ads)
    Is the "milk" campaign a sinister plot to cause osteoporsis? This article goes against everything I've learned about the value of animal protein in a weight training regimen...maybe it's time to switch to soy or hemp protein...

    Boning Up On Osteoporosis
    REPRINTED FROM BEYOND HEALTH® News

    by Raymond Francis

    Osteoporosis is a man-made disease that should never happen. In short, it's entirely preventable and treatable, but look at what's happening. The United States has one of the highest osteoporosis rates in the world. Osteoporosis kills more women every year than cancer of the breast, cervix, and uterus combined. Twenty-five million Americans have been diagnosed with osteoporosis, and it has been estimated that nine out of ten Americans have bone densities that are less than optimal. Even young, professional athletes have their careers cut short by osteoporosis. It doesn't have to be this way!

    Osteoporosis literally means "porous bones." Bones lose mass, weaken, and become susceptible to fracture. This disease is a widespread, silent, symptomless condition, affecting both men and women, with potentially devastating consequences.

    Americans suffer more than 1.5 million fractures every year from osteoporosis. Over 280,000 of those are hip fractures. Twenty five percent of these people will never walk again unassisted, 25% will end up in nursing homes, and 25% will die within three months of conditions related to the fracture, as did the late Eva Gabor. Like all other chronic degenerative diseases, osteoporosis is extremely rare among native populations that eat traditional plant-based diets.

    If for some weird reason you want to get osteoporosis, anyone can do it if they are willing to invest a lot of time and money. Osteoporosis doesn't come cheaply or quickly. You have to purchase expensive ingredients, like meat, dairy, and soft drinks, and have the patience to stick with the program. It's not easy to make a human being sick.

    Bone is a living tissue. It grows, it mends, and it renews itself throughout life. As old bone is reabsorbed and new bone formed, we replace about 20% of our bone mass every year. Normally we lose some bone mass as we grow older, but if we build strong bones in our youth, the losses won't matter. Osteoporosis happens when this loss is accelerated, and too much bone is lost or too little new bone is formed. To accelerate bone loss, here's how to do it:

    Eat a diet that is high in meat, dairy, sugar, salt, phosphorous, and caffeine, and low in fresh vegetables and whole grains. Then don't get a lot of exercise. In other words, do what most people do.

    Let's look at some of the things that cause bone loss. Meat causes bone loss. Americans eat far too much protein, and about 70% of our protein is from animal sources. We consume about 100 grams/day which is much more than what we need. Healthy populations eat 20-42 grams/day, and less than 10% of that is animal protein. The rest is plant protein, which is fundamentally different. Animal protein metabolizes in our bodies to strong acids, namely sulfuric and phosphoric acids. To neutralize these acids, our bodies use up calcium from our bones. If fact, if you eat a diet high in animal protein it doesn't matter how much calcium you consume, you will still lose bone mass. Alaskan Eskimos have the highest osteoporosis rate in the world because they eat twice as much protein as we do, and it's all animal protein. They also consume more than twice as much calcium as we do, but it doesn't help. The excessive protein is the key.

    Dairy is another contributor to bone loss. Americans are only 4% of the world's population, but we consume more dairy than the other 96% put together. If milk were good for our bones, we would have the strongest bones in the world. Instead we have some of the weakest bones in the world. Cow milk has four times the calcium of human milk, yet we absorb more calcium from human milk. The calcium in cow milk is not bioavailable to us. In addition, cow milk is high in protein which strips the calcium out of our bones. Cow milk is also low in magnesium, which is necessary for using calcium. As a result of these and other factors, and contrary to popular belief, dairy promotes bone loss. Feeding milk to children can result in weaker bones later in life.

    Refined sugar also promotes bone loss. The average American consumes about 150 pounds of refined sugar per year, which is sufficient to do a lot of bone damage. Sugar is absorbed quickly and sharply increases our cellular glucose levels. Cellular glucose increases, but the oxygen in the cell doesn't increase and this causes incomplete oxidation of the sugar. Partial oxidation forms acids and the acids strip calcium from our bones. Sugar also causes losses of magnesium, which is necessary for bone formation.

