Can you review my essay?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

sepaul

Senior Member
7+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
20+ Year Member
Joined
Aug 2, 2003
Messages
119
Reaction score
1
Hello all,

I am about to finish with my APP and ma stuck on my essay. This is like draft 7 or so. Can you give me some comments?

Thanks,
Sepaul

Before the age of 27 my parents had died of cancer. Both underwent chemotherapy and radiation therapy and later benefited from meditation and exercise. After a bout with tuberculosis I caught on the Iberian Peninsula, my focus shifted from the politics of Mexico-US border issues to pursuing a career in medicine.

As a freshman at the University of California at Davis I was determined to study medicine. A heavy science load combined with na?ve study skills resulted in poor grades. On the advice of my father, a psychiatrist, I enrolled in Intro to Psychology and a Spanish course. Growing up in the Sacramento Valley, spending time at with friends at quinceneras and picnics allowed me to pick up Spanish. Spanish classes in high school and university deepened my friendships while fueling my desire to understand the relation between language and the mind. I took a teaching assistant position at the Davis High Migrant Mathematics program to explore this relationship.

Raul, a seventh grader, had faith that academics could lift him out of his dilapidated house in rural Yolo County. Raul and his family had limited access to health care. I enrolled in the education abroad program at the University of Granada in Spain with the goal of majoring in Spanish and psychology. The striking similarities between the Moroccan shantytowns of the farming communities of rural Andalusia and Yolo County solidified my desire to stay involved in my community. Despite boasting a bustling economy, like in California, Spain grappled with the quagmire of providing healthcare and education to immigrants.

Towards the end of winter quarter of my senior year, I fell ill to tuberculosis. Suffering from a chronic cough, weight loss, headaches and lethargy, my attendance and grades plummeted. After a positive skin test doctors discovered a lung cavitation the size of a large walnut. The severity of my condition called for intensive three-drug therapy for an entire year. Six months later I applied and was accepted to a graduate school renowned for both their language program and focus on Mexican-American border issues.

While at the Monterey Institute of International Studies, my mother?s breast cancer reoccurred. Two years before she underwent aggressive treatment including surgery, chemotherapy and radiation and unfortunately the doctors had exhausted all medical treatment. During this time, my mother was introduced to Barbara, a cancer survivor. Her cancer would grow and regress, much to the surprise of her doctors. Barbara educated my mother on the benefits of eating organic foods and stress reduction through meditation and exercise. My mother diligently followed her spiritual and nutritional plan and it unleashed newfound energy. Vigorous walks were central to my mother?s health. I have vivid memories of strolls along the walnut groves by our family home. When my legs faltered my mother would insist politely we keep pace.

Medicine gave her three years of life, but, it was her sense of humor throughout the worst of times that helped my six siblings and I cope. She gracefully endured the pain for many months, finally passing away one day after her sixtieth birthday.


My mother?s strength throughout her illness solidified my desire to leave international relations and pursue a medical degree. I took classes and worked at the Scripps Research Institute as a Scientific Intern quickly advancing up the ranks to Lab Technician level. Traveling twice a month to La Esperanza, a community clinic supporting the indigent of Tijuana, provided invaluable insights into medical care. La Esperanza trains health promoters to educate the community on prevention of diseases like cervical cancer and management of chronic aliments like diabetes. I spent my time translating for patients and an internist, Dr. Biederman, who explained to me diagnostic information, treatment options and how he formulated his conclusion. On our ride across the border, we discussed how familial support, sanitation; allocation of resources, and community empowerment could provide the essential components of healthy living on the Tijuana border.

Tragedy struck once again when doctors diagnosed my father with esophageal cancer. My father?s cancer was an unsettling reminder of my struggle to accept my mother?s mortality. Through my dialogue with death and my exposure chronic disease in Tijuana, I was able to accept his death and embrace the time we shared. After completing chemotherapy and radiation, his cancer aggressively returned. My father continued to perform his duties as medical director of a state run methadone clinic and faithfully practice Tai Chi until he passed away six months later.

