LOL! I'm sorry to disappoint everyone, but in situations like these, I am actually going to side with ADCOMs, and here's why.
In the case of this specific guy, his crime took place in 1992. This was the dawn of the world wide web. In fact, this was before Windows 95, when computing became awesome! I was still using Windows 3.1!
So assuming he got the charge expunged, I'm sure that ADCOMs would probably not have known about what happened. Back then, you couldn't just search up any random thing and find it on the internet. I'm sure that aside from his criminal record which was accessible only from law enforcement, if it weren't expunged, that you would have to actually go to a public library and look through newspaper archives to find the story. So back then, it was much easier to sweet a crime under the rug.
Even today though, I wouldn't blame ADCOMs for accepting students that committed crimes in the past? Why? Because everyone is quick to get things expunged if possible. Even if the story is on the internet, I believe that you can get it removed if your charges are dropped or have your record expunged, though I'm not sure. I went to high school with a guy who was charged and convicted of battery a few years ago. The story in the blotter was up on the internet for a few years, then randomly disappeared. Stories from the blotter that happened before his arrest are still online, so I believe he probably had the record expunged.
Remember, in our society it's far better to sweep things under the rug like it never happened than to claim responsibility. So if an applicant was successful in getting the conviction expunged and stories taken off the internet, how can anyone blame ADCOMs? I'm sure there's at least someone in your medical school class with a fairly serious criminal charge, that the ADCOMs probably had no knowledge of.
Plus this reminds me of a story I read last year on SDN. I searched for it in Google and managed to find it. It's very sad and I hope he never gets into medical school.
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...-Grammys-apologised-hospitalising-couple.html
But like they say, time heals all wounds. And by that, it means after enough time you can get your crimes expunged and probably get any evidence of it taken off the internet.
By the way, I'm a guy.