    Salt contributes to bone loss. Americans eat an excessive amount of salt. Many people consume 8,000 to 10,000 mg of sodium per day. Our ancestors consumed about 700 mg per day. Every 2,000 mg of sodium consumed causes a loss of 23 mg of calcium in the urine. Unless these losses are replaced, an intake of 5,000 mg of sodium per day can cause a loss of 2.5% of your skeleton every year, which calculates to 25% lost in 10 years.

    Excessive phosphorous causes bone loss by reacting with the calcium to form an insoluble compound thus inhibiting absorption of calcium from the digestive system. Phosphorous also causes calcium losses from bone by metabolizing to phosphoric acid, which has to be neutralized with calcium. Excessive phosphorous is contained in animal protein and in soft drinks, especially colas, which have phosphoric acid added as an ingredient.

    Caffeine, smoking, excessive alcohol, steroids, and lack of exercise also contribute to bone loss. The sedentary lifestyle that most Americans lead increases the rate of both urinary and fecal calcium losses. Exercise, especially weight bearing exercise, will actually increase bone mass and reverse bone loss. A three-year study of older women at the University of Wisconsin showed that a control group of sedentary women lost 3% of bone density while the exercise group gained 2%.

    Bone loss is one mechanism for osteoporosis. Another is insufficient formation of new bone. Shortages of critical vitamins and minerals will inhibit this process.

    Calcium is the central ingredient. Americans get an average of 1,143 mg/day. The recommended amount is 1,000-1,500 mg/day. However, our healthy ancestors consumed only 300-600 mg/day. The problem is Americans lose an average of 320 mg/day in the urine. Because of our bad diets, we actually lose more calcium than some of our healthy ancestors were eating. Calcium absorption is only 20-40% efficient and requires an acidic environment which many of our older people lack. If you lose 320 mg/day and absorb at the 20% rate, you will need 1,600 mg/day just to keep up with your losses. Our average intake of 1,143 mg/day is insufficient. Obviously, the thing to do is cut the losses and increase the consumption of bioavailable calcium. The best sources of calcium are green vegetables like broccoli, chard, and kale, and whole grains and beans.

    It is impossible to build bone without magnesium. Magnesium is necessary for numerous bone-related reactions including the conversion of vitamin D to its bioactive form, which is necessary for calcium absorption. Several studies have shown that about 80% of the American population get only two-thirds of the RDA of magnesium. On top of that, the RDA is known to be too low.

    Vitamin D is the main regulator of intestinal calcium absorption. A lot of older people don't get enough vitamin D because they tend to stay out of the sun. Vitamin D must be converted to its bioactive form and this requires both magnesium and boron.

    Manganese is required for bone mineralization and for synthesis of the organic matrix on which calcification takes place. A study reported in Science News found that osteoporotic women had serum manganese levels of only 25% that of the controls.

    Folic acid is part of the osteoporosis puzzle, yet the typical diet contains only half the RDA for folic acid. Vitamin K is also essential. A study in Clinical Endocrinology found that vitamin K supplementation reduced urinary calcium losses in osteoporosis patients by 18 to 50%. Zinc is also an essential player, but a survey in the Journal of the American Dietary Association found that 68% of adults consume less than two-thirds of the RDA for zinc.

    Vitamin B6, vitamin C, strontium, silicon, and other nutrients also play important roles. As you can see, calcium metabolism is very complex and requires adequate amounts of many nutrients. To prevent and successtoreully treat osteoporosis you first have to reduce calcium losses. This means cutting down on meat and dairy. Keep your protein intake to 1.5 to 2 ounces a day, and less than 10% of that should be animal protein. Drastically reduce your intake of sugar, salt, phosphorous, and caffeine. Secondly, you have to consume the right amounts of nutrients that support formation of new bone such as calcium, magnesium, manganese, boron, vitamin D, and so forth.