Before I started college, I only aspired to be a physician, now I have learned that attaining this goal will bring a sense of fulfillment and joy. My most powerful motivation to pursue medicine is embodied in the spirit in which my parents embraced life. In truth, disease only eroded away the bodies of my parents, but their unrelenting passion to live is source of my strength.
 
Sepaul,
I read your essay and this is what i think-
Its very heartfelt and genuine, and your ending is very impactful.
However, If you can, work on the chronological sequence of events that you present to the reader. You seem to be jumping back and forth in time and it can be confusing if one does not know you personally. You have some great ideas. OVerall its good, but I would just work on the first para a little bit. Same idea, just word it better to catch the readers attention.
Also, the part about Raol felt irrelevant.

Hope this helps!
Good luck!




sepaul said:
Hello all,

I am about to finish with my APP and ma stuck on my essay. This is like draft 7 or so. Can you give me some comments?

Thanks,
Sepaul

Before the age of 27 my parents had died of cancer. Both underwent chemotherapy and radiation therapy and later benefited from meditation and exercise. After a bout with tuberculosis I caught on the Iberian Peninsula, my focus shifted from the politics of Mexico-US border issues to pursuing a career in medicine.

As a freshman at the University of California at Davis I was determined to study medicine. A heavy science load combined with na?ve study skills resulted in poor grades. On the advice of my father, a psychiatrist, I enrolled in Intro to Psychology and a Spanish course. Growing up in the Sacramento Valley, spending time at with friends at quinceneras and picnics allowed me to pick up Spanish. Spanish classes in high school and university deepened my friendships while fueling my desire to understand the relation between language and the mind. I took a teaching assistant position at the Davis High Migrant Mathematics program to explore this relationship.

Raul, a seventh grader, had faith that academics could lift him out of his dilapidated house in rural Yolo County. Raul and his family had limited access to health care. I enrolled in the education abroad program at the University of Granada in Spain with the goal of majoring in Spanish and psychology. The striking similarities between the Moroccan shantytowns of the farming communities of rural Andalusia and Yolo County solidified my desire to stay involved in my community. Despite boasting a bustling economy, like in California, Spain grappled with the quagmire of providing healthcare and education to immigrants.

Towards the end of winter quarter of my senior year, I fell ill to tuberculosis. Suffering from a chronic cough, weight loss, headaches and lethargy, my attendance and grades plummeted. After a positive skin test doctors discovered a lung cavitation the size of a large walnut. The severity of my condition called for intensive three-drug therapy for an entire year. Six months later I applied and was accepted to a graduate school renowned for both their language program and focus on Mexican-American border issues.

While at the Monterey Institute of International Studies, my mother?s breast cancer reoccurred. Two years before she underwent aggressive treatment including surgery, chemotherapy and radiation and unfortunately the doctors had exhausted all medical treatment. During this time, my mother was introduced to Barbara, a cancer survivor. Her cancer would grow and regress, much to the surprise of her doctors. Barbara educated my mother on the benefits of eating organic foods and stress reduction through meditation and exercise. My mother diligently followed her spiritual and nutritional plan and it unleashed newfound energy. Vigorous walks were central to my mother?s health. I have vivid memories of strolls along the walnut groves by our family home. When my legs faltered my mother would insist politely we keep pace.

Medicine gave her three years of life, but, it was her sense of humor throughout the worst of times that helped my six siblings and I cope. She gracefully endured the pain for many months, finally passing away one day after her sixtieth birthday.


My mother?s strength throughout her illness solidified my desire to leave international relations and pursue a medical degree. I took classes and worked at the Scripps Research Institute as a Scientific Intern quickly advancing up the ranks to Lab Technician level. Traveling twice a month to La Esperanza, a community clinic supporting the indigent of Tijuana, provided invaluable insights into medical care. La Esperanza trains health promoters to educate the community on prevention of diseases like cervical cancer and management of chronic aliments like diabetes. I spent my time translating for patients and an internist, Dr. Biederman, who explained to me diagnostic information, treatment options and how he formulated his conclusion. On our ride across the border, we discussed how familial support, sanitation; allocation of resources, and community empowerment could provide the essential components of healthy living on the Tijuana border.

