- Joined
- Jun 16, 2006
- Messages
- 869
- Reaction score
- 1
Hi. I am considering going into medicine and I just wanted to know what are your thoughts about the negative aspects of medicine??
how about any bureaucracy kind of issues? residency training?
You will find that residency training has little to no bureaucracy at all! It's quite wonderful!! As far as socially inept peers, that someone else mentioned, I find that some people may be delightfully quirky but they are all very very great people!! You will love them all, each and every one! Good luck!
The expectation that you are perfect and a miracle worker. Despite discussions of possible complications, patients are always suprised when they have one and in many cases, they are quick to blame the physician for it
You have to really LOVE medicine to love your job because its ****ing hard...
wow thanks for the info. It sounds like a lot to deal with, but I dont care I still want to be a doc!🙂 I might not know a lot of this because I'm not even close to being where u guys are, but I still believe the good will outweigh all the negative aspects.
wow thanks for the info. It sounds like a lot to deal with, but I dont care I still want to be a doc!🙂 I might not know a lot of this because I'm not even close to being where u guys are, but I still believe the good will outweigh all the negative aspects.
there is a sucka born every minute![]()
hey medicine needs suckers like me with our naive optimism.😉
hey medicine needs suckers like me with our naive optimism.😉
No, actually it doesn't. It needs people who are smart enough to learn the material, savy enough to apply it to real situations, and strong enough to deal with (and struggle against) the system. Premeds have vastly overstated the importance of optimism and compassion. Patients need doctors who are their advocates, not their best friends or a shoulder to cry on.
The reality is that we spend maybe five minutes a day with our sickest inpatients, but many hours discussing their cases and getting them what they need. Nurses, social workers, and other ancillary staff make a far greater personal impact on patients than we do. Our expertise is in managing medical issues, not social or emotional issues. Forget this at your peril.
hey medicine needs suckers like me with our naive optimism.😉
wow thanks for the info. It sounds like a lot to deal with, but I dont care I still want to be a doc!🙂 I might not know a lot of this because I'm not even close to being where u guys are, but I still believe the good will outweigh all the negative aspects.
I don't understand.
You wanted honest responses and you got them. And yet, you've decided not to listen to them, or even think them over?
I mean, people basically said - it's hard, dirty, sometimes thankless work. And your response is "I still believe the good will outweight all the negative aspects." Did you even read carefully over what everyone said?
It really is hard work. And while I'm not saying that NOBODY should go into medicine anymore, I think that the better informed you are before you start, the better off you are. I wish I had gotten such frank, detailed responses before starting med school.
actually did read what ppl wrote but I'm entitled to formulate my own opinion from it too...and exactly u were in my spot once.
I've been thinking about responding here for a few days. I tend to be pretty cynical so I was avoiding it. But I think I can add to some of the other points that other posters have brought up.
Two caveats: #1 I am cynical so some rosy people might not share my take. By the same token I see the rosy people get eaten alive on a regular basis. #2 I'm in Emergency Medicine and the ED tends to be the flashpoint for everything that's wrong with medicine. The very fact that EDs are as busy as we are is a symptom of the failure of the system.
Medicine is a business and even when you would really like to do right by a patient sometimes you can't. Whatever specialty you are you will need other docs to consult and if your patient is poor/uninsured it's difficult to get docs to do what needs doing. For example, lets say you're a surgeon and you have a patient who needs a chole. If they are broke you may be screwed. Even if you're willing to comp them your services you may not be able to get anesthesia or the hospital to deal with them. In the private practice world these situations are common and draining.
While medicine is a business it's a uniquely bad business in that other entities determine the price you can charge for your efforts. CMS and insurers will tell you what you're worth. The really insidious thing about this is that you will likely reach a point in your life where you depend on making a set amount of money. That means that when your pay gets cut by one (or both) of these entities you will have to take it or work harder to keep even. This is why primary care docs are trying to see 6 patients per hours which no one thinks is a good idea.
Patients have unreasonable expectations of medicine, hospitals, doctors and the system in general. This is America and there should be a pill for every ill. They will not lose weight, eat better, quit smoking or stop drinking but when these choices catch up to them they are happy to blame you for not being able to fix them.
Patients have no concept of risk. You can tell them 'till you're blue in the face that X, Y and Z are risks and may happen to them but they will not understand. Every chronic back pain patient who had a surgery and still has pain had a "botched" surgery as far as they are concerned. Just ask them, they'll keep telling you and you'll never get them to shut up.
Patients have no idea if they got good care or not. They just don't. They will decide they got bad care, and report this to everyone they know and their lawyer, for silly things like their lunch tray was late or the nurse was busy when they wanted a glass of water.
