I purchased a mixture of TBR and TPR books for my retake, and I must say, so far its been much better than when I took Kaplan's class. Kaplan's VR is a joke (waaayyy too easy and detail oriented), their BS is too outside knowledge based, and PS though difficult is not representative of the actual MCAT.
Are there some things in TPR's bio that I think is overkill? Maybe, but it seems more reflective of the MCAT I took in April than Kaplan's skimming. The one thing I'll give Kaplan the edge on is orgo. TPR's orgo is very minimal and doesn't provide many example or go through mechanisms.
edit: Another comment to something you've said, I've never heard of a 3.5 GPA cutoff. Simply is not true. The average matriculant is 3.6-3.7, making a cut off of 3.5 impossible. Look at the AAMC's data for this as well. If there was a 3.5 cutoff, many people on this board might as well give up [myself included].