Hey, Whatsup
I know very little about the competitiveness of the schools and I base my understanding only on what I read on the forums.
There was a thread a few months ago which asked people what they thought the "best" DO schools were. Many responded and gave lists and Western was missing from every single list. It was this plus another thread intended for the Western students who bitched and moaned about the state of the school, the rotations, the insensitivity of the administration, etc.
Like I said, I don't know, but I agree with you. I looked past all of this garbage and focused instead on the high pass rate of the boards, the varied residency placement (lots of different specialties), the So Cal connection (I grew up in Santa Monica, went to UCLA) and the excellent presentation at the campus last April (Osteopathic Medicine Awareness Conference).
I applied to COMP about 10 years ago and actually had a DREAM that I was accepted! I still remember the feeling. Funny enough, I ended up going to podiatry school and it didn't quite live up to my dream feeling.
I have a book (some Princeton book) which lists all of the medical schools, MD and DO, in the states. From what I read, they are all pretty similar in terms of numbers/GPA. I think Pikeville might have had the lowest overall numbers.