- Joined
- May 25, 2015
- Messages
- 283
- Reaction score
- 161
Is it ok to basically summarize my personal statement for my "why medicine" interview answer or do they not want to hear the same thing? Also, typically how long should my response be?
Just answer the questionIs it ok to basically summarize my personal statement for my "why medicine" interview answer or do they not want to hear the same thing? Also, typically how long should my response be?
Two minutes is long.Is two minutes ok? I'm planning to tell a story about an interaction I've had with a patient.
Two minutes is long.
Does anyone talk for two minutes in a conversation?
If it sounds rehearsed, it's worse
This sounds rehearsed...So should I not tell any stories, but instead give an overarching reason for choosing medicine and hope that they ask follow up questions?
I feel like it would sound too vague if I I just said I like to critically think about science but also feel that medicine requires a physician who communicates well and listens to their patients....and I have shown that my personality suits this through x,y,z EC.
This sounds rehearsed...
Just belt out the story in less than a minute and let them follow up.
My answer had nine words in two sentences. I got into every school that I interviewed.
Pare it into the smallest number of syllables. Say it with conviction.The story is basically how I learned that medicine requires more than just smarts, but an art for connecting with patients and listening to them.
This is what's in my PS.
I got into every school that I interviewed.
I post them every day.Teach us your ways!
This sounds rehearsed...
Just belt out the story in less than a minute and let them follow up.
My answer had nine words in two sentences. I got into every school that I interviewed.
Ideally, the interview should feel like a conversation, not a series of presentations.There's actually a lot of conflicting advice on this. Most of what I've seen says to tell a story rather than just directly state your reasons which should take about 2 minutes
Ideally, the interview should feel like a conversation, not a series of presentations.
If the opening response is short but compelling, the interviewer has the opportunity to follow-up in a direction that interests them.
It will depend on the scenario.Thanks for your responses. Would this also apply for MMI interviews? Or should we keep talking longer for these?
This sounds rehearsed...
Just belt out the story in less than a minute and let them follow up.
My answer had nine words in two sentences. I got into every school that I interviewed.
It will depend on the scenario.
Then it's the same. No one wants to hear a soliloquy.I mean if they ask the why medicine at an MMI station.
I mean if they ask the why medicine at an MMI station.
At the start of my interviews I will clearly state that I do not wish to be spoken to, I feel that this will allow me more time to tell my interviewer stories that demonstrate how good I am at listening to and conversing with patients.
It doesn't say anything...@gyngyn -I've been thinking about this question and how does this sound? "I want to pursue a career in medicine because it is unlike any other field I have experienced." Is this to vague?
Then why the hatred for the "I love medicine" Especially if you can back up that statement?Imagine meeting someone for the first time and they immediately said, "Now let me tell you a story..."
If it's anyone other than the Fresh Prince of Bel Air, I've tuned out by time they've taken their second breath.
Then why the hatred for the "I love medicine" Especially if you can back up that statement?
There have been many interviews where this question has come up as an afterthought on behalf of the interviewer. It is difficult to assess the impact i could make in 10 seconds without sounding stupid or talking like a maniac.No hatred, in my opinion it's more effective to explain your "I love medicine" without potentially digressing from your key points. In my opinion, one needs to manage the impression they make in an interview, using a story to answer the one of the most important questions may leave room for uncontrolled interpretation.
That's not exactly how MMIs work though... They are definitely not conversations.Ideally, the interview should feel like a conversation, not a series of presentations.
If the opening response is short but compelling, the interviewer has the opportunity to follow-up in a direction that interests them.
MMI's consist of me babbling like an idiot trying to read body language of the interviewers to see if they are content with any word I have said so far.That's not exactly how MMIs work though... They are definitely not conversations.
And they're never content. I've heard that they literally tell some interviewers to keep a stern face the entire time haha.MMI's consist of me babbling like an idiot trying to read body language of the interviewers to see if they are content with any word I have said so far.
I know, but some people cant help it. THey are not trained very well. Some people unknowingly nod, others smile, others let out an audible "Yes" . The ones you cant read are the most difficult.And there never content. I've heard that they literally tell some interviewers to keep a stern face the entire time haha.
@gyngyn -I've been thinking about this question and how does this sound? "I want to pursue a career in medicine because it is unlike any other field I have experienced." Is this to vague?
It perplexes me that this is a perplexing interview question