Xenon
I know exactly what you are going through...because I am in the same boat. I got a 12, 11, 9 and have yet to get in from last year's application cycle, but am on WL's at UCLA and USC. But the thing is, I DID apply to a very wide range of schools, from the bottom to the top in rankings, and I only got interviews at these two schools! It was hard to believe that I got interviewed and WLed at UCLA, and didn't even get interviews at some less-stellar schools (of which I won't name because I don't want to piss anyone off). Aren't you on the WL for UCLA as well, I always thought you were? (by the way I am am Cali resident, does that have anything to do with the dis-interest of all east coast school with my application?)
TO be honest, I have no advise, but just wanted to join in with your confusion. I guess the only thing that I do know what that application numbers went up during last year (economy, ect...) and perhaps we just had back luck...I doubt I will take my MCAT again( my other stat's are similar to yours), but I also said that I probably wouldn't apply again if I didn't get it, soo...things change with time (I am going to apply again, but wait until next year--since I do have a good job, and want to wait out the WL cycle to the bitter end). Good Luck on your application this year, at least we learned a lot the first time around!
CCHieb's