Nd > md ?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
It really is only a matter of time before they can gain licensure in all 50 states.

And no MCAT! Where do we all apply?!
Members don't see this ad.
 
Nymphicus said:
ensuring that they have a very collaborative environment.
Click to expand...

Which, you'll surely agree, promotes the hydrotherapy efficacy.


As long as there's incense.
 
Members don't see this ad :)
Marge said:
2. To be fair, here is the curriculum:

Biochemistry
Human Physiology
Histology
Anatomy
Macro- and Microbiology
Immunology
Human Pathology
Neuroscience
Pharmacology

Clinical Nutrition
Botanical Medicine
Homeopathy
Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine
Lifestyle Counseling
Massage
Physical Medicine
Hydrotherapy
Click to expand...

I wanna take some of those courses, actually.
 
mmmcdowe said:
4)Hydrotherapy works by causing blood vessels to pump blood, allowing superior blood flow and removal of toxins from unhealthy tissues.
Click to expand...

Lulz. What was the thing about CO2 building up in the blood and causing damage? Why would there be CO2 buildup unless you were exercising vigorously or decided to stop breathing, which you wouldn't do if you were sick (hopefully).

But if we're being honest, some of it did sound sort like osteopathic medicine ... allowing the body to heal itself, structure affects function, etc.
 
Marge said:
Lulz. What was the thing about CO2 building up in the blood and causing damage? Why would there be CO2 buildup unless you were exercising vigorously or decided to stop breathing, which you wouldn't do if you were sick (hopefully).

But if we're being honest, some of it did sound sort like osteopathic medicine ... allowing the body to heal itself, structure affects function, etc.
Click to expand...

Happens during respiratory acidosis
 
tenndoc said:
Happens during respiratory acidosis
Click to expand...

Das the truf but the lady was saying hydrotherapy should be used for chronic conditions. :confused: Perhaps a medical student can comment on the efficacy of using hot and cold water to vasodilate and vasoconstrict, respectively, one's blood vessels, and how that would affect one's overall health.
 
Marge said:
Das the truf but the lady was saying hydrotherapy should be used for chronic conditions. :confused: Perhaps a medical student can comment on the efficacy of using hot and cold water to vasodilate and vasoconstrict, respectively, one's blood vessels, and how that would affect one's overall health.
Click to expand...

shhh... god did it, thats alll you need to know
 
Nymphicus said:
By having no MCAT, they weed out the gunners, ensuring that they have a very collaborative environment.
Click to expand...

Hahaha!! Best post I've read all night! Thanks for teh lulz :)

Sent from my PG86100 using Tapatalk 2
 
Named by The Princeton Review as one of the 168 best medical schools in the country, the School of Naturopathic Medicine at Bastyr University is committed to developing leaders in the evolving field of natural medicine. Bastyr's fully accredited naturopathic doctor (ND) degree program is internationally renowned for its rigorous curriculum, comprehensive clinical training and groundbreaking research. With that in mind, there is no better place to earn a well-respected, nationally recognized degree in natural medicine than Bastyr.


And they even have dual degree options!! Master of Science in Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine!

At Bastyr's teaching clinic, Bastyr Center for Natural Health, as well as at Bastyr's off-site community care clinics, you are trained to be a primary care physician capable of treating a broad spectrum of patients. This training emphasizes adherence to the highest standards in patient assessment, differential diagnosis, medical record documentation, referral practices and patient follow-up.
You will be taught by faculty who are outstanding physicians, many of whom are recognized leaders in their fields. Your shift supervisor encourages, leads and directs the patient/clinician encounter, while allowing you gradually increasing levels of autonomy.


http://www.bastyr.edu/academics/areas-study/study-naturopathic-medicine






Where do I sign up???
 
compshateme85 said:
What I don't get, is after all those biochemistry, anatomy, physiology, pathology, histology classes etc, the people taking them can then sit there and listen to how diet can cure cancer AND BELIEVE IT.

