Kiki,
I like to maintain my anonymity, so I'd prefer not to divulge my program, however, I can answer your other questions. Currently, neuro is not an especially competitive field so I only accepted 6 interviews...including 2 top 25 programs. Neuro is becoming more popular, but I doubt it'll ever be a really competitive area, so don't stress too much (neurosurg is an entirely different story). Anyway, I wanted to get the inside scoop on a few programs (I was a little obsessive about ending up in a benign program, close to home) so I arranged elective time at my top 3 choices. Boy, did that help! Not only did it give me an edge, but it really helped me realize what was and wasn't important in a training program! Now, what is and isn't important will vary somewhat from person to person, but for me, my priorities (after location) were, 1. receiving great training in a BENIGN setting, 2. board pass rates, 3. fellowship opportunities and 4. work load/weekly schedule (days off). I wasn't obsessed with being in a top 25 program (some of them are REALLY malignant...you sacrifice happiness for prestige). In the end I was able to find it ALL, so it is possible, but you'll have to determine for yourself what is and isn't important, then try to use elective time to help you narrow your choices.
As for "why neuro"? It's kind of a weird story, but here goes. I have, for a long time, been interested in pain management. Although I thoroughly enjoyed my freshman neuro course, I never really considered it as a specialty choice...not sure why...just assumed I'd end up in anesthesiology. That all changed during my 3rd year rotations. To my surprise, I HATED my anesthesiology rotation...knew on the FIRST day that I wouldn't be going into that field! At that point I felt pretty lost and didn't know what I wanted. A couple of months later I did a neuro rotation...absolutely LOVED it...still not sure why. Anyway, I soon found out that I could pursue PM as a neurologist and that sealed the deal! However, looking back, it seems like I just wasn't paying attention to my interests. I'd done really well in my freshman neuro course and on SEVERAL occasions during the 2nd yr (path and micro courses), ended up choosing neuro conditions as topics for case studies and reports. Just goes to show you that you should pay attention to what you find interesting and avoid tunnel vision. Hope this helps
.