May 17, 2012
189
3
Status
Medical Student
Hi, I've been lurking around on the forums for awhile now... but am about to apply and wanted to see what you guys think I should do...

I sat for the March MCAT and got 11 PS 5 VR 11 BS...
It was my second time taking the test; I took it last year and got a 10 PS 5 VR 10 BS... but didn't apply last cycle.

What do you guys think?... I would really hate to have to take it again.. I'm mainly applying to DO programs.

My GPA is a 3.5
Thanks guys

Edit:
I also have very strong extracurricular activities such as emergency room, working as a MA, 4 years of research, tutoring, and etc.
 

Temperature101

Membership Revoked
Removed
May 27, 2011
3,487
80
Status
Medical Student
Hi, I've been lurking around on the forums for awhile now... but am about to apply and wanted to see what you guys think I should do...

I sat for the March MCAT and got 11 PS 5 VR 11 BS...
It was my second time taking the test; I took it last year and got a 10 PS 5 VR 10 BS... but didn't apply last cycle.

What do you guys think?... I would really hate to have to take it again.. I'm mainly applying to DO programs.

My GPA is a 3.5
Thanks guys

Edit:
I also have very strong extracurricular activities such as emergency room, working as a MA, 4 years of research, tutoring, and etc.
That VR score might be big impediment to your application even if you are ESOL student. But I think you still have a shot...DO NOT even apply to MD with that VR score.
 
May 17, 2012
189
3
Status
Medical Student
Yeah, I'm not applying to any MD programs.
It's just both times my average AAMC's were landing between 8-12 in verbal (overall 30-34 composite average) but on the day of, just bombed it.

I'm hoping that I will get some love from DO programs :/
Would a retake be a bad idea? lol; but I would hate for my score to drop in the sciences.. I mean God fobid... b/c that never happens :annoyed:
 
About the Ads

Temperature101

Membership Revoked
Removed
May 27, 2011
3,487
80
Status
Medical Student
Yeah, I'm not applying to any MD programs.
It's just both times my average AAMC's were landing between 8-12 in verbal (overall 30-34 composite average) but on the day of, just bombed it.

I'm hoping that I will get some love from DO programs :/
Would a retake be a bad idea? lol; but I would hate for my score to drop in the sciences.. I mean God fobid... b/c that never happens :annoyed:
You should call the DO schools that you are interested in and ask them if they have a cut off score for VR. People on SDN have said that a 6 is the minimum most schools will accept. Find out yourself...I am having the same ****ing problem with VR on my practice test. The curve in VR is crazy.
 

angldrps

10+ Year Member
Oct 23, 2010
1,885
22
Status
Medical Student
You should call the DO schools that you are interested in and ask them if they have a cut off score for VR. People on SDN have said that a 6 is the minimum most schools will accept. Find out yourself...I am having the same ****ing problem with VR on my practice test. The curve in VR is crazy.
Call the schools so you know which schools you shouldn't waste your money applying to since they have minimum cutoffs for Verbal.
 
May 17, 2012
189
3
Status
Medical Student
Yeah I will do that tomorrow. I did call a few last year and they said "oh just apply and see what happens" -.-
 
May 17, 2012
189
3
Status
Medical Student
I called 13 schools today an they all said 11-5-11 is absolutely fine bc they emphasize sciences and "look at the composite score" and told me that I am very competitive... So we'll just see what happens..
 

Ibn Alnafis MD

10+ Year Member
Dec 26, 2008
5,126
3,417
Where the past and the future intersect
forums.studentdoctor.net
Status
Resident [Any Field]
I called 13 schools today an they all said 11-5-11 is absolutely fine bc they emphasize sciences and "look at the composite score" and told me that I am very competitive... So we'll just see what happens..
How many of the schools you called gave you this response? I read on other threads that Touro-NY doesn't care about the verbal section, as long as everything else is on par.
 

TriagePreMed

Membership Revoked
Removed
Apr 28, 2010
6,216
33
Status
I called 13 schools today an they all said 11-5-11 is absolutely fine bc they emphasize sciences and "look at the composite score" and told me that I am very competitive... So we'll just see what happens..
I hope for your own sake, that happens to be the case. However, since the verbal is known as the biggest predictor for the USMLE, I have doubts many programs will be okay with it. Again, I hope I'm wrong.
 
About the Ads

CodeRedDew

Thirst Quencher
Bronze Donor
7+ Year Member
Nov 13, 2011
488
114
Status
Resident [Any Field]
I hope for your own sake, that happens to be the case. However, since the verbal is known as the biggest predictor for the USMLE, I have doubts many programs will be okay with it. Again, I hope I'm wrong.
I've heard otherwise that it is the sciences that correlate the most with your USMLE scores. I mean it makes sense, since the USMLE is composed of sciences and not passages about Picasso and his works.
 

Goro

Gold Donor
10+ Year Member
Jun 10, 2010
62,341
93,445
Somewhere west of St. Louis
Status
Non-Student
The 5 is worrisome, but note necessarily lethal. Keep in mind that the Admissions Office might overlook the 5, but the AdCom might not, especially if you're a native English speaker. It probably would be in your best interest to try one more crack at MCAT. You know what you have to work on now.



Hi, I've been lurking around on the forums for awhile now... but am about to apply and wanted to see what you guys think I should do...

I sat for the March MCAT and got 11 PS 5 VR 11 BS...
It was my second time taking the test; I took it last year and got a 10 PS 5 VR 10 BS... but didn't apply last cycle.

