- Joined
- Nov 8, 2009
- Messages
- 4
- Reaction score
- 0
I've noticed over the past couple months that some things have been said about the MacNeal Transitional Year program becoming a more hardcore, less TY friendly program. I am a current resident at MacNeal and was very excited to match there last year because of all the great things I had heard about it. When I was applying the residents did 4 months of medicine wards, 1 month of either ICU or surgery, and for the most part all the other months were easy. Traditionally MacNeal has been a very competitive place to match because of location and being known for one of the easiest in Chicago. The rumors on this site are true that everything is changing...and to make it worse the program is not notifying applicants of these upcoming changes which I think is just dishonest. This is all lead by Dr. Tynus the program director at MacNeal who has made it her mission to make the program tougher.
There have been a ton of changes this year for the worse, and there are even more slated for next year. Instead of the 4 months of med wards and 1 month of ICU or surgery we now have 3 months of ICU, 2 months of Wards, 1 month of surgery, and 1 month of family practice inpatient wards. You take call each of these months. I was told there would be no call on ICU when I interviewed, but we now have call all three months. Also, the culture at MacNeal previously was to get all your work done and you can leave. This means if you were done by 11 you could sign out and leave. Dr. Tynus has now changed that to you have to be in house until 3 pm. On all inpatient months there is now a teaching session at 2 pm for the sole purpose of keeping us there later (exact words of the program director). We now sit around from 11 am when we are done with rounds until 2 pm waiting for these teaching sessions to start. I know 3 pm is not that late compared to other programs but at least your time is used in an appropriate way and you aren't just sitting around waiting for something to happen. We now also have to carry around a sheet on all of our electives and have it signed every day...like we are in middle school!
There are also a lot of changes that will be occurring next year that you have not been told about. There will continue to be 3 months of ICU, but with the new shift schedule there will be multiple various shifts lasting for 12 hours each. This will take the average hours per week from about 50-55 to 72. Also, there will now be TWO months of surgery, and you are no longer allowed to take vacation during this time. They are also devising ways to keep the residents in house until 3-4 pm every day. This may not sound like a big deal but it makes the commute disastrous. Almost everyone at MacNeal lives in Chicago and when we were getting out early traffic was never a big deal, but if you now leave the hospital at 4 you won't make it back downtown until 5-5:30. Not a great way to spend your day when you were done with work at 11am! They are also talking about moving morning report from 11 am to 7 am so that everyone has to get in to the hospital earlier as well.
These are just the changes that I have become aware of so far. I am sure there are many others that I am not aware of. The key to take away is that the culture of MacNeal is now changing. It used to be a cush TY program but is becoming more and more like a full medicine prelim program. With the new work hour changes a lot of other programs will become more attractive, but it definitely will make your time at MacNeal worse. I would strongly advise against ranking MacNeal. I also looked at Resurrection, St Josephs, St Francis and Northshore and would rank all of them above the proposed MacNeal next year. I would also let all of your friends who are applying to MacNeal know about all of these changes too. If you are still interested great, but it really pissed me off that they are not making these changes known to applicants.
Please PM or reply if you have any questions.
There have been a ton of changes this year for the worse, and there are even more slated for next year. Instead of the 4 months of med wards and 1 month of ICU or surgery we now have 3 months of ICU, 2 months of Wards, 1 month of surgery, and 1 month of family practice inpatient wards. You take call each of these months. I was told there would be no call on ICU when I interviewed, but we now have call all three months. Also, the culture at MacNeal previously was to get all your work done and you can leave. This means if you were done by 11 you could sign out and leave. Dr. Tynus has now changed that to you have to be in house until 3 pm. On all inpatient months there is now a teaching session at 2 pm for the sole purpose of keeping us there later (exact words of the program director). We now sit around from 11 am when we are done with rounds until 2 pm waiting for these teaching sessions to start. I know 3 pm is not that late compared to other programs but at least your time is used in an appropriate way and you aren't just sitting around waiting for something to happen. We now also have to carry around a sheet on all of our electives and have it signed every day...like we are in middle school!
There are also a lot of changes that will be occurring next year that you have not been told about. There will continue to be 3 months of ICU, but with the new shift schedule there will be multiple various shifts lasting for 12 hours each. This will take the average hours per week from about 50-55 to 72. Also, there will now be TWO months of surgery, and you are no longer allowed to take vacation during this time. They are also devising ways to keep the residents in house until 3-4 pm every day. This may not sound like a big deal but it makes the commute disastrous. Almost everyone at MacNeal lives in Chicago and when we were getting out early traffic was never a big deal, but if you now leave the hospital at 4 you won't make it back downtown until 5-5:30. Not a great way to spend your day when you were done with work at 11am! They are also talking about moving morning report from 11 am to 7 am so that everyone has to get in to the hospital earlier as well.
These are just the changes that I have become aware of so far. I am sure there are many others that I am not aware of. The key to take away is that the culture of MacNeal is now changing. It used to be a cush TY program but is becoming more and more like a full medicine prelim program. With the new work hour changes a lot of other programs will become more attractive, but it definitely will make your time at MacNeal worse. I would strongly advise against ranking MacNeal. I also looked at Resurrection, St Josephs, St Francis and Northshore and would rank all of them above the proposed MacNeal next year. I would also let all of your friends who are applying to MacNeal know about all of these changes too. If you are still interested great, but it really pissed me off that they are not making these changes known to applicants.
Please PM or reply if you have any questions.