There is such a huge cognitive disconnect, I must be missing something.
Click to expand...

Didn't you hear that tumors have insulin receptors on 'em? This proves that sugar causes cancer. This also proves that if you feed someone wolfsbane or something with sugar, it will kill the tumor.

Obviously you haven't taken as much basic science as an ND.
 
scarshapedstar said:
Didn't you hear that tumors have insulin receptors on 'em? This proves that sugar causes cancer. This also proves that if you feed someone wolfsbane or something with sugar, it will kill the tumor.

Obviously you haven't taken as much basic science as an ND.
Click to expand...
Hey, naturopathic remedies are NATURAL. What more do you need to know? They aren't evil, toxic, chemicals, made in a lab somewhere! They are NATURAL substances, how could they NOT be better than the drugs MD's push?
 
Members don't see this ad :)
I'm extremely interested in finding out exactly what has been groundbreaking about bastyr's research.
 
Well if you have cancer, Bastyr is definitely the place to go!

The Bastyr Integrative Oncology Research Center (BIORC) opened in February 2009 on Bastyr University's campus in Kenmore, Washington. The center offers research participants an integrated approach to managing their cancer, providing comprehensive support for each stage of the participant's experience(from diagnosis to treatment decisions and restoration of immune function and health after completion of standard treatments). Research participants can receive care from licensed naturopathic physicians, nutritionists and acupuncturists, all of whom have advanced oncology training.


http://www.bastyr.edu/research/clinical-research-center/integrative-oncology
 
Before I walk in to take a final... I'd just like to Comment on their comparison on credits. I took Med biochem for 2 credits and in undergrad took rhetoric seminar for 4. Just Sayin
 
Hmm, no.

Homeopathy = immediate disqualification from the competition.

Rough break, naturopaths. Sorry.
 
I left Bastyr's ND program. Trust me. Its NOT the same. Diagnostic skills are ZERO upon graduation! and I don't know what clinical skills you are referring to because...well, besides giving B12 shots and " prescribing" suppliments you can get over the counter yourself, there isn't any! There should be a mandetory residency program!!!!!! Omg I'm serious! These students are not equipped as primary practitioners! And they have to find other nd's to gain experience under if they "want" to...its not mandetory!

And there is a reason ND's work @ health food stores, and suppliment stores.... they are not experienced enough to actually treat and dignose sick people. Healthy people?...sure. supplement away ND's, but How can you prescribe your patient anything when you have ZERO understanding of what medications he walked through your office already on? How they work...what they interact with! I saw one nd advertising ozone therapy! Seriously?? Who's is regulating these naturopaths?? I'm taking my mcat and going the DO route because I knew the limits of nd! I saw and experienced it myself... I think it is terribly wrong to be unable to admit as an ND you are limited in diagnostic skills needed to treat patients MEDICALLY! And if you are a primary doctor ehem... then that is what you are suppose to be able to do!

Medical students...can you imagine treating patients the day after graduation. (Boards too) without a residency and ZERO supervision??

This is so wrong!
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
The first two years are sound. Hard core classes. It is during "clinicals" at the neighborhood clinic that the deficits really begin to show. Serving patients with chronic issues is imperative you have a solid medical understanding of the meds they ARE CURRENTLY on from their MD/DO. This is where it gets dicey in my opinion. I know one student who left and is attending PNWU this fall. Holistic medicine should be used in a partnership with an md/do. Then naturopathic medicine can be extremely helpful. I left after serious counsel from md's that treat patients with a naturopathic/holistic approach and ND's. All agree you can always go MD/DO and take the knowledge and integrate naturopathic/holistic, but you can't be an ND and integreat the skills/knowledge of an MD/DO... afterall, you have to find your own experience under an ND when you graduate as a naturopath as well if you want supervised experience in the ND field. The program just needs mandatory residencies. Then it would be a great program within its scope! I don't want to bash bastyr. Professors are top notch. But this program is incomplete. And its expensive. You can walk into almost any suppliments store in seattle and find an ND on staff, I'm sure working to pay off their student loans.. a doctor making...what 16 bucks an hr? Maybe??? Hmm that is a huge red flag as well.

