- Joined
- Jan 10, 2007
- Messages
- 30
- Reaction score
- 0
Hi everyone-- just wanted to get in touch some people I'll be going to school with this coming July
-- Are there any inexpensive apartments next to campus that you guys know of?
I'm not sure about the rest of you, but I was really concerned about ASDOH's accreditation status, "Initial Accreditation - Intent to Withdraw 1/2007," considering that it affected my ability to qualify for student loans, scholarships, and affected my chances of specializing and possibly licensure.
Sir, with all due respect, you're HIGH if you really think "It was NEVER an issue." Are you kidding me, of course it was an issue. If you really think it wasn't an issue, then why don't you take a few minutes and talk to the numerous authorities in the field that make up CODA and evaluate all dental schools nationwide (oh wait, you're a 4th year dental student, so you obviously have more knowledge on the subject compared to them...get real). By saying it was never an issue; you are essentially saying that accreditation is not relevant to schools. From high school, college/university, post-grad, law, medical & dental schools, accreditation is something that can not be taken lightly. Why don't you do a little research and see how many schools in the last 50 years have lost their initial accreditation status during the first 4 years of operation. News flash...ASDOH is king of that prom.It was never an issue, but I'm glad your mind is at ease.
Kind of reminds me of visiting my grandparents farm during my youth in the summers and listening to the 'country kids' talk about big city life even though they had almost no experiences in life outside of their bucolic upbringing.
Sir, with all due respect, you're HIGH if you really think "It was NEVER an issue." Are you kidding me, of course it was an issue. If you really think it wasn't an issue, then why don't you take a few minutes and talk to the numerous authorities in the field that make up CODA and evaluate all dental schools nationwide (oh wait, you're a 4th year dental student, so you obviously have more knowledge on the subject compared to them...get real). By saying it was never an issue; you are essentially saying that accreditation is not relevant to schools. From high school, college/university, post-grad, law, medical & dental schools, accreditation is something that can not be taken lightly.
For those that think this is arrogant or harsh...you need to grow a little thicker skin, step back and understand the underlying point of his post.
Personally, I kind of enjoyed the analogy of growing up in the country vs. the city. I hardly think he was making fun of people that grew up in the country, but merely stating that sheltered kids that have only spent their time on a farm usually have a pretty warped opinion of what its really like in the city (and vice versa). That was not arrogant nor harsh, just stating fact.
My skin is plenty thick, tust me. And I do understand the underlying point and agree with it. However, I just think it is silly to make points from a generalization about people based on where they are from or what they may have or have not experienced. Why would you assume kids are sheltered because they are from the "country? or from a farm? Couldn't the same be true for kids from the city who haven't experienced anything outside of the city? I guess I get tired of the stereotypes and in his context sound harsh and arrogant. Does one think they know more about life because they are from the city?
The one thing I must state after lurking on this forum for a while yet never writing (since I'm not going to dental school next year...that privilege & joy is reserved for my wifeFONT]
Does your wife know you are on here? I admire a man who can let his wife wear the pants. I've found all of these posts super entertaining. especially from the two of you who are knocking people for not being experts on things they know nothing about. It reminds me of a story. Once upon a time there were 2 guys who whose wives were going to go to dental school so they, by proxy, became experts on the subject and taught everyone else, who was already in dental school, a lesson about dental school. the end![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
:
LOL. That was a good one. Yeah, I'm over this 'discussion'...obviously some on here are easily side tracked and miss the main point I was trying to make.I guess us married men with our sugar mama wifes going to dental school next year have to stick together. Cheers.
Sir, with all due respect, you're HIGH if you really think "It was NEVER an issue." Are you kidding me, of course it was an issue. If you really think it wasn't an issue, then why don't you take a few minutes and talk to the numerous authorities in the field that make up CODA and evaluate all dental schools nationwide (oh wait, you're a 4th year dental student, so you obviously have more knowledge on the subject compared to them...get real). By saying it was never an issue; you are essentially saying that accreditation is not relevant to schools. From high school, college/university, post-grad, law, medical & dental schools, accreditation is something that can not be taken lightly. Why don't you do a little research and see how many schools in the last 50 years have lost their initial accreditation status during the first 4 years of operation. News flash...ASDOH is king of that prom.
Granted, the issues seem to be minor and ASDOH appears to be on the cutting edge of teaching students the finer points in the art of dentistry, but if you think the class of 2011 shouldn't have been paying very close attention to this issue and instead just planting their collective heads in the sand, then you really are more high than I originally thought.
Fixcaries was dead on when he/she stated that it was a concern. Very smart. If ASDOH didn't 'Pass' this evaluation, it would have affected all incoming students...from student loans (translation: NO student loan funding on non-accredited school), graduation status and board cert eligibility.