    The best way to accomplish all this is to eat a plant-based diet consisting of a variety of fresh, unprocessed, organic vegetables, whole grains, and beans. Take high quality nutritional supplements, like Perque 2 and Perque Bone Guard, which contain the essential bone forming nutrients. Get regular exercise, including essential weight bearing exercise. Osteoporosis is a disease that modern diets and lifestyles have created. No one has to have this problem.

    Raymond Francis is an M.I.T.-trained scientist, a registered nutrition consultant, author of Never Be Sick Again, host of the Beyond Health Show and an internationally recognized leader in the emerging field of optimal health maintenance.
  2. t33sg1rl

    t33sg1rl Senior Member

    Joined:
    Sep 2, 2004
    Messages:
    350
    Location:
    Ohio
    SDN 5+ Year Member
    dude, remember to look at the source of information. Mr. Francis doesn't even have a college degree. He would also like to sell you his book on how to be healthy.

    Also, just pick any part of this lame argument and ponder it. Let's take his milk paragraph since you are concerned. For now we'll just pretend that all of his assumptions are true (which I doubt, but don't care to research)

    1. Americans eat more dairy than anybody else.
    2. Americans have more osteoporosis than anybody else.

    Now, to conclude that dairy causes osteoporosis is a logical error covered in most people's high school math classes (did Mr. Francis finish high school? I'm becoming concerned.) To create a connection between these statistics is idiotic. You might as well say that television causes osteoporosis, because we Americans probably watch more than anybody else.

    Anyway, here's the final word on how to stay in good health, based on national health data:
    The Japanese eat very little fat and suffer fewer heart attacks than the British or Americans.
    Mexicans eat a lot of fat and also suffer fewer heart attacks than the British or Americans.
    The Japanese drink very little red wine and suffer fewer heart attacks than the British or Americans.
    The French drink excessive amounts of red wine and also suffer fewer heart attacks than the British or Americans.
    The Germans drink a lot of beer and eat lots of sausages and fats and suffer fewer heart attacks than the British or Americans.

    Conclusion: Eat and drink what you like. Speaking English is what kills you.
  3. chef_NU

    chef_NU G-Unit

    Joined:
    Jul 27, 2004
    Messages:
    424
    Location:
    Chicago
    SDN 5+ Year Member
    Ummm sources? This dude sounds like that Trudeau guy or whoever you say his name... "natural cures". Duh Americans have a bad diet... but eliminate dairy to prevent osteoporosis? He's taken some common medical knowledge (exercise, especially weight training, increases bone density... excess protein can prevent calcium absorption...) and put his own dumb spin on it to sound unique. The problem is that his logic is flawed. Correlation doesn't prove causation...
  4. McDoctor

    McDoctor Over One Billion Cured

    Joined:
    Feb 13, 2006
    Messages:
    657
    Location:
    McHospital
    Status:
    Attending Physician
    SDN 5+ Year Member
    I wouldn't even know where to start in taking apart this article, but lets start with the author's own numbers, whether they be accurate or not.

    He tells us 25 million americans have osteoporosis.
    By his numbers 6% of those will have a fracture and less that 1% will have a hip fracture severe enough to significantly impact their quality of life. Tragic, yes, but hardly an epidemic.

    He doesn't even begin to comprehend that the rise of osteoporosis is more than anything else the result of people living longer than ever.
    "Dairy is another contributor to bone loss" ???

    Here's something that really does contribute to bone loss and osteoporosis: Living past the age of 50. :idea:
  5. Mr. Adventure

    Mr. Adventure Oat-Packing Dadaist

    Joined:
    Jul 14, 2005
    Messages:
    178
    Location:
    Getting a soapy...
    Status:
    Pre-Medical
    SDN 5+ Year Member
    This may have to go in my signature... :thumbup: Thanks for the input all!
  6. boulux

    boulux Member

    Joined:
    Aug 17, 2005
    Messages:
    149
    SDN 7+ Year Member
    :laugh: good one!
  7. jonathon

    jonathon Removed

    Joined:
    Dec 28, 2005
    Messages:
    152
    Status:
    Other Health Professions Student
    Old age alone causes osteoperosis. LOL.
  8. USCguy

