most common hand surgery cases

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

mtheman

You know you want it.
15+ Year Member
Joined
Jul 7, 2005
Messages
127
Reaction score
0
This may sound stupid, but I was wondering, what is the most common case treated by hand surgeons? Also do hand surgeons(who have gone through ortho residency) treat fractures of the hand wrist and arm. Additionaly does going through plastic surg. training make a difference in the cases seen.


Any input would be great

Members don't see this ad.
 
does anybody know how to answer these questions?
 
since no one has answered yet I'll give you a quick answer. From my experience hand surgeons treat elbow and distal. They treat fractures, do tendon repairs, carpal tunnel releases, etc.

I'm not sure how plastics training affects care but I would imagine the fracture care would go to the ortho hand surgeon and more cosmesis s/p burns etc would go to plastics. hope this helps.

-J
 
Members don't see this ad :)
bennett's fractures are big for hand surgeons. :p
 
DOctorJay said:
I'm not sure how plastics training affects care but I would imagine the fracture care would go to the ortho hand surgeon and more cosmesis s/p burns etc would go to plastics. hope this helps.

-J

Our hand specialist is a plastic surgeon. He does all types of fractures and uses a lot of external fixation, does total wrist implants, and does some "less sexy" procedures like carpal tunnel, 1st MCP arthritis, tendon lengthenings, etc.

LCR
 
diabeticfootdr said:
Our hand specialist is a plastic surgeon. He does all types of fractures and uses a lot of external fixation, does total wrist implants, and does some "less sexy" procedures like carpal tunnel, 1st MCP arthritis, tendon lengthenings, etc.

LCR

Hey is your Avatar an Ilizarov frame? Can't really tell from this side.
 
Bull's eye said:
Hey is your Avatar an Ilizarov frame? Can't really tell from this side.

I'm doing a lot of Ilizarov for Charcot reconstruction. It works great (as internal fixation notoriously fails with Charcot patients).

The picture is a Smith and Nephew Ilizarov set with the Taylor Spatial rings. I switched companies about 2 months ago and now I'm using Small Bone Innovations (a new Hand and Foot/Ankle company). They have an Ilizarov frame they acquired from France. It's much lighter than anything I've used before. Aluminum rings and carbon fiber foot plates.

LCR
 
mtheman said:
This may sound stupid, but I was wondering, what is the most common case treated by hand surgeons? Also do hand surgeons(who have gone through ortho residency) treat fractures of the hand wrist and arm. Additionaly does going through plastic surg. training make a difference in the cases seen.


Any input would be great

Delayed response but may help someone...

Much of what you do as a hand surgeon depends on where you trained (your fellowship) and what you're interested in. There are some hand surgeons who do shoulder, elbow and wrist/hand and they're "upper extremity" surgeons. Others focus on elbow and distal. Most orthopaedic hand surgeons do elbow cases as well but this varies depending on the complexity of the case. The setting in which you practice also determines the pathology you see. For example, a patient with elbow instability from a sports injury is more likely to see a sports doctor than a hand surgeon. Patients with elbow arthritis or nerve compression are more likely to be referred to a hand surgeon.

Plastic surgeons usually focus on wrist and hand. It is rare for plastic surgeons to do elbows and shoulders in terms of bony work. They may do flaps, nerve repairs, decompressions, etc., but again it would be rare for them to do bone work in these areas. Whether they treat hand fractures depends on the setup at the hospital but most do treat hand fractures. At some hospitals, plastics takes care of soft tissue stuff and ortho does bony work. This is variable and probably less common. As far as cases, I think the issue is level of comfort. Plastic surgeons by virtue of their training feel more comfortable with soft tissue work and I think in many cases prefer this over bony procedures. This is a gross generalization but I think has some merit.

Bottom line is that much of what you do as a "hand surgeon" depends on where you trained and what exposure you had. Again, there are "upper extremity" fellowhips that give you broader exposure. Some fellowships are more focused. There are fellowships that give you plenty of elbow work but others that focus mostly on wrist/hand. So it's really variable.

Common hand procedures are carpal tunnels (by far most common), DeQuervains, ganglion cysts, mucous cysts, joint fusions (PIP, DIP), arthroplasties (MCP, PIP), tendon repairs, and fracture care which is very common. Hand surgeons also treat rheumatoid problems (tendon transfers, etc), do carpal fusions, treat ligament injuries in the wrist, etc. There is such a variety of cases and much of it depends on where you practice and the particular pathology that is prevalent in that area.
 
At a lot of the major centers, plastics and ortho will rotate hand call. A plastic surgeon spends a fairly decent amount of time on fixing fractures of the wrist/metacarpals/phalanges.

For example, at Pittsburgh there is a combined ortho/plastics Friday A.M. hand conference. Ortho will tell you they do a better job with hand than the plastics guys but I'm not at all experienced enough to know a difference.
 
A lot of hand guys are involved in the microsurgery as well. Atleast from the ones I know.
 
diabeticfootdr said:
I'm doing a lot of Ilizarov for Charcot reconstruction. It works great (as internal fixation notoriously fails with Charcot patients).

The picture is a Smith and Nephew Ilizarov set with the Taylor Spatial rings. I switched companies about 2 months ago and now I'm using Small Bone Innovations (a new Hand and Foot/Ankle company). They have an Ilizarov frame they acquired from France. It's much lighter than anything I've used before. Aluminum rings and carbon fiber foot plates.

LCR

Now from what I'm gathering you are a podiatrist that does a lot of diabetes etc. Do you do a lot of ankle stuff with neuropathic arthropathy or is it mostly mid/forefoot stuff. It seems as though you have a lot of experience treating these fairly complex foot problems, more than most podiatrists I know. I like a lot of the stuff from Innovations, have used their volar wrist plate I believe.
 
SOUNDMAN said:
Now from what I'm gathering you are a podiatrist that does a lot of diabetes etc. Do you do a lot of ankle stuff with neuropathic arthropathy or is it mostly mid/forefoot stuff. It seems as though you have a lot of experience treating these fairly complex foot problems, more than most podiatrists I know. I like a lot of the stuff from Innovations, have used their volar wrist plate I believe.

I do mostly rearfoot, midfoot Charcot. We do the occasional tibiocalcaneal fusion, but the scope of practice for DPMs in NY is horrible. DPMs outside of NY do a lot of ankles, but probably little Charcot.

I'll be doing a fellowship next year (probably Chicago) in diabetic limb salvage. I may get more experience with ankles there.

Are you seeing any of this where you are?

SBi used to be a upper extremity company (volar plate), but now they're branching out into the lower extremity too.
 
In the University setting you see a lot of trauma with microvascular work, pins, and very small plates and screws. Oh yeah, don't forget about Pus.

In private practice, your cases seem to be:

1. Carpal Tunnel
2. Corporal Tunnel
3. Car-pool Tunnel
4. Ulnar nerve transposition
5. Distal radius fractures

and sometimes:

6. CMC arthritis
7. Scaphoid fractures
8. Tendon lacs

Don't get me wrong, I love hand. But if you are thinking of doing a hand fellowship, be ready for a lot of unhappy workers with numb fingers.
 
Top