As requested. Again, disclaimer this is based off of personal opinion and being 2 years prior where many changes may have been made due to mergers and faculty changes and whatnot.
SOMC: Not continuing
St. Joseph/St. Elizabeth Boardman: This program was still just SJHC in warren, OH at the time but the Boardman location was already in place and in the process of accepting residents for it's inaugural class. There may be bias in this post as I did spend a good amount of time in the region as a medical student. SJHC is a small trauma III hospital with a relatively rural patient population consisting of Amish and underserved/blue collar patients. Boardman hospital is a brand new hospital located in the more wealthy area of Youngstown, OH. You will also do rotations at the trauma 1 hospital based in downtown Youngstown, SEHC. Located in the rust belt, Youngstown is really not a nice area by any means. You are however one hour from cleveland roughly as well as pittsburgh. That said, this area has a great patient population to train from as you will see a great variety of patients with a slew of different complaints. Strengths: low cost of living (i mean LOW), great training, amazing faculty (Uberti and Moosally are incredibly awesome), connection with a large local physicians group (4M), strong connections with the trauma 1 hospital, variety of different settings (boardman (upscale) vs. SJHC (rural community) vs. SEHC (more county-ish)) and their populations that come with it, EPIC EMR. Detractors: Faculty (inbred program), new (SJHC is not new, but boardman is), youngstown ohio...
Adena Health: Based in Chillicothe, OH. Relatively new program (at the time) with two new additions of faculty from Doctors in Columbus. Rural program which casts a wide patient population net where it is located between Columbus and southern Ohio. Interview day started at their new PACCAR med ed building with the other interviewees which consisted of talks from various people in administration about the nitty gritty stuff if you became a resident and a brief tour of the simulation lab. The interview process itself consists of a meeting with the PD, aPD, and 1-2 other members of the faculty. Out rotations are usual for Ohio, trauma and peds rotations in Columbus. Strengths of the program include hands on experience, wide variety of patients, support of the hospital for the residency, simulation center was/is top of the line, and low cost of living in the area. Detractors include the area is rural (you are relatively close to columbus though), new program (had yet to graduate a resident), and a few of the faculty members were not only abrasive but needed to come off their high horse.
Promedica: At the time it was still Mercy Memorial Hospital which was in the process of fleshing out a merger/assimilation with Promedica. Brand new program, with their seniors in their 2nd to third year of residency. It is located in Monroe, MI which is a small commute outside of Detroit near some energy (nuclear?) plant. The area is not pretty by any means but a good number of the residents lived in Detroit (royal oak, plymouth, etc) and commuted to work. The strength of this program for me was both in the faculty and in the upcoming partnership with Promedica. The PD at the time was also the creator of SOMC down in Portsmouth, Ohio and was well versed in building a residency program. Great charisma. However he was stepping down (openly admitting it during the interview) and was passing the reins off to a younger faculty member who is also equally as awesome in her own way and also happens to be the RISE vice chair. The program is well connected with the area's EMS and their curriculum for residents is actually very well thought out to me with a good mix of necessary rotations. The merger between Promedica which is the largest hospital system in Toledo will allow good access to a Trauma 1 center and if EM rotations are split between the two facilities, residents will get great necessary experience. Detractors: it's Monroe..., new program (can be a plus or minus depending on the person), details with the merger have yet to be totally hashed out at the time, PD was leaving, and the base hospital.
Botsford Hospital: Located in farmington hills, this hospital ran a busy ED with a generally urban population. There were talks of merging with Oakwood and Beaumont at the time which I know ended up happening as well as an expansion of the hospital and ED itself. The strengths of this program were quite practical to me. Their out rotations were top notch with trauma at Baltimore Shock along with months at Henry Ford, DMC and likely now Beaumont. Farmington Hills is also a relatively well to do area in Detroit so location was also a relative plus. The program itself has been around for quite some time and most if not all of the faculty is from their own private group (also a plus). They have graduates that are currently working all over and unlike many other residencies, they do emphasize training in documentation and billing as well which is a big big plus. Interview day consisted of interviews with the chief residents, a panel of attendings (6-9) as well as another separate interview of 3 faculty members). It also included a session with a where is waldo/I-spy book with a pulse ox attached to the finger and a semi mandatory sim lab session where they wanted to watch you put in an US guided central line in a mannequin. That said, this program was impressive on different levels though they did have a "holier than thou" attitude that may or may not be justified.