Tragedy struck once again when doctors diagnosed my father with esophageal cancer. My father?s cancer was an unsettling reminder of my struggle to accept my mother?s mortality. Through my dialogue with death and my exposure chronic disease in Tijuana, I was able to accept his death and embrace the time we shared. After completing chemotherapy and radiation, his cancer aggressively returned. My father continued to perform his duties as medical director of a state run methadone clinic and faithfully practice Tai Chi until he passed away six months later.

Before I started college, I only aspired to be a physician, now I have learned that attaining this goal will bring a sense of fulfillment and joy. My most powerful motivation to pursue medicine is embodied in the spirit in which my parents embraced life. In truth, disease only eroded away the bodies of my parents, but their unrelenting passion to live is source of my strength.
 
sepaul,

this looks like a warm, personal essay. I agree with the first appearance, it looks a little over the place. you need to hone on what you want to say and next time ask for people to look over essays thru PM,d on't post it.

Best of luck
 
this essay has the greatest potential to be one of th best....however, in its present state it is not very organized...but i think that with a little work its going to be wicked!
 
You have received some sound advice on this essay so far, and it has immense potential. I do agree that it should flow a little better, you should cut out some of the details and probably leave out the part about TB. One thing that I would like to suggest is that you should speak more about why you want to become a physician. Let the readers get more of a sense about who you are as a person and why you are so passionate about medicine. How did your parents' passing and your health problems motivate you to become a physician? That, IMHO, should be should be the theme for which to base your essay. The time you spent doing other things is great, and certainly deserve mentioning. Just leave out some of the details to make more room to talk about things that will give people a better sense of who you are.
 
You have rich experiences to talk about, they just need to be better organized and more concise (remember, these adcoms have to wade through thousands of these.) Personally, I?d start with a catchy lead in sentence and move through your experiences chronologically. I don?t think you need to bring in the death of your parents in the first sentence, cause then you leave it hanging and don?t get back to it until much later. Without a better tie in, this seems kind of rambling.

Suggest starting with something like ?Growing up in the Sacramento Valley, my childhood friends taught be Spanish, how to dance at Quinceneras and the importance of community involvement. I also saw the consequences of inadequate health care for immigrants?? (do you have a short story or anecdote to illustrate this). ?In college, I continued my study of Spanish and international?? (then stuff related to this). Then move into how your Moroccan experiences renewed your interest in health care to immigrants. Just a suggestion, lots of way to organize it, but needs a flow from one topic to the next that connects.

Certainly the death of your parents is extremely important (and sad), but I?d spend a little less time describing the details of their illnesses, and concentrate on what you learned (i.e. more about you and less about them.) For example, when you talk about your mother?s use of alternate health means, rather than describe them in detail, say something like ?as I watched the strength my mother found in meditation, exercise and organic diet, I learned about the importance of understanding an individual?s spiritual beliefs and emotional health.? ? (something like that.) Something like this tie into your work in La Esperanza (differences in medical care, culture, etc.)

Basically, you want to tie all these experiences together to show how it?s formed not only your desire to be a physician, but to be a physician working within a community, or the indigent, or whatever is true for you.

You have so much stuff to talk about, that it will be difficult to decide what to leave out to keep it short enough and to the point. But don?t worry, when you start writing all the secondary essays, you get plenty more opportunities to discuss experiences that aren?t in your personal statement. In fact, at that point, you?re glad you didn?t cover everything here!

Best of luck.
 
I agree with synapster and everyone else, it's very heart felt and especially the end is powerful, but it's difficult to follow the chronology.

Don't start with saying your parents died, or do it in a different way. It seemed like they were already dead and then you talked about them again as if they were alive and then you say they died.
 
Top