The "Why do you want to be a doctor?" question

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

yalla22

Senior Member
7+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
20+ Year Member
Joined
Jan 6, 2003
Messages
911
Reaction score
0
As I'm preparing for interviews, i surprisingly find myself having a hard time answering this question verbally in a way that sounds unique and not cookie cutter. My advisor has told me that i need to work on coming up with a really solid answer for this question but its a lot harder given the fact that my answer is probably the same answer that everyone else will give...
When I think about this, the point that comes to mind is that I just really like helping people and along the same lines, taking responsibility for people, being depended on, etc. but my advisor has told me that they can grill you on this type of answer at interviews saying that there are many other professions that fit the same criteria.and i'm like "yes, there are MANY things with overlap in this world but there are still those minute differences that make things categorically different...you know?"
what do you all think?
 
I think if you answer the question "Why do you want to be a doctor?" would make you the common applicant. Try answering the question: "What made you want to be a doctor?" Find a situation in your life to answer this question. Everyones situations are different, yet everyone one "wants to help people." So stay away from that phrase.
 
As I'm preparing for interviews, i surprisingly find myself having a hard time answering this question verbally in a way that sounds unique and not cookie cutter. My advisor has told me that i need to work on coming up with a really solid answer for this question but its a lot harder given the fact that my answer is probably the same answer that everyone else will give...
When I think about this, the point that comes to mind is that I just really like helping people and along the same lines, taking responsibility for people, being depended on, etc. but my advisor has told me that they can grill you on this type of answer at interviews saying that there are many other professions that fit the same criteria.and i'm like "yes, there are MANY things with overlap in this world but there are still those minute differences that make things categorically different...you know?"
what do you all think?

Hi, there...

I feel your pain. This is perhaps the most diagnostic question that an interviewer can ask, however, so you are right to think it through as much as possible. The answer you give tells the schools boat loads of how much you actually know about being a physican and how much you want to be one.

I'd say avoid the "I want to help people..." line as you would the bubonic plague. It may be accurate, but it's the archetypal canned response and lacks any precision whatsoever. I mean, there are loads of ways to "help" people and to serve them. Given your above description, many public servants and healthcare providers could potentially apply. What you want to do is to get really, really specific, down to the level of detail that only describes the role of a physician, and then demonstrate, through examples why that makes you want to get up in the morning. For this, you will have to draw on your shadowing and clinical experiences (or do some research). It's best if you can tell stories, too. What do physicians do that inspires you enough to take on $250K worth of debt and 8 more years of schooling, many of which you will not be sleeping well? Make it heartfelt and authentic, but specific.
 
As I'm preparing for interviews, i surprisingly find myself having a hard time answering this question verbally in a way that sounds unique and not cookie cutter. My advisor has told me that i need to work on coming up with a really solid answer for this question but its a lot harder given the fact that my answer is probably the same answer that everyone else will give...
When I think about this, the point that comes to mind is that I just really like helping people and along the same lines, taking responsibility for people, being depended on, etc. but my advisor has told me that they can grill you on this type of answer at interviews saying that there are many other professions that fit the same criteria.and i'm like "yes, there are MANY things with overlap in this world but there are still those minute differences that make things categorically different...you know?"
what do you all think?

"Why do you want to be a doctor?" is a totally bogus question. If there was any justice in the world you would just answer, "None of your business," and move on.

Unfortunately the purpose of medical school admissions seems to be to make us all into liars, kiss asses, and worse. You'll of course have to talk about kittens, Dead African Babies, and your experiences distributing condoms to schizophrenic bums. There's no way out of it. They've got you by the balls.

You know it. They know it. They want you dance like a trained monkey.

Well. Why won't you do it?

Dance, monkey, dance! Damn you! Tell us how much you care! Tell us about yer' friggin' childhood hero Ghandi and how you burn, literally burn, with passion to wash the feet of the underserved for nothing.

Do we have to hire a mime? You call that dancing? You haven't even mentioned how your multiple experiences becoming involved in the lives of people who make you lock your car doors have made you into a more caring, soulful person in tune with the needs of the community.

Dance! Why won't you dance? Would it kill you to dance? You'll have plenty of time for regret when you're an intern.
 
Our you could just say, "Why do I want to be a doctor?"

"Because, despite what Public Enemy told me, I do so believe the hype! I embrace it! The hype is my rock upon which I have built the church of my life!"
 
Look, the "I just want to help people" answer is a bunch of BS. By going to med school, you are taking out around $250 - $400K worth of loans and devoting 8 years of your life to it. If you really just wanted to help people, you'd take that time and money and start a charitible organization and end up helping a lot more people than you would as a doctor. So yes, maybe you do want to help people. I hope that everyone who applies to med school wants to help people. But you have to be honest with yourself (and your interviewers) and figure out why you really want to be doctor. If you think you are ONLY doing it to help people, then you're just fooling yourself. Interviewers, on the other hand, are not as easy to fool.
 
Seriously, though. Would it cause the heavens to weep and the earth to open up if you just said, "Because I thought it might be an interesting job and a decent way to make a good living?"

Just a heads up. If I'm ever on an admission committee and somebody says that I'd accept them on the spot regardless of low grades or crappy MCAT score.
 
This question should not be that hard. You just have to figure out why you actually want to be a doctor.

If you say you want to help people / save people / etc., that must be presented in the context of the life you live. If you REALLY had only the desire to save/help people, you would go around the world distributing oral rehydration solution to folks with cholera [actual class example used by one of our teachers]. You could literally save thousands of people with little money. In medicine you usually spend zillions to actually "save" very few people. So helping/saving people IS a component of medicine, but clearly not the only component. But it IS a career where you do get to help people and still live a relatively normal life [note I did say relatively].