Malpractice and it's demon spawn defensive medicine are bad. They drain the life force out of you and slowly grind you down day after day.
Friends, nurses, acquaintances and so on will want you to write them scripts, sign off on their kid's school physicals, etc. You want to help them but you are under intense regulatory, local and liability pressure to refuse. If you refuse you are a jerk in their eyes because they don't appreciate the real factors and think you are refusing because you don't want to do it for free.
There is a lot of work in medicine. And most of it can't be put off until tomorrow like at an office job. If you're on call and you get 20 admissions you just have to keep going 'til they're all seen. If you're going for 36 hours that's just how it is. One of the things that doesn't get mentioned when people argue about limiting resident work hours is that there is no limit on attending work hours. You work until the work is done.
You watch bad things happen to good people. Patients die. Families grieve. You can't stop it. If you're lucky and good you may help enough people to make up for that and all the rest. If you go into medicine you're betting that you will be that lucky and good.
You watch bad things happen to good people. Patients die. Families grieve. You can't stop it. If you're lucky and good you may help enough people to make up for that and all the rest. If you go into medicine you're betting that you will be that lucky and good.
Medicine reminds us of our mortality and limitations, BUT also our shared humanity.
Yes, patients die. We can only do our best with the limited tools/knowledge that we have to treat and possibly cure our patients.
However, we also bear witness to suffering and death and can do much to palliate symptoms and ease suffering. To me, it is very rewarding to give adequate analgesia to a cancer patient with chemotherapy-resistant disease...to directly talk to a family about their ICU patient loved one's prognosis and help them form a plan for goals of care.
I don't think anyone is "lucky" enough to make up for the reality of death. Granted, I'm a young doc, but I cope by accepting death when my team has exhausted all its curative resources. ...and I have a good cry now and then. 😳)
Now -- the business side of medicine just p****s me off.
...On the other hand, you have a direct effect on people's lives and make a difference every day...
No. No you don't. The majority of the codes, for example, that I have been involved in for at least the past month have been some demented, stroked out, multiply comorbid nursing home space-occupying masses who either died in the ED, died later in the ICU, or were "saved" to return to the nursing home to lay in urine and feces until the next time.
Of course, the 'goobers' and 'crazies' do not count but that is why I am not going into Geriatrics or Psych.
I would commit a hate crime against myself if I had to work with some of the people I see on these boards.
Please, do you mind not posting here until you can say something that's marginally useful?
Yeah, me too! 🙄
..Of course, the 'goobers' and 'crazies' do not count but that is why I am not going into Geriatrics or Psych...
...I am not talking about hero-type procedures but life-impacting decisions that alter the course of people's consciousness...
We do even less of that than saving lives. Man. You are setting yourself up for a huge disappointment.
Unless you decide on Pediatrics, most of your patients are going to be the elderly, many of them are going to be demented, and you'd better start brushing up on your geriatrics.
Looking at my "sticker sheet" from last night, here are the ages of the patients I saw:
56, 75, 72, 12, 38, 87, 92, 88, 3, 21, 26, 67, 78, 78, 80, 82
No. No you don't. The majority of the codes, for example, that I have been involved in for at least the past month have been some demented, stroked out, multiply comorbid nursing home space-occupying masses who either died in the ED, died later in the ICU, or were "saved" to return to the nursing home to lay in urine and feces until the next time.
Different population in the ER, though. Not all of our codes are like that. 🙂
Your view and your patients are influened by your EM specialty and EM experience. It does not make your view right or wrong, just 'your view'.
Well, the ones in the ICU generally are and, as we are on the code team for the hospital, almost every code I go to is for somebody who later dies in the ICU. I know because I follow up.
Whoa. I have also done two years of off-service rotations, everything from general surgery to neurology and, with the exception of OB/Gyn, the majority of my patients have been elderly. I actually see more young patients in the ED than I did on one of my many medicine or surgery rotations.
hey medicine needs suckers like me with our naive optimism.😉
i had naive optimism once too....now i'm in my late 20's, all my friends have decent jobs and go on wonderful vacations during the summer or awesome road trips on the weekends and what am i doing? studying for Step 2 and filling out ERAS apps while racking up an enormous amount of debt. what will i be doing next year? working my butt off at "80 hours" a week, getting paid less than a unionized janitor or garbage man, and having my son raised by a nanny.
oh but i'm not bitter....it's all for the better-ment of humanity, right?
I am sure the average American making $20k-30k per year is crying a river for you.
Get over yourself. Unlike you, some of us worked in the real world of business before med school and it is a black hole compared to the games we play on the road to a financially secure and respected profession.
Sounds like you live in Florida.