Summary (because I didn't realize how much I just ranted)
Many aspects of NYU are frustrating, but probably the same as other schools.
Some aspects of NYU [anatomy, some of the lab faculty] are awesome.
Prepare to be frustrated rather than amazed, and you will be happier.
NYU is probably not worth 2x the amount of other schools, but it's tough to say something like that from first year.
-------
Kayakfisher, I really envy you your positive attitude. And I type that without the slightest hint of sarcasm - I really, truly wish I could be as positive as you are about NYU.
My take on NYU has been that it is terribly disorganized and frustrating. Professors regularly give incorrect information about their own exam questions. Professors regularly give incorrect or misleading information about what will be tested on the exam. One professor continually insists that "the textbooks and other professors are wrong", and tries to cover himself by saying things like "This is really new information. You won't find this in any textbook yet." This makes studying his exams a wonderful time of unlearning anything you remember from undergrad; trying to decipher his questions is a real treat too.
Many classes are a waste of time but are attendance-based, so you are forced to come in. Scheduling is disjointed and unorganized - in the first two weeks of school we had three professors drop classes completely (I'm terribly sorry guys, I didn't know I had to teach). Ethics. Epidemiology. Health Promotion, dental-patient relationship, dentistry as a science and profession. I hate to say it, but these are all joke classes that I feel have been added to the curriculum only to meet accreditation requirements, with no real thought or planning.
"Technologically savvy" - again, you must be a much more optimistic, patient individual than I am, and I say that, again, without sarcasm. Because when I go to class, what I see is: "Where did my pointer go? For some reason it disappears... oh there it is. Wait... it's gone again." "Hang on guys... TurningPoint isn't working. Let me try that again." "I don't know why Microsoft PowerPoint turns my numbers into symbols... it isn't me, it's Microsoft." "Is the feedback gone? What about now? Can you hear me now? Does anyone know how to turn this thing up?"
On the techy note, though, I do love VitalBook - it crashes a lot, so you have to be gentle, but when it does work, it's really quite awesome being able to Find Function through seventeen different textbooks. Being able to full-screen anatomy pictures on my laptop and zoom in to different pictures while working on my desktop has been a LOT nicer than slicing my textbooks up so I don't have to carry 90 pounds daily.
Actually, my brief time at NYU has felt like a constant hunt for gems in a giant pile of rocks. Many of the lab faculty doesn't care much about waxups; others don't care; but there are a few who will give you calm, measured feedback on your work.
On the plus side, the Anatomy Department has been really amazing to work with - the head of the department is a skilled and entertaining presenter and the supporting faculty have all been very good about helping with understanding details. However, the shoddy quality of the Basic Sciences department [if they are separate departments] makes me feel that I am receiving a crappy version of my NYU Undergraduate education, which I found to be very good.
WHEW. That all said... I imagine it's about the same as any dental school. You will have annoying professors and bad classes and bad lecturers just about anywhere you go. I personally have no reason, as yet, to believe NYU is truly worth the money if you get in elsewhere, but you would need to do a side-by-side comparison of NYU graduates versus graduates of other schools to get a better view.