altaskier,
While being in Mad-Town has put me in close proximity to Milwaukee, I'd never really been there before my interview. That said, I loved it. I was accepted and will be attending next year. I know tons of WI residents, and they love the place (the school takes half their class from WI, and gives them a huge break on tuition). A friend of mine works at MCW, in the peds ER, and she loves it. She's from the Milwaukee area, and has worked there (in various capacities) for years. I think that the UW med school is a bit more respected, but MCW is a great place, and seems like a perfect place for me. I love the suburban setting, parking, lack of traffic, etc. I am pumped to go there. Plus, tuition isn't horrible for a private school. Good luck!