What Constitutes URM?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

entdreams47

Full Member
7+ Year Member
Joined
Feb 21, 2016
Messages
97
Reaction score
63
What constitutes an Underrepresented Minority? If you are mixed ie 25% black count?

Members don't see this ad.
 
Last edited:
You can check both races. Each school can decide for themselves if they consider mixed race students to be underrepresented in medicine.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
Members don't see this ad :)
Just be forewarned that this may very well bite you on the ass if you lack a demonstrated commitment to underserved communities and/or communities of color, and you show up for interviews and the interviewees see this white kid. it wouldn't be the first time it happened.

To me, 25% AA doesn't count as URM.


What constitutes an Underrepresented Minority? I am 25% Black, 75% European (Italian) but I look very white. I dye my hair blonde, and I have my moms light eyes. I know legally I am allowed to check off black on applications but since there is an interview component I do not want to come across as dishonest. I was going to check off both - I may briefly discuss my mixed heritage in my personal statement, as well. Would this work to my advantage at all in the application process, as being a URM does for some people, or would I just be viewed as Caucasian?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 5 users
Just be forewarned that this may very well bite you on the ass if you lack a demonstrated commitment to underserved communities and/or communities of color, and you show up for interviews and the interviewees see this white kid. it wouldn't be the first time it happened.

To me, 25% AA doesn't count as URM.

Hi Goro, Why would you say the commitment to underserved communities and/or communities of color "validates" URM status? If 100% AA would you hold same opinion? What if 25% but very dark complexion/hair? At what percentage does this become a requirement in your opinion when not applying to a mission based program? Judging URM status seems so murky to me, maybe everyone should give a DNA sample:)
 
Hi Goro, Why would you say the commitment to underserved communities and/or communities of color "validates" URM status? If 100% AA would you hold same opinion? What if 25% but very dark complexion/hair? At what percentage does this become a requirement in your opinion when not applying to a mission based program? Judging URM status seems so murky to me, maybe everyone should give a DNA sample:)
Go away. Don't start that garbage.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
So many white kids try to game the system by checking the URM box that with some candidates, you have to walk the walk and not merely talk the talk.

One of my SDN advisees had >20 IIs and 19 rejections, due to this very scenario.


Hi Goro, Why would you say the commitment to underserved communities and/or communities of color "validates" URM status? If 100% AA would you hold same opinion? What if 25% but very dark complexion/hair? At what percentage does this become a requirement in your opinion when not applying to a mission based program? Judging URM status seems so murky to me, maybe everyone should give a DNA sample:)
 
  • Like
Reactions: 8 users
Hi Goro, Why would you say the commitment to underserved communities and/or communities of color "validates" URM status? If 100% AA would you hold same opinion? What if 25% but very dark complexion/hair? At what percentage does this become a requirement in your opinion when not applying to a mission based program? Judging URM status seems so murky to me, maybe everyone should give a DNA sample:)

It's not murky at all. In fact blacks and Mexicans face discrimination in similar ways that an interviewer would judge your status, with their eyes. All Goro is saying is that is a blonde white girl walks in an starts talking about her life as a Mexican/Black girl then there might be issues.

He is also saying that just having a skin color isn't a free pass, you need to have demonstrated service to your community. Med schools don't just admit blacks and Mexicans because they are that race, they do it with an expectation that they might service that community better in medicine (which traditionally is underserved otherwise).
 
  • Like
Reactions: 5 users
I am of mixed race myself, technically speaking. However, I was raised white, look white, and identify as white. Although I could've claimed URM, I chose not to, and still proclaim myself as non-URM for purposes related to this forum.

Because of my name, an interviewer who was URM asked me about my ancestry. I told my story, and when they asked me why I didn't put down URM status, I told them that I didn't believe in using my ancestry for the sole purpose of gaining an advantage, and that I'd rather let my achievements and work do the talking. They told me that that was one of the most honest answers they had ever received. Subsequently, I did get accepted.

If you talk the talk, be ready to walk the walk. You absolutely do not want to come off as disingenuous.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 5 users
Just be forewarned that this may very well bite you on the ass if you lack a demonstrated commitment to underserved communities and/or communities of color, and you show up for interviews and the interviewees see this white kid. it wouldn't be the first time it happened.

To me, 25% AA doesn't count as URM.

I actually had a question about this. I'm 100% URM, but my community doesn't really exist in my college town. Instead, I've worked heavily with the homeless in a clinical setting. Do you think that that will reflect my desire to work in an 'underserved' area well, if I state it as such?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
So many white kids try to game the system by checking the URM box that with some candidates, you have to walk the walk and not merely talk the talk.

One of my SDN advisees had >20 IIs and 19 rejections, due to this very scenario.

Wait what? Your advisee had 20 interview invites and 19 post-interview rejections?! Sorry but this is rather shocking, and I would believe it has also to do with poor interview skills.
 
I actually had a question about this. I'm 100% URM, but my community doesn't really exist in my college town. Instead, I've worked heavily with the homeless in a clinical setting. Do you think that that will reflect my desire to work in an 'underserved' area well, if I state it as such?