One component is personal interest. I hate to sound cheesy [and I'll admit as a first year student, I do have limited experience in medicine], but medicine can actually be interesting. If you're interested in science, you might just find this career interesting.

So why go into a career where you will work so hard? One will argue that people work their butts off in LOTS of careers. Some people work hard no matter what. They could be a janitor, and damnit they get three janitor jobs and work their tail off! Some people just have that in their personalities. If you know you'd be working like crazy no matter what you did b/c you're just like that, medicine might be for you. I know this is not a reason to go into medicine, but it is certainly a reason to not be dissuaded from going into medicine. If you think this is not relevant, I was actually asked about this in an interview last year.

My main point here is that we all have different reasons for going into medicine. But there is usually never one main reason b/c you could usually get the same effect from numerous other careers. But for most people that go into medicine, when they add up all the things they want in a career, the signs end up pointing to medicine.

I will give you a very brief list of my reasons for entering medicine as an example [note, I am not taking the time to explain these here, but hopefully they might serve as good examples....also note they obviously will be different than your reasons unless you are exactly like me]:

attracted to scientific aspect
like opportunity to research is i choose
like opportunity to teach if i choose
ability to help others
like the idea of feeling like i worked for something worth working for instead of working just to make money, etc., like some people do
like the idea of a stable income [i know people say mentioning $$ in an interview is taboo] since i grew up in a working class family with a small business that never had a stable, predictable income
like the idea of living where i want to live
like the idea of not having to move wherever some business wants to move me
like the idea of having smart, interesting colleagues
i like to make decisions
i like that the field is based on merit, where some other jobs are not
like the idea that no matter how hard it gets, it really does matter

Anyway, I chose medicine for reasons like the ones above. So really sit down and think about what you like about medicine. It does not have to be just about helping people or devoting yourself to your patients, b/c you really can do that in many other careers.
 
i want to help people haha, yes this sounds really lame, but i do. however, i have no plan of doing primary care, i don't got the patience for that.
 
They want you dance like a trained monkey.

Well. Why won't you do it?

Dance, monkey, dance! Damn you! Tell us how much you care! Tell us about yer' friggin' childhood hero Ghandi and how you burn, literally burn, with passion to wash the feet of the underserved for nothing.

Do we have to hire a mime? You call that dancing? You haven't even mentioned how your multiple experiences becoming involved in the lives of people who make you lock your car doors have made you into a more caring, soulful person in tune with the needs of the community.

Dance! Why won't you dance? Would it kill you to dance? You'll have plenty of time for regret when you're an intern.

Abso-freakin' hillarious ~

I obviously need to practice my monkey-dancing skills before my turn to apply comes up 😉 I totally should print this out and tape it to my monitor, so I can be reminded daily to buck up and just DO the crap that needs to be done and stop whining ~
 
Abso-freakin' hillarious ~

I obviously need to practice my monkey-dancing skills before my turn to apply comes up 😉 I totally should print this out and tape it to my monitor, so I can be reminded daily to buck up and just DO the crap that needs to be done and stop whining ~


Oh yeah. Do the dance. Shuck and jive. Look rapturous. Whatever it takes. Just keep in mind that the only thing you're going to be passionate about around the middle of intern year is getting a few days off.
 
"Because I thought it might be an interesting job and a decent way to make a good living?"

i don't know, i mean money is really never something i look for in becoming a doctor, if you decreased the pay would i still do it, the answer would still be an yes. I just see it as a nice way of giving back, maybe that is the communist background of me talking, but in either case, i don't feel like "good living" is really the decision maker for me.
 
I usually respond to the question more by answering "what events, experiences, and people, have directed me to medicine" and also take the time to talk about why not other professions like social worker, or psychologist (which I actually considered at one point). This answer has worked pretty well for me so far.
 
As I'm preparing for interviews, i surprisingly find myself having a hard time answering this question verbally in a way that sounds unique and not cookie cutter. My advisor has told me that i need to work on coming up with a really solid answer for this question but its a lot harder given the fact that my answer is probably the same answer that everyone else will give...
When I think about this, the point that comes to mind is that I just really like helping people and along the same lines, taking responsibility for people, being depended on, etc. but my advisor has told me that they can grill you on this type of answer at interviews saying that there are many other professions that fit the same criteria.and i'm like "yes, there are MANY things with overlap in this world but there are still those minute differences that make things categorically different...you know?"
what do you all think?

I am going to go against the crowd and say this is a pretty reasonable question. You are about to embark on a career that can potentially eat up 60 + hours of your waking life a week for the rest of your life. You must have some reason you are willing to endure this other than pure masochism -- although I can't speak for everyone on this. So in the answer, don't mention helping people, money, TV doctors, or the masochism thing. Talk about what made you think you liked this career path. Talk about what interests and excites you about this career path.
 
I wonder, is it frowned upon if you answer the question by replacing the word doctor with the specialty you want to go into?

So, I would answer the question as if I were asked, "Why do you want to become a psychiatrist?"
 
I wonder, is it frowned upon if you answer the question by replacing the word doctor with the specialty you want to go into?

So, I would answer the question as if I were asked, "Why do you want to become a psychiatrist?"
I wouldn't commit yourself to any particular specialty. So many people change their minds so many times. However, if you're asked, "If you had to decide right now, which specialty would you go in to?" then say psychiatry. However, to answer the OP's question, I would explain how you felt during a particular experience you had shadowing a psychiatris or something to that effect.
 
Top