This is my last post on this subject. My advice to anyone contimplating the ND route. Be wise, seek counsel and do your due dilegence. Don't make this choice based on emotion or your core belief in natural medicine. Do you have money to start your own practice? There are very few ND jobs. Do you have a seasoned ND who can teach you for @ least 3 yrs after graduation? Do you have enough discernment to know the patient in front of you needs allopathicmedical treatment coupled with your treatment and your strong enough and secure enough to tell her that? Be wise. Don't be emotional and blinded. Reality is a B *$%h on the other side.
 
I can't really tell who is trolling but seriously, ND are dangerous! and they are competing with MDs and DOs at least in Arizona. I don't know how people are just trusting them. As I said in other post, I almost died because I was just too dumb to go see a ND instead of a real doc because I thought they were better since they were holistic.

Just saying
 
I'd rather see a nurse practioner.
 
Life Sucks said:
I'd rather see a nurse practioner.
Click to expand...

same, although i had an experience where I went to see a np and she freaked out because i came out positive for TB test. i tried to explain to her that people who were born abroad are often vaccinated for TB, but she didn't seem to understand and kept pushing that i take a year long medicine for it. so i switched to a real doc
 
zoner said:
same, although i had an experience where I went to see a np and she freaked out because i came out positive for TB test. i tried to explain to her that people who were born abroad are often vaccinated for TB, but she didn't seem to understand and kept pushing that i take a year long medicine for it. so i switched to a real doc
Click to expand...

she didn't go for the chest xray after a positive PPD? that is kinda standard....
 
SpecterGT260 said:
she didn't go for the chest xray after a positive PPD? that is kinda standard....
Click to expand...

she just didn't know these things... really even the regular nurses know these simple things.. i know she might have been just off that day or just one bad seed but it really made me realize that i will not go see np or pa as my pcp.. she even called me to try to convince me to go on the meds and i had to politely refuseit and she thought i was the one being all crazy
 
Last edited:
zoner said:
she just didn't know these things... really even the regular nurses know these simple things.. i know she might have been just off that day or just one bad seed but it really made me realize that i will not go see np or pa as my pcp.. she even called me to try to convince me to go on the meds and i had to politely refuseit and she thought i was the one being all crazy
Click to expand...

I have personally had similar situations with midlevels as well as heard several from friends/family. To be perfectly honest.... I am not aware of a single anecdotal incident from the people close to me in which there wasn't a problem. :(
 
there is anti np thread as well?
 
I was super confused when I saw it was Nymphicus posting this BS...and then I realized it was Nymphicus posting!
 
Last edited:
mehc012 said:
Incorrect. Enough said.
Click to expand...

no that is a correct statement. Because saying there is no "right" or "wrong" is not the same as saying there is no "greater than" or "less than" :smuggrin:

Wait crap... for a second there I thought we were in an NP thread, not ND.... yes, ND training is wrong and you basically have to reject most of what is taught in pre-clinic years to adhere to it.
 
Haaaaaa. Just had a dream about this. Posted about it in pre-osteo.

I'm actually surprised they focused their attack at MD curriculum and not DO. DO schools would be the weaker foe in the community's eyes anyway.
 
whatever guys, hydrotherapy is legit.

I pulled a muscle in my elbow, took an ice bath and was cured of pain in 20 minutes. I would have been on aspirin for a week to get the same results.

In seriousness though, I feel bad poking fun at others people's expense and refuse to take part. You guys should be nicer.
 
Mehd School said:
Haaaaaa. Just had a dream about this. Posted about it in pre-osteo.

I'm actually surprised they focused their attack at MD curriculum and not DO. DO schools would be the weaker foe in the community's eyes anyway.
Click to expand...