The one thing I must state after lurking on this forum for a while yet never writing (since I'm not going to dental school next year...that privilege & joy is reserved for my wife...and yes, one of the schools she was accepted to is ASDOH and it's at the top of her list for possible schools to attend next year) is the lack of reported fact. With that being said, please don't think I'm bashing the school...to be absolutely clear, I'm bashing your flippant, 'ho-hum' attitude you've demonstrated numerous times on this topic in numerous threads.
I'm blown away with the lack of actual knowledge/fact that is reported by the majority on this forum which is instead replaced with a proliferation of 'he said, she said' rumors that usually prove to have little substance and almost no foundation. Kind of reminds me of visiting my grandparents farm during my youth in the summers and listening to the 'country kids' talk about big city life even though they had almost no experiences in life outside of their bucolic upbringing.
Accreditation is one of the MOST important things a new school strives for, to say it was NEVER an issue even though numerous authorities (with over a centuries worth of expertise in the field of dentistry) deemed there were sufficient deficiencies at ASDOH to warrant a status change to the '...w/ intent to withdraw' classification WAS a big deal.
It's NOT common, it was NOT good and it WAS an issue. But then again what do you care...unlike the class of 2011 (if CODAs ruling wouldn't have been favorable) you had your student loans secured almost 4 years ago and no matter what happened at the end of JAN, you would still be eligible for board cert upon graduation.
NEWSFLASH: I hope you work on teeth better than your spelling/grammar.NEWSFLASH to those who don't got to dental school but think they know all: CODA told us students here at ASDOH that it wasn't a big deal and never was. There was a communication error to CODA about what was already being done at ASDOH. CODA didn't understand what had been presented in a report and needed to come out in JAN and see for themselves. CODA explained to us students who actually attend the school the "Intent to Withdrawl" was only a formality. There was never any real concern on the part of CODA or the school that there would be a loss of accredidation.
So, can i guess that you know-it-alls are really just a couple of farm boys?
NEWSFLASH: I hope you work on teeth better than your spelling/grammar.
Also, you left out a few deficiencies that CODA had to re-evaluate...but I can't say I was very surprised to see a response like this. There's nothing like telling half the story to defend your position.
You don't have to be a current student to evaluate CODAs findings...if anything, those of us that are not current students are probably looking at this issue with much more unbiased eyes than those of you that seem to take any mention of CODA stripping your beloved school of accreditation as a direct, personal slap in the face. If it was never an issue and you truly believe this fact, then why even bother defending yourself so adamantly to all us ignorant country bumpkins? Kind of makes you think...hummmm....
Rock on man, whatever floats your boat.
Yep, very angry...you nailed it Sherlock. Thanks for the entertaining exchange, it's been real. Would love to keep chatting about this captivating topic, but I've got to go kick the dog now. Cheers.I guess then what you are asking current and applying applicants to do, is to pay more attention to your ranting, than to what was told by CODA representitives to current students during a meeting that took place at their last site visit. I haven't quite figured out your real intentions, but you do come across as angry! Man, I'm sorry if this has just been a rough day and you needed to take it out on your computer......
I've done a lot of research on this topic over the last couple of days, and although I still don't know much, what I have found out is that withdrawal of accreditation is not something that happens automatically, nor does it happen quickly. In fact, a program must be on probation for 2 years before its accreditation is taken away. During this time, they can "fix" whatever problems there are, pay their fees, and regain accreditation.
New schools such as ASDOH cannot gain accreditation until they graduate their first class, which will occur in the next few months.
As far as other dental schools that have lost accreditation, I have not found any (and would appreciate it if verdugo could send this information to me). Of course accreditation should be important to everyone planning on going to Arizona. They made it seem to us during our interview that it was not a big deal, and that they will, in fact become fully accredited once they do graduate the D4s, and that the intent to withdraw was strictly a miscommunication.
I would take faculty and current student's advise as to what CODA was up to, and what they were looking for exactly more than I'd take anyone here posting that there have been xxx amount of schools which have lost their initial accreditation. This has almost nothing to do with ASDOH. These schools may have other circumstances, or may not have wanted to keep accreditation.
I challenge you, verdugo, to post facts: ie which schools have lost accreditation, and exactly why it was so. Also, I'd like to know if you know of any issues regarding ASDOH's accreditation status that may hinder their approval. If you have merely stated that it is an issue, I'd have to agree with you. Of course it is always an issue/concern. If ASDOH had specific problems which were not easily correctable, they would (or should) have told their current and prospective students. I would be absolutely shocked if they didn't gain accreditation this year.
My main point, and something that I think MANY on this forum have quickly forgotten about or simply missed, was the very simple fact that ASDOHs accreditation status change WAS a big deal & should NOT be taken lightly...especially for incoming, class of 2011, students.
Goodness, people! You're scaring meEven though I've accepted somewhere else, I'd like to just point out that I started this thread so that those who've accepted at ASDOH can meet each other (in a happy, oh so happy way
) Peace
.