I am in a similar situation and yes I think it may still reflect that.
 
I think that's fantastic!

I actually had a question about this. I'm 100% URM, but my community doesn't really exist in my college town. Instead, I've worked heavily with the homeless in a clinical setting. Do you think that that will reflect my desire to work in an 'underserved' area well, if I state it as such?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Members don't see this ad :)
So does a person who is 100% black and is privileged also get the advantages of being a URM? Or is being a URM also tied with being disadvantaged as well?
 
So does a person who is 100% black and is privileged also get the advantages of being a URM? Or is being a URM also tied with being disadvantaged as well?

Don't think they are tied...I know so many Nigerians who are privileged/wealthy out the wazooo but bc of the way Race is perceived in America they are considered urm and assumed to be disadvantaged among other stereotypes....and on top of that we are grouped into being African American instead of Nigerian American or just Black which complicates things even more.


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile
 
So does a person who is 100% black and is privileged also get the advantages of being a URM? Or is being a URM also tied with being disadvantaged as well?

From my understanding those two are separate entities.

Underrepresented minority is not the same as disadvantaged. You can be disadvantaged and part of an over-represented ethnicity
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
@Goro Hypothetical: If President Obama had a twin brother and if that brother married a WASP, could/should their kids identify racially as black/African-American and white on the AMCAS?

Should such a person deny the ethnicity of one of their four grandparents?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
@Goro Hypothetical: If President Obama had a twin brother and if that brother married a WASP, could/should their kids identify racially as black/African-American and white on the AMCAS?

Should such a person deny the ethnicity of one of their four grandparents?

Wouldn't they mark down both? 50% AA and 50% White-anglo-saxan
 
Don't think they are tied...I know so many Nigerians who are privileged/wealthy out the wazooo but bc of the way Race is perceived in America they are considered urm and assumed to be disadvantaged among other stereotypes....and on top of that we are grouped into being African American instead of Nigerian American or just Black which complicates things even more.


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile

This is very interesting actually as I think about this situation from a latino american perspective..... Years ago I am sure that anyone from latin heritage would be considered URM... But now I know that Cubans are not considered URM because they were able to establish themselves here in the US, while Mexican-Americans and some others are still URM... I wonder if this same thing will happen with Black community. I think a big step would be deciphering between Nigerian American/African-American and other subsets, just as latin americans have done
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Wouldn't they mark down both? 50% AA and 50% White-anglo-saxan

On the AMCAS, you can self-identify by checking as many boxes as you wish. I don't believe there is any requirement to check percentages. In this case, the applicant has one black grandparent (from Kenya) and three white grandparents.

@Goro says this shouldn't count as URM
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
there are other groups in the US that as face value "look white" but identify as black....they are known as Creoles and actually used to pass for white to enter into certain parts of society ....I think it just matters who self identify as. For my college application I put other and wrote Nigerian American


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
This is very interesting actually as I think about this situation from a latino american perspective..... Years ago I am sure that anyone from latin heritage would be considered URM... But now I know that Cubans are not considered URM because they were able to establish themselves here in the US, while Mexican-Americans and some others are still URM... I wonder if this same thing will happen with Black community. I think a big step would be deciphering between Nigerian American/African-American and other subsets, just as latin americans have done

It's not hard to decipher. They are culturally different. I grew up in a very Nigerian household....my name is Nigerian and most of us are raised to be pretty nationalistic and there are tons of Nigerian milieus across the country. Actually I remember being taught to say I was from Nigeria and not America.


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile
 
there are other groups in the US that as face value "look white" but identify as black....they are known as Creoles and actually used to pass for white to enter into certain parts of society ....I think it just matters who self identify as. For my college application I put other and wrote Nigerian American


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile

Yeah I make sure to list Cuban-American because that is what my grandparents and mother have always considered us. If a medical school does not consider that condones URM status/would add diversity to their class then hopefully I can do that through my accomplishments and personality :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
It's not hard to decipher. They are culturally different. I grew up in a very Nigerian household....my name is Nigerian and most of us are raised to be pretty nationalistic and there are tons of Nigerian milieus across the country. Actually I remember being taught to say I was from Nigeria and not America.


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile

I understand they are culturally different, very much so. But I think any subset from Africa would be considered URM while Latino countries do not have the same
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Well see the thing is...an important justification for AA is that these people will go back to their communities and serve...and also relate better to patients of their own race. If you look totally white, I don't think a black person would relate (a big part of the relating comes from the observable skin color; you don't have all day to talk about your backgrounds etc) any better to you than a Caucasian doctor.

Since you are 75% Italian, I can bet money that you haven't affiliated much with the black community.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
On the AMCAS, you can self-identify by checking as many boxes as you wish. I don't believe there is any requirement to check percentages. In this case, the applicant has one black grandparent (from Kenya) and three white grandparents.

