So to understand how this all played out, you need to understand how we got to this point, and the evolution of this game defined its structure. SOV started with the premise of a WW game where the roles would be the actual previous WW games, and other than that, had no particular view on the game design. LIS came onboard with the idea, that no one picked up on, that the wolves would be from the games where the wolves won, the villagers would be from games the villagers won, and neutral characters would be from games where neutral/chaos won. A very simple concept, and it would have made it fairly easy to pick out wolves vs villagers once understood. We never got to that point, so the source of wolves and villagers remained a mystery until the end. From there, we changed the role names from the game itself to a memorable role in the game for us, sometimes using the same role ability, sometimes changing it, but never paying attention to whether the role was a villager or a wolf role. Also we had to make one "exception to the rule" didn't we?
The problem quickly developed that the wolves were winning almost all of the games we liked. In the end we had 7 villagers, 15 wolves, and 2 chaos. That fairly easily broke down into 3 groups of wolves. To give the villagers a fighting chance we had to 1) supercharge the villagers so they had powers and could survive and 2) delay the wolves realizing they were the majority and could gang up on the villagers. As DocE noted after his death this is a WW of WW (werewovles) game, so there were werewolves everywhere. To accomplish these goals the wolf groups were all handicapped in some manner. Group #1 "the sort of wolves" were told they were villagers and given useful powers for villagers, and would not be organized into a pack until night 5 when they gained their killing power. Sadly only 1 wolf lasted that long. Group #2 was organized into a group, was NOT told their affiliation, and did not know they could kill. Their "protector" was actually the killer and that power passed down on death. Due to an odd confluence of events, they kept on killing people that were killing other people so it took a while for them to realize why "protection" kept on being put in quotes. In the meantime they "protected" a few of their own members and quickly got killed off until only one was left. Their resurrector, resurrected a mute villager. Finally, the 3rd group of wolves had almost no useful abilities, but at least they knew who they were. They also had the ability to kill permanently those pesky hard to kill villagers if Sauron got the whip. And even though one of the wolves received the whip, it wasn't passed on to Sauron. Also, one of these wolves could NOT kill if used for it. Finally, all the wolves got their abilities in separate PM conversations to foster a little distrust. So that may have added to the confusion.
So who are we left with: We have JaynaAli the Phoenix from DVMD's huge mysterious planet game, we have the Creator from SOV's Thomas Covenant game, and we have the Bengal cat/tiger from DVMD's cat game. Anyone who played these games should now know who was the wolf and who was the villager. SOV couldn't help get his revenge on that Bengal cat by making it the toothless kitty cat who could attack but not kill. So DVMD is the original wolf has been not killing every night since the last wolf was killed.
JaynaAli has been lynched, a villager. She still has 2 more regenerations left, but sadly, while she is regenerating, DVMD scratches SnS and SnS gets infected and dies. When JaynaAli finally regenerates it is just her and DVMD, and even a toothless cat can swallow a little regenerating bird.
WOLVES WIN. Not sure how you pulled that out DVMD.. A wolf who can't kill, and seemed to be clearly identified as someone who couldn't be an original villager survived. I guess that is why wolves keep inactive players around. LOL.
<THE END>
Thanks for playing. It was a lot of fun. As usual, your creativity helps to make the game exponentially more interesting.
Sorry we ran a day late. A few less kills than we figured would happen.
The Full Roster.
DocEspana Jaime Lannister, villager killer
Zensing, George Bailey, wolf "protector"
Wolfspeaker, a sheep, and a wolf, of sorts
OneGrainOfSand, Qui-gon Jinn, a wolf blocker, of sorts
Gwenevre, Mr. Gold, wolf seer
sorasea, Tony, wolf blocker
FFM, Angel, a wolf protector, of sorts.
Cyndia, Engineer, wolf
Resolute Mike, Debra Morgan, a wolf seer of sorts.
Jilary , Vincent the dog
STL, Sauron, wolf
Orcagirl, Ceiling Cat, villager role seer
Swingnsave, Batman, wolf resurrector who had assumed Zensing's duties upon death
WZ, Tiger Willow, neutral
Devyn, Dionysius and wolf.
Krist, vet student, and wolf
Dyachei, Ezio Auditore, villager assassin
lupin, lupin, sort of wolf turned full wolf
WTF, the Musher, chaos
BI, Elvis, who ran out of fans and is dead for good.
Lissarae, the *****.
JaynaAli, phoenix.
SnS, the creator.
DvmD:, bengal cat/tiger, toothless wolf