St. John Providence: Another of the detroit's osteopathic EM programs. Strong training with the usual out rotations of DMC, children's hospital of detroit, Sinai grace and whatnot. You will come out of this program with the necessary tools to become successful and well rounded. Residents mentioned their graduates being the highest billers of their new employer groups and having great efficiency. Interview day consisted of a panel of three of the faculty with you on the other side of the table and an array of questions being tossed at you. I personally did not like this interview but nevertheless solid program.
Lakeland: Located in St. Joseph Michigan, Lakeland is one of the newer Michigan programs as they were just about to graduate their first class when I interviewed. Wow. Where do I start. The faculty were all relatively young, hungry and energetic coming from all over. The PD, Dr. Mancini, is really awesome and intense (in a good way). There is no graduated responsibility, it is trial by fire as in, if that is your patient and this is your first day as a PGY-1 in the ED, you will try the intubation, central line, etc. etc. The hospital itself is beautiful (one of the hospital rooms that we saw could just as well have been from a Hyatt Place. New emergency department with a well thought out set up. Lakeland was not a trauma center when I interviewed but you will see plenty of trauma come through the hospital as it is one of the largest in SW Michigan outside of Kalamazoo. Interesting pathology such as water related accidents. There are two separate patient populations as you will see the underserved from Benton Harbor in a sister hospital and a separate patient population where the base hospital is located in St. Joseph. The EM residents are the strongest in the hospital and are unopposed (there is only an FM residency otherwise). Didactics are well organized. Out rotations at Spectrum Health in Grand Rapids. Detractors: new program and the area of St. Joseph itself. The area really isn't so bad as it is an hour out of chicago roughly and somewhat close to lansing and Grand rapids, however it is a sleepy tourist town. Interview day consisted of a pizza night with the residents before and tour + 3-4 separate interviews on the interview day itself.
MetroHealth: Located in Grand Rapids, this program has some similarities to Lakeland for me. Beautiful hospital with a well layed out ED, located in a fun vibrant city. They had plans when I auditioned and interviewed of becoming a Trauma II. The ED has a busy volume and the faculty are pretty great overall. Their PD, Dr. Berg, is incredibly awesome and all of their residents are down to earth and very chill. Not sure if anything has changed but they only accept two residents per year and their interview process was with only 10-12 interviewees who had all auditioned there prior. They are huge on the fit and finding the right person. Interview day consisted of drinks and pizza in Grand Rapids downtown with the faculty and residents. Out rotations are at Spectrum Health. The location to me is a plus as Grand Rapids is a small-medium sized city with plenty to do/eat and drink (founders!!). Detractors: inbred program, patient population, and unsure of the future of the program moving forward into the ACGME process.
Aria Health: Located in Philadelphia, Aria is more unique compared to alot of the other DO EM residencies in that it has a three hospital system. This allows access to three very different patient populations. Bucks is their suburban hospital which mostly sees fast track and acuity level 3/4/5 patients with minor-ish complaints. Torresdale is their trauma II hospital with a brand new ED which is amazing to look at. Seriously. The ED itself is awesome. Frankford is their third hospital which is located in the frankford district in NE philadelphia and this place is like a jungle with a very undeserved a primarily african american/immigrant population. You see some really weird pathology here with the general usual slew of undeserved urban complaints. The area around is not safe, on night shifts two of the hospital guards would have to walk you across the street to the parking structure and one would stand guard outside as the metal gate was raised and wait for you to come out. I loved it. Out rotations are amazing, burn month at Temple, peds at CHOP, etc. That said, the program had some extreme faculty turnovers when I auditioned there and had mostly new faculty with many locums tenens attendings. Aria residents are also one of the lowest paid residents in the city of Philadelphia. On top of that, there were constant mumblings of how many medicine months that the residents had to pull to cover and Aria itself has not only EM but EM/IM, EM/FM, FM, IM and other such programs. All in all, I felt it is a good training environment especially with the three hospital system which is rare in the DO EM world, and that you will come out well rounded to practice in any urban setting but the atmosphere wasn't the friendliest for me personally
Will post more later if time allows and there are specific requests as this is time consuming.
Other sites/programs include olympia fields, sparrow, conemaugh, St. Mary Mercy, Arnot, Marietta, St. Johns Westlake, HF Wyandotte, and Rowan.