•••quote:•••Originally posted by AllezLesBleus:
•Hey true1,
I answered "Yes" to the disciplinary action question; I failed a class and it was my school's policy to send a letter of warning from the Dean to any student receiving an F in a class, no matter the reason. (Of course, I had no good reason for failing the class, so this didn't matter to me anyway.) I wasn't sure if it counted as true disciplinary action, so I called my school and asked if it counted as such; they thought it didn't and that I would be fine. In the end I decided to respond "Yes" because I didn't want any admissions committee to think I was trying to cover something up when I wasn't. Moral of this: even if it was for something minor, fess up to it if your school took any action against you.
I explained mine thusly: "I received a Letter of Warning from the Dean of Blah Blah University for receiving an F in Blah Blah class in the fall of Blah Blah." That was it. I figured if a med school had a policy against people who had had disciplinary action against them (that is, if you did you're automatically out), then any explanation was useless; on the other hand, I figured if a school didn't have such a policy, there would be a better place to explain it (namely, secondaries or interviews) and that I didn't need to waste their time--or mine--with anything that smacked of trying to make an excuse. Did this work against me? Perhaps, but I was accepted outright at a couple medical schools and recently got off the waitlist at some well-reputed ones. So, in the end, I don't think the question harmed me.
Now, if you did something truly odious (or stupid) and think that the simple statement of fact is so bad that it will sour most admissions committee members, an explanation (NOT an excuse!) is perhaps warranted. If not, e.g., if you did poorly in a class or series of classes and don't have a close relative deathbed/dying reason, just state what happened and move on. There will be time for explanations later.
I hope this helps, and good luck!•••••I honestly don't think that was disciplinary action. And I don't think anyone at AMCAS or whatever would have thought so, either. It was called a warning, and that's exactly what it was. But you got in, so it doesn't matter, I don't guess.