- Joined
- Apr 11, 2006
- Messages
- 4
- Reaction score
- 0
I was wondering if anyone was having second thoughts about going to med school in Israel because of this current conflict?
newarkpremed said:I was wondering if anyone was having second thoughts about going to med school in Israel because of this current conflict?
a_ditchdoc said:IDFTIGER,
I have tried to look past your inflammatory posts on other threads. Please try not to respond to these threads if you have nothing constructive to say. It seems as if you are just trying to provoke animsosity.
IDFTIGER said:Listen man, as a proud American and Israeli, I can post whatever I want when Israel is in trouble, to support ISRAEL. I don't care if you don't like my posts; don't read them if you don't want.
a_ditchdoc said:It is great to support Israel, but you do not have to be inflammatory about it.
IzzyMD09 said:as for the tiff I see forming on this thread, I would like to remind a-ditchdoc about the first ammendment and the freedom of speech, and I would also like to remind ditchdoc, that throughout studentdoctor.net there is a plethora of anti-Israeli and anti-Semitic resentment that goes unchallenged and unquestioned, so because of that I would like to ask him/her to refrain from hypocrisy and self-righteousness
Izzy
a_ditchdoc said:I do not think I was being a hypocrite or self righteous. I was trying to not let this threat evolve into some pissing contest. There are ways to say things without being inflammatory and I was merely trying toi point that out. Calling me a hypocrite is rather ironic considering I studied here for the past three years while he supposts Israel with his inflammatory remarks from abroad. Who's the Hypocrite? And in addition, can the tone of your last sentence be any more self righteous?
Thanks for helping to keep the thread on topic...
alx943 said:So there are 3 American medical schools in Israel. Sackler, Ben Gurion and Technion. How many students go to technion? What are they doing now since it seems that the actual school is under fire? just curious.
IzzyMD09 said:I am not sure about Technion or Sackler, I know the incoming class at BGU has been delayed a week,
Izzy
alx943 said:They have been delayed a week at BGU? what does that mean? they came late or are coming late by air? Are they there but just not starting?
Everything at Sackler is scheduled to go on as usual--starting Aug 17th for orientation.
alx943 said:How many students go to technion? What are they doing now since it seems that the actual school is under fire? just curious.
IzzyMD09 said:BGU Medical School for International Health has enrolled its largest class to date
46 students beating last years class by 2 people
So as you can see life goes on as usual, despite terrorism
which is the point
secretwave101 said:So, BGU people, what's the word? Has the new class started? Did you have many dropouts? Or, did 46 people really show up?
QuikClot said:Few comments:
* This forum is really not the place for politics, except as they relate to healthcare issues. If you want to praise Zionist Israel or apartheid South Africa or Nazi Germany, there are websites for you all up and down the Internet. This space is for medical stuff. Free speech does not mean any speech, any where.
* Statistically speaking, Israel is a very safe place. You chances of dying at the hands of a religious fundementalist praticing terrorism (the IAF, rather than Hezbollah) are much greater in Gaza, or the West Bank, or Lebanon. Thousands are dying there, not dozens. Real death and destruction come from hanging around with the brown people, not from the paper cut that is the Arab response to Israeli terror.
* If I wanted to go to medical school in Israel (I am actually looking for opportunities in Gaza) it would be because I identified with the people there and their endless struggle to "Keep China British!" as it were. If that were so, it wouldn't discourage me at all to face for a few years the comparably tiny risk of being hurt in an attack. If, on the other hand, you don't identify with them -- why put yourself in the middle of that, even if there were no risk to you personally? Decide where you stand, and live your decision.
QuikClot said:Few comments:
* This forum is really not the place for politics, except as they relate to healthcare issues. If you want to praise Zionist Israel or apartheid South Africa or Nazi Germany, there are websites for you all up and down the Internet. This space is for medical stuff. Free speech does not mean any speech, any where.
* Statistically speaking, Israel is a very safe place. You chances of dying at the hands of a religious fundementalist praticing terrorism (the IAF, rather than Hezbollah) are much greater in Gaza, or the West Bank, or Lebanon. Thousands are dying there, not dozens. Real death and destruction come from hanging around with the brown people, not from the paper cut that is the Arab response to Israeli terror.
* If I wanted to go to medical school in Israel (I am actually looking for opportunities in Gaza) it would be because I identified with the people there and their endless struggle to "Keep China British!" as it were. If that were so, it wouldn't discourage me at all to face for a few years the comparably tiny risk of being hurt in an attack. If, on the other hand, you don't identify with them -- why put yourself in the middle of that, even if there were no risk to you personally? Decide where you stand, and live your decision.
QuikClot said:Few comments:
* This forum is really not the place for politics, except as they relate to healthcare issues. If you want to praise Zionist Israel or apartheid South Africa or Nazi Germany, there are websites for you all up and down the Internet. This space is for medical stuff. Free speech does not mean any speech, any where.
* Statistically speaking, Israel is a very safe place. You chances of dying at the hands of a religious fundementalist praticing terrorism (the IAF, rather than Hezbollah) are much greater in Gaza, or the West Bank, or Lebanon. Thousands are dying there, not dozens. Real death and destruction come from hanging around with the brown people, not from the paper cut that is the Arab response to Israeli terror.