    USCguy Member

    Joined:
    Nov 3, 2005
    Messages:
    273
    Status:
    Resident [Any Field]
    SDN 7+ Year Member
    *IF* this guy's arguments are true, it would seem that eating 2 servings/day of mixed nuts would help fight osteoporosis. I just looked on my can of Planters NUT-rition mixed nuts and each serving contains 20% of the magnesium and 30% of the manganese of the RDA. but, all yeah, the RDA is messed up too...guess we are all screwed.
  9. Vox Animo

    Vox Animo Runs with Scissors

    Joined:
    Jan 28, 2006
    Messages:
    1,290
    Location:
    Midwest
    Status:
    Medical Student
    SDN 7+ Year Member
    I have heard arguments such as his before by Dr. John Robbins in Diet for a New America. He actually has citations. Some of it is true. For instance eskimos have the highs rates of osteoporosis. The population's with the lowest rates of osteoporosis are Bantu tribal women in Africa and they eat 350 mg of calcium a day. I would suggest looking through that book among others. There or millions of confounding factors for each side that I don't dare venture to discuss. I would think that activity levels also have more to do with osteoporosis than anything.

    Bone loss also has to do with how much of what you eat. For instance, pop (not soda) has sugar, acid and caffeine, all which remove calcium for the bones to the blood. But if you drink some caffiene, and have dietary calcium and exercise, your bones probably won't lose calcium.

    And as far as milk goes, its really is only heathly if you are a newborn calf that needs to double your body weight in 48 days. Aside from Europeans and West africans (traditionaly for the past few thousand years these population relied heavily on milk) most of the world is lactose intolerant.


    As for Europeans, that eat almost all organic food, along with the japanese, this probably has something to do with their health as opposed to genetics. Countries that are adopting americanized diets are catching up with us in osteoporosis, strokes, hearth attack, obesity etc.


    More importantly than anything, remember that the average doctor never takes a course in nutrition throughout their career. When I first became a vegetarian, i read as many books as a could and learned about how my diet had to change. All my doctor(s) said was watch your protein, which is the least important of a vegetarians worries.
  10. scpod

    scpod Moderator Emeritus

    Joined:
    Oct 13, 2005
    Messages:
    3,210
    Status:
    Attending Physician
    Physician SDN 7+ Year Member
    In bone loss, there are G-type calcium receptors that control the release of parathryroid hormone (PTH). PTH stimulates osteoclasts, resulting in the release of calcium into the blood.

    Thank you soooooooo much for your attempt at humor. Many pre-meds might actually believe some of the other nonsense you have spouted were it not for its shear ludicrosity. I have to wonder...did you ever actually take a biology class? Have you ever studied the human body? I have never laughed more than when you said milk, "is only heathly if you are a newborn calf that needs to double your body weight in 48 days." I doubled over with laughter. Can you actually believe that some people might think you were serious?

    When you said the average doctor never takes a course in nutrition, I cracked up. Of course, not many of them get to take their course in nutrition from your second cousin's brother-in-laws nephew's waitress at the IHOP. Damn! That woman knows some stuff about nurition! Who'd have known about the benefits of corned beef hash over eggs if Darlene Jones hadn't done that study at the trailer park!
  11. McDoctor

    McDoctor Over One Billion Cured

    Joined:
    Feb 13, 2006
    Messages:
    657
    Location:
    McHospital
    Status:
    Attending Physician
    SDN 5+ Year Member
    These differences are due to the differing amount of UV sunlight exposure, which is necessary for proper utilization of vitamin D. This is proven fact. It has everything to do with eskimos living in near total darkness for half the year (and the Bantu tribal women living at the equator) and nothing to do with diet.
    Beware of the junk science.
  12. gujuDoc

    gujuDoc

    Joined:
    Feb 21, 2004
    Messages:
    13,844
    Status:
    Medical Student
    SDN 10+ Year Member
    Last I checked osteoporosis was caused by hormonal changes in the body that go with old age, especially in women after they've gone through menopause.

    So I don't see how the milk think affects osteoporosis.

Share This Page


About the ads