What do you guys think?... I would really hate to have to take it again.. I'm mainly applying to DO programs.

My GPA is a 3.5
Thanks guys

Edit:
I also have very strong extracurricular activities such as emergency room, working as a MA, 4 years of research, tutoring, and etc.
 

JFK90787

Membership Revoked
Removed
Aug 17, 2009
382
1
New England
Status
Pre-Medical
I hope for your own sake, that happens to be the case. However, since the verbal is known as the biggest predictor for the USMLE.
That is absolutely bull crap. Anecdotal evidence, but a girl I work with who speaks English decently but is a terrible reader and writer (ESL) got a basically top 5% step 1 score a few months ago. I'm sure she would be lucky to get a 3 on the VR section.
 

TriagePreMed

Membership Revoked
Removed
Apr 28, 2010
6,216
33
Status
That is absolutely bull crap. Anecdotal evidence, but a girl I work with who speaks English decently but is a terrible reader and writer (ESL) got a basically top 5% step 1 score a few months ago. I'm sure she would be lucky to get a 3 on the VR section.
There's actually been research done on this, so while some people may be an anomaly, like this girl you mention, that's not the case overall.
 

TriagePreMed

Membership Revoked
Removed
Apr 28, 2010
6,216
33
Status
I've heard otherwise that it is the sciences that correlate the most with your USMLE scores. I mean it makes sense, since the USMLE is composed of sciences and not passages about Picasso and his works.
It actually doesn't make sense. The sciences in the MCAT are something you can study a lot and memorize a lot for, whereas verbal is on the spot analysis and critical thinking of new material, which is more similar to the USMLE.
 
May 17, 2012
189
3
Status
Medical Student
I literally called every school today. KCUMB, RVU, TCOM, TOURO-NV, straight up said, a "5" in verbal will not fly.

Every other school said, it doesn't matter HOW you make up the composite score, i.e: 11 5 11 or a 9 9 9, a 27 is a 27. Interesting thing LMU told me was a good writing score can off-set a not-so-good verbal score.

However........ I will most likely pull out the books again
 

CodeRedDew

Thirst Quencher
Bronze Donor
7+ Year Member
Nov 13, 2011
488
114
Status
Resident [Any Field]
It actually doesn't make sense. The sciences in the MCAT are something you can study a lot and memorize a lot for, whereas verbal is on the spot analysis and critical thinking of new material, which is more similar to the USMLE.
But you study for the topics that will show up in the MCAT sciences and you apply what you know to passages/topics you've never seen before, which I believe is how the USMLE is structured. You practically study all of the topics that will show up on the USMLE and then you're presented multiple vignettes you've never seen before and use your background information to solve the problems -- similar to the science sections on the MCAT. With the verbal section, no outside knowledge is needed (which can actually hurt your score) to solve the questions.
 

TriagePreMed

Membership Revoked
Removed
Apr 28, 2010
6,216
33
Status
But you study for the topics that will show up in the MCAT sciences and you apply what you know to passages/topics you've never seen before, which I believe is how the USMLE is structured. You practically study all of the topics that will show up on the USMLE and then you're presented multiple vignettes you've never seen before and use your background information to solve the problems -- similar to the science sections on the MCAT. With the verbal section, no outside knowledge is needed (which can actually hurt your score) to solve the questions.
That's a good counter argument, although verbal doesn't need outside knowledge either. It's simply critical thinking. There is, however, evidence that VR score is the highest predictor for USMLE.
 

CodeRedDew

Thirst Quencher
Bronze Donor
7+ Year Member
Nov 13, 2011
488
114
Status
Resident [Any Field]
That's a good counter argument, although verbal doesn't need outside knowledge either. It's simply critical thinking. There is, however, evidence that VR score is the highest predictor for USMLE.
I said that verbal didn't need any outside knowledge ^_^

But along with critical thinking you have to also be familiar with the nuances of the English language--which many students of different language backgrounds aren't really familiar with and ultimately their score suffers. But that doesn't mean that they have weak critical analysis skills. How else would they receive good scores in the other sections, dont those sections require critical analysis as well? :)
 
May 17, 2012
189
3
Status
Medical Student
here's my initial school list...
A.T. Still – Kirksville
Kirksville, MO (KCOM)
A.T. Still – Arizona
Mesa, AZ
Midwestern @ Arizona
Glendale, AZ
Midwestern @ Chicago
DMUCOM
Des Moines, IA
LECOM
Erie, PA
LECOM-B
Bradenton, FL
LMU-DCOM
Harrogate, TN
MSUCOM
East Lansing, MI
NYCOM
Westbury, NY
NOVA Southeastern
Ft. Lauderdale, FL
PCOM
Philadelphia, PA
PCOM-GA
Suwanee, GA
Touro-NY
New York, NY
Touro-CA
Vallejo, CA
TCOM
Ft. Worth, TX
VCOM-CC
Blacksburg, VA
VCOM-SC
Spartanburg, SC
WVSOM
Lewisburg, WV
WCU
Hattiesburg, MS
 
Last edited:

Napoletana1007

5+ Year Member
May 31, 2012
275
2
Status
Medical Student
I hope for your own sake, that happens to be the case. However, since the verbal is known as the biggest predictor for the USMLE, I have doubts many programs will be okay with it. Again, I hope I'm wrong.
Not true.. I've seen some of the research on this.. Bio has the biggest correlation then physics
 
About the Ads