I agree. It's about Selfidentification. Bc from an African perspective they would still be considered Kenyan even if they are mixed or one of their parents is white. I have cousins who are mixed and they are raised to think they are Nigerian esp if their father is Nigerian, didn't matter if their mom were white or any other nationality.


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile
 
Oh, applicants can check whatever box they want. I'm more interested in the perception of the Adcom and interviewers when they see the candidate walk into the room. As @gyngyn has mentioned, people have been disingenuous about his, and it's blown up in their faces.

For example, what reaction would these candidates get?

upload_2016-5-27_10-32-42.jpeg


images










@Goro Hypothetical: If President Obama had a twin brother and if that brother married a WASP, could/should their kids identify racially as black/African-American and white on the AMCAS?

Should such a person deny the ethnicity of one of their four grandparents?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
Reminds me of an application that came in from an applicant from a very, very affluent suburb of a large American city (you know the type). Self identified as American Indian (Native American) and white. That might have been the kiss of death but something like a 3.89/39 turned the tide in the applicant's favor.

Of course, given that schools can be sanctioned by LCME (accrediting agency) for having too little diversity in its student body and faculty, I would bet that some schools will count anyone who checks a box as URM if they are also good enough to get admitted.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
Oh, applicants can check whatever box they want. I'm more interested in the perception of the Adcom and interviewers when they see the candidate walk into the room. As @gyngyn has mentioned, people have been disingenuous about his, and it's blown up in their faces.

For example, what reaction would these candidates get?

View attachment 204337

images


Black folks can spot Black folks (usually). Those last two are clearly Black. (And I love the first woman on suits!) How would a non- black adcom see them? As anything BUT black, haha.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Don't think they are tied...I know so many Nigerians who are privileged/wealthy out the wazooo but bc of the way Race is perceived in America they are considered urm and assumed to be disadvantaged among other stereotypes....and on top of that we are grouped into being African American instead of Nigerian American or just Black which complicates things even more.


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile

Your average white employer isnt going to be able to discern between a "poor" black and a "rich" black
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
Black folks can spot Black folks (usually). Those last two are clearly Black. (And I love the first woman on suits!) How would a non- black adcom see them? As anything BUT black, haha.

I know black ppl that look like this....I know Nigerians that look like this and some have green eyes too....actually when I go to Nigeria ppl think I'm mixed bc I guess I don't fit the stereotype bc I'm like very very fair among other features. It's such a hard call. The first girl is mixed btw she's half black and I love her on suits!!


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile
 
I know black ppl that look like this....I know Nigerians that look like this and some have green eyes too....actually when I go to Nigeria ppl think I'm mixed bc I guess I don't fit the stereotype bc I'm like very very fair among other features. It's such a hard call. The first girl is mixed btw she's half black and I love her on suits!!


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile


I know, I've watched suits forever. I just don't put her in the "clearly Black to Black people category".

Black folks come in alllllll shades. You made me think of Jidenna (sp). A lot of Jamacians have fair skin as well.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
I know, I've watched suits forever. I just don't put her in the "clearly Black to Black people category".

Black folks come in alllllll shades. You made me think of Jidenna (sp). A lot of Jamacians are fair skin as well.

Yup Jidenna is a great example!! We are from the same ethnic group in Nigeria and a lot of us look mixed/ambiguous.


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile
 
Ok. what is your point? They can't discern btw a poor white person and a rich white person either.


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile

I dont think white people have a history of racial discrimination against white people. (unless we get into the whole Irish thing).
 
I dont think white people have a history of racial discrimination against white people. (unless we get into the whole Irish thing).

ok. I'm going to leave this here because I don't want to go into any debate about race on SDN. It's not worth it. Thank you for your input though.
 
ok. I'm going to leave this here because I want to go in it any debate about race SDN. It's not worth it. Thank you for input though.

Feel free. I have personally experienced employers in my hometown with blanket policies that they do not hire blacks on principle. This isnt a thing that people make up. Its not an imagined reality.

The point is that if someone walks up who clearly doesnt look black or mexican then its hard to imagine them facing racial discrimination.
 
Feel free. I have personally experienced employers in my hometown with blanket policies that they do not hire blacks on principle. This isnt a thing that people make up. Its not an imagined reality.

Ok. I am going to respectfully decline bc I think you are trolling.


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile
 
Ok. I am going to respectfully decline bc I think you are trolling.


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile

Funny you say that.

Another anecdote was in my church. We have about 100 people each sunday and I happen to be the only non-white (Mexican) in the membership (when I still went to church). One day in my adolescent years a black family decided to come to the church one sunday, the first time I believe that had happened.

They came a few weeks and then around 4 weeks later they never came back again. At a later time, my grandfather told me that some of the other church members confronted the pastor and told him "if those blankers' children keep coming to sunday school, we will stop donating to the church."

This was in rural NC. That instance kind of opened my eyes on why the blacks/mexicans in my community did not go to the church that I went to. Previous to that I thought blacks in my community simply werent christians.

Lucky for me I as adopted into a fairly upstanding white family so I am well accepted in the church (also im only half mexican and fair skinned).
 
Last edited:
Top