Initial question:
Yes. I keep an open mind when thinking about the DO/MD argument, because soon it will be a four-way battle for many DO/MD/CNP/PAs.*
AOA and OPP: I'm an M2, so weigh what I say against the naivety inherent in my post. I think most of the OMT I've learned can be summed up by this:
1. Hand skills are good and OPP will give you a temporary edge on most MDs when it comes to patient contact and manual dexterity.
2. Stretching is good. Poor posture is bad.
3. DOs can spot drug seeking behavior with a simple set of physical skills many MDs never learn.
and most importantly...
4. Never question an OPP professor on the scientific research behind a weird technique unless you do it in his/her office.
Independent and widely validated research is the solution to the debate. You can't teach most rational people the science behind medicine and expect them to believe jibberish. Get rid of the crap and most of the hucksters will find another vocation. I hope this will happen as the economics of healthcare change and vetting becomes a priority when dealing with fringe therapies. Insurance may decrease our wages, but at least it'll be good for our education.
Anecdote: Me and the girly visited the ruins of a pseudo-scientific cult (The Koreshan Unity) started by an MD in Chicago this weekend, and I won't lie: AT Still and the OMT Jim Joneser's came up in discussion more than once. I've connected the dots while reading this thread and realized
what separated AT from some of the practioners today is the body of scientific knowledge available to him, which he would have eaten up and probably done great things with. We need to revise that knowledge, imo.
To bastardize Gandhi: "I like your AT Still, but I do not like your OPP nut-jobs."
*-
Rant:
Markets correct themselves quickly when demand outstrips supply.I
think hard work will become a requirement for this job in the next five years, regardless of the letters behind your name and the chosen specialty. While people will whine on about a cushy job/residency stripped of them, I'll be glad I was born with a hyperactive right brain and steady backbone.
I didn't get into medical school to make money or have people call me daddy... and yeah, patients can make you feel great, but I digitally removed enough morphine turds in the ED as a CNA to learn appreciation is not a guaranteed perk in this job.
I did it because I love solving problems under stress and being able to rewind the tape and critique myself over and over again in order to perfect some weird mix of art and science that will never be fully understood by 'itself.'
You have to be slightly masochistic to play this game and love it. I can already see that, and the referee just fired the starting gun. So... what was that about DO/MD preference?
It'll be interesting to read this in two years and see how my opinion has changed. Thank gawd for the interwebz.