Lol. I hate pre med dreams. The night right before my interview in Houston, I dreamt that I overslept my interview by three hours. I woke up terrified and checked the clock. It was 4:30 in the morning but needless to say, I was so nervous about oversleeping I couldn't fall back asleep lol. :scared:
 
mehc012 said:
I was super confused when I saw it was Nymphicus posting this BS...and then I realized it was Nymphicus posting!
Click to expand...

I'm afraid I don't follow.


However, after reading:
Licensed naturopathic physicians have attended four-year professional-level programs at accredited institutions, where they have been educated in the same basic sciences as allopathic physicians. Some member schools in the AANMC actually require more hours of basic and clinical science than many top allopathic medical schools. (!!!!!!!!:eek:)
http://www.aanmc.org/naturopathic-medicine/naturopathic-physicians-are-rigorously-trained.php
​
I'm glad I just go to a regular, old-fashioned MD school because I probably wouldn't pass the curriculum at a ND school!
 
def1 said:
I feel bad poking fun at others people's expense and refuse to take part. You guys should be nicer.
Click to expand...

Well, it's one thing to poke fun at individuals, but a whole other thing when the representing body is full of ****. ND's could be ok, but their main source of information is down-putting of the golden standard degree of medicine today. If they just kept to themselves and said "This is what an ND is, and this is why we're good" instead of "This is what an ND is. We do more than MD's do. See how qualified we are???"

I mean, I'm going to be applying to osteo schools, but for the very same ****ty image reasons (among many others) the AOA is an easy target. They don't represent themselves in a tactful manner, and instead bring the entire DO degree down a little bit. :thumbdown:

You'll never see me say "Look at that dumb ass ND. Couldn't get into a real man's medical school, or what?". I'll never do that because I genuinely don't care about people's career paths and choices other than my very own.

Outside of our own narcissistic views, there seriously are people who want to go to podiatry or chiropractic school instead of MD/DO. I have a friend that pulled a 3.8 and 36 and went to a podiatry school. Full ride. His dream school.
 
Nymphicus said:
I'm afraid I don't follow.


However, after reading:
Licensed naturopathic physicians have attended four-year professional-level programs at accredited institutions, where they have been educated in the same basic sciences as allopathic physicians. Some member schools in the AANMC actually require more hours of basic and clinical science than many top allopathic medical schools. (!!!!!!!!:eek:)
http://www.aanmc.org/naturopathic-medicine/naturopathic-physicians-are-rigorously-trained.php
​
I'm glad I just go to a regular, old-fashioned MD school because I probably wouldn't pass the curriculum at a ND school!
Click to expand...

I was confused because SDN has a tendency to suck the sense of humor out of me. I thought it was BS until I saw it was you, and then I looked closer. Then I realized that this was some seriously good info...I mean, I would never have considered ND before, but now I have to reconsider my app strategy.
 
Huh...double posted. Odd.
 
mehc012 said:
I was confused because SDN has a tendency to suck the sense of humor out of me. I thought it was BS until I saw it was you, and then I looked closer. Then I realized that this was some seriously good info...I mean, I would never have considered ND before, but now I have to reconsider my app strategy.
Click to expand...

It was sarcasm. That is only good info if you don't think about it at all
 
She just didn't know these things... really even the regular nurses know these simple things..
Click to expand...

Even I know that. And only because you have to get a TB test to volunteer in a hospital setting. How could you not know that as an NP!
 
Mehd School said:
Outside of our own narcissistic views, there seriously are people who want to go to podiatry or chiropractic school instead of MD/DO. I have a friend that pulled a 3.8 and 36 and went to a podiatry school. Full ride. His dream school.
Click to expand...
Is there a "DO or ND?" thread yet? I will be so sad...
 
Nymphicus said:
Named by The Princeton Review as one of the 168 best medical schools in the country, the School of Naturopathic Medicine at Bastyr University is committed to developing leaders in the evolving field of natural medicine. Bastyr's fully accredited naturopathic doctor (ND) degree program is internationally renowned for its rigorous curriculum, comprehensive clinical training and groundbreaking research. With that in mind, there is no better place to earn a well-respected, nationally recognized degree in natural medicine than Bastyr.