* If I wanted to go to medical school in Israel (I am actually looking for opportunities in Gaza) it would be because I identified with the people there and their endless struggle to "Keep China British!" as it were. If that were so, it wouldn't discourage me at all to face for a few years the comparably tiny risk of being hurt in an attack. If, on the other hand, you don't identify with them -- why put yourself in the middle of that, even if there were no risk to you personally? Decide where you stand, and live your decision.
QuikClot said:Few comments:
* This forum is really not the place for politics, except as they relate to healthcare issues. If you want to praise Zionist Israel or apartheid South Africa or Nazi Germany, there are websites for you all up and down the Internet. This space is for medical stuff. Free speech does not mean any speech, any where.
* Statistically speaking, Israel is a very safe place. You chances of dying at the hands of a religious fundementalist praticing terrorism (the IAF, rather than Hezbollah) are much greater in Gaza, or the West Bank, or Lebanon. Thousands are dying there, not dozens. Real death and destruction come from hanging around with the brown people, not from the paper cut that is the Arab response to Israeli terror.
* If I wanted to go to medical school in Israel (I am actually looking for opportunities in Gaza) it would be because I identified with the people there and their endless struggle to "Keep China British!" as it were. If that were so, it wouldn't discourage me at all to face for a few years the comparably tiny risk of being hurt in an attack. If, on the other hand, you don't identify with them -- why put yourself in the middle of that, even if there were no risk to you personally? Decide where you stand, and live your decision.
secretwave101 said:Don't see why this response is getting so much flack. Just an honest opinion. Maybe a little contradictory, but give the guy a break.
dopaminesurge said:Give the guy a break? He just compared "zionist Israel" to Nazi Germany and Apartheid South Africa. That's what we called ignorant extremism. Also, if he knew anything, he'd know the IAF (Israeli air force) is comprised of the most secular people in Israel. Thank you, indymedia.org reading *****.
Macguyver83 said:Just some quotations ; some from Ben-Gurion's biography...to illustrate just the kind of place Israel is. Its a shame they named a medical school after that terrorist.
Macguyver83 said:"Jewish villages were built in the place of Arab villages. You do not even know the names of these Arab villages, and I do not blame you because geography books no longer exist. Not only do the books not exist, the Arab villages are not there either. Nahlal arose in the place of Mahlul; Kibbutz Gvat in the place of Jibta; Kibbutz Sarid in the place of Huneifis; and Kefar Yehushua in the place of Tal al-Shuman. There is not a single place built in this country that did not have a former Arab population."
Macguyver83 said:"We must expel Arabs and take their places."
DPPM said:I try not to waste my time on political stuff, and I won't say a whole lot, but with such misinformation in the above post, I just have to respond. A lot of those quotes above are either taken out of context (probably to fit your agenda or some other author's), or are just plain fabricated.
I'll just give a couple examples:
That was your quote, but you omitted the part right before which was
"we bought the lands from the Arabs, Jewish villages were built in the place of Arab villages..."
Furthermore, it was a quote by Moshe Dayan from 1969, responding to a student's question suggesting that Israel adopt a policy of punishing Arabs who commit crimes in the West Bank by deportation to Jordan. Dayan's answer (the above quote was part of it) represented his stance, being in opposition to this idea and insisting that the answer to the Arab-Israeli conflict is to learn to live together with Arab neighbors.
Another quote of yours:
The quote, unfortunately, has been hacked up and mistranslated by people like yourself. It has been debunked, but it is still frequently used to propagate hatred. Here is the actual quote in correct translation:
We do not wish, we do not need to expel Arabs and take their place All our aspiration is built on the assumption that there is enough room in the country for ourselves and the Arabs.
Okay, I'm done for now. Back to talking about medicine (hopefully).
On one hand, well, maybe three to four fingers, I think that it is great to show resolve despite terrorism. If it is true like most of is think that this is terrorism, then yes! no matter what, we should not let terrorism run our lives. And I think it is brave and even a standard that will inspire others in the world to live up to that we go on with our lives even though they want us to be afraid and run and hide.
On a few other fingers, (the remaining fingers are sitting on the fence). I really believe that coming to Israel takes faith. Perhaps it is Zionism (and all that the God of Zionism entails) or faith in the Christian God who is your protection and refuge no matter what "physical circumstances" may be. Perhaps it is faith in yourself to become a doctor no matter what. Perhaps it is faith that the goodness of human nature will prevail. Whatever it is for you, I believe that faith is the only reason that people are willing to move to a volatile place like this. WE believe in something--or so it seems.
However, maybe some of us are just so analytical that the statistical evaluation of "perceived danger" has not yet reached a threshold by which to change course--at least for the time being. After all, we are talking about "pre-meds."
Whatever the reason, many have decided to come to Israel for a quality medical education despite "terrorism." On so many levels I applaud us, yet my claps are tempered with the realization that in times like these we examine our inner selves to find if our motives are pure.
Not only did all 46 students show up....but from what I have heard from my