And they even have dual degree options!! Master of Science in Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine!

At Bastyr's teaching clinic, Bastyr Center for Natural Health, as well as at Bastyr's off-site community care clinics, you are trained to be a primary care physician capable of treating a broad spectrum of patients. This training emphasizes adherence to the highest standards in patient assessment, differential diagnosis, medical record documentation, referral practices and patient follow-up.
You will be taught by faculty who are outstanding physicians, many of whom are recognized leaders in their fields. Your shift supervisor encourages, leads and directs the patient/clinician encounter, while allowing you gradually increasing levels of autonomy.


http://www.bastyr.edu/academics/areas-study/study-naturopathic-medicine






Where do I sign up???
Click to expand...



LMFAO

This one kills me. Really.

"one of the 168 best medical schools in the country"


there are 138 MD schools
there are 29 DO schools

138 + 29 = 167

do they even rank ND "schools"?
 
SpecterGT260 said:
It was sarcasm. That is only good info if you don't think about it at all
Click to expand...

Yes, this was me joining the sarcasm, rather than simply bashing the first post like I did initially. In the end, what it REALLY means is that I posted when I was too tired/otherwise out of it, and failed on all levels of internet communication (twice). My bad. Carry on, folks! :laugh:
 
Oh god, I turned it into an anti-NP thread. Oh yeah don't bash D.O's. Can't have doctor without the D.O.
But seriously, I have a very bad experience with NP's.
 
Life Sucks said:
Oh god, I turned it into an anti-NP thread. Oh yeah don't bash D.O's. Can't have doctor without the D.O.
But seriously, I have a very bad experience with NP's.
Click to expand...

We have to bash naturopathic doctors. Natural treatments has to be made very inferior to the big pharma industry.

To treat fibroids? Full on pain meds. Obesity? Give them liposuction and stomach stapling sugery? Don't like that? throw them out of your office. Big pharma's goal is to make sure patients stay on long term medication. If there's natural ways of curing diseases ... we have to call them quacks and bash them hard so nobody hears about it.
 
delta121 said:
We have to bash naturopathic doctors. Natural treatments has to be made very inferior to the big pharma industry.

To treat fibroids? Full on pain meds. Obesity? Give them liposuction and stomach stapling sugery? Don't like that? throw them out of your office. Big pharma's goal is to make sure patients stay on long term medication. If there's natural ways of curing diseases ... we have to call them quacks and bash them hard so nobody hears about it.
Click to expand...

Nice sarcasm.
 
delta121 said:
We have to bash naturopathic doctors. Natural treatments has to be made very inferior to the big pharma industry.

To treat fibroids? Full on pain meds. Obesity? Give them liposuction and stomach stapling sugery? Don't like that? throw them out of your office. Big pharma's goal is to make sure patients stay on long term medication. If there's natural ways of curing diseases ... we have to call them quacks and bash them hard so nobody hears about it.
Click to expand...

Any scientifically proven "natural ways of curing disease" are called medicine, not "alternative" or "naturopathic" medicine. Anyone who promotes "natural" cures WITHOUT being willing to hold their "cure" to the same standards as the rest of medicine, IS a quack and is NOT deserving of the same consideration as real science.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Next unread thread

Similar threads

O
  • Locked
Stressed/overwhelmed pre-med thoughts on ND schools and post grad
Replies
32
Views
1K
gyngyn
gyngyn
G
  • Locked
What is the consensus on Naturopathic (ND) schools?
2
Replies
95
Views
7K
Ferrismonk
Ferrismonk
S
MD vs PA
Replies
14
Views
2K
Meerkatology
Meerkatology
T
Declining an MD Acceptance and Reapplying
Replies
13
Views
2K
yourgfgf
yourgfgf
G
MD Admissions Updates
Replies
2
Views
828
Mr.Smile12
Mr.Smile12
Top