- Joined
- Aug 9, 2013
- Messages
- 136
- Reaction score
- 41
I am fortunate to be in a position of holding acceptances to my top 2 choices this application cycle: CCLCM and University of Wisconsin-Madison. The choice may seem simple, but it really is not.
CCLCM gives full tuition scholarships to all (32) accepted applicants, so CCLCM clearly had the edge (for other reasons, too, of course) over UW-Madison, especially since I am an OOS student for the latter. I was shocked, however, to find out a few days ago that I also received a full tuition scholarship to UW-Madison. So, I'm in the position of choosing one of these programs without the need to really factor cost/debt into the equation. (Additional info: wait-listed at Hopkins, withdrew my application from Harvard post-interview, and accepted to Tulane, though I am not interested in attending there given my other choices.)
Curriculum
The curriculum is completely different when comparing these two programs. CCLCM, on the one hand, is primarily PBL in a seminar setting (groups of 8) with no grades, no exams, etc. UW-Madison, on the other hand, is lecture-style with pass/fail the first year and A/B/C/D the second year (IIRC). I don't like the idea of a graded system the second year at Madison. As a graduate student in the humanities with a bachelor's in both a social science and a natural science, I enjoy both seminary-style learning and lecture-style learning; however, I am not really sure what seminar style, PBL learning looks like for a field like medicine.
CCLCM is 5 years, and UW-Madison is 4 years; however, I plan to pursue an MA at both institutions so the 4yr vs. 5yr situation is somewhat irrelevant, though the master's degree would be covered by the scholarship at CCLCM and not covered by the scholarship at UW-Madison. I'm not sure, though, if this is really a deal breaker at the moment. CCLCM gives a free computer and long white coat to its students, but that's not really important to me in the grand scheme of things and not a reason to choose a medical school.
In terms of other clinical factors, CCLCM, I hear, offers privileges tantamount to interns in a lot of situations around the Cleveland Clinic (also, no grades for rotations, right?), but UW-Madison's placement of 3rd-yr and 4th-yr med students around the states for a total of 4-5 months means a lot more one-on-one interaction with Attendings in private practice, rural clinics, etc, which, I've been told, results in a pretty cool "hands-on" approach as opposed to being at a place with a LOT of attendings, residents, fellows, etc.
Research
Ultimately, I want to be a physician practicing at a teaching hospital for a number of reasons I delineated in both application essays and interviews, but without going into any detail and pertinent to this post, I want to both practice medicine and research/teach (the details of which are still murky). I'm interested in public health and medical anthropology research, and I have a strong affinity for the history of medicine and ethics. CCLCM seems more geared towards laboratory and clinical research, but it is possible to get degrees in either public health or bioethics, and they have some cool opportunities in medical humanities, too. Of course, I think the 2.5 months of lab-based research to start off medical school at CCLCM pretty cool!! UW-Madison seems to have a much stronger research emphasis on public health and a general multi-disciplinary approach to medicine in the context of public health (medical anthropology, medical sociology, etc), though I could always get a master's in med anthro at Case Western (though not paid for). So, both offer research opportunities and additional opportunities to study disciplines pertinent to medicine that interest me.
Rankings
Honestly, rankings and the name of the school don't really do a lot for me and are not really determining factors. Cleveland Clinic hospital is clearly a top-4 U.S. hospital, and UW-Madison as a medical school is top-22 or so in research rankings and top-10, I think..., in primary care (a pretty solid balance!). My guess is that I will probably "see" more at Cleveland compared to UW-Madison? Also, the population of Madison seems fairly homogenous compared to Cleveland. Both Madison and CCLCM have impressive match lists (as far as I can even comment on this process, which I really can't) in areas that I am potentially interested in (IM, EM... though that is always bound to change, right?).
City and People
I was not a huge fan of Cleveland in general, but I really loved Madison. I am an avid runner, and it seems like there is better areas for running in Madison compared to Cleveland, though the Emerald Necklace in Cleveland seemed nice.
As for people, I honestly had very pleasant experiences at both schools with interviewees, current medical students, and faculty! Both places seem like they have incredible people. CCLCM seems like it fosters a more intimate environment since there's only 32 students, and on interview day Dean Franco seemed to know everything about every medical student we passed. That was cool! UW-Madison, though, seemed like a less intimate environment than CCLCM, and the students I talked to said they did not really know a number of their classmates. On the one hand, all the attention a student gets at CCLCM seems pretty freaking awesome (!!), but it seems like it has the potential for that "I'm really being micro-managed" feeling (which I am not opposed to). On the other hand, it seems like one is far less managed at Madison and not forced to learn a certain way, which can be a good thing or bad thing depending on how you look at it. I'm neutral to both, which makes it difficult to choose which I would like more.
Miscellaneous
CCLCM students have access to all-things Case Western Reserve University, two mentors, the Cleveland Clinic hospital (amazing), etc. Madison students have access to all of Wisconsin to learn medicine, a lot more outdoor activities from what I can ascertain (again, I'm a runner), and the city (amazing).
Thankfully, I don't really have to decide until mid-April, but it's still a tough decision. Do any of you see something that I am saying or not saying that I might be missing? Honestly, I love both programs despite the fact that both programs are so different. Both excite me! But I can't attend both....
CCLCM gives full tuition scholarships to all (32) accepted applicants, so CCLCM clearly had the edge (for other reasons, too, of course) over UW-Madison, especially since I am an OOS student for the latter. I was shocked, however, to find out a few days ago that I also received a full tuition scholarship to UW-Madison. So, I'm in the position of choosing one of these programs without the need to really factor cost/debt into the equation. (Additional info: wait-listed at Hopkins, withdrew my application from Harvard post-interview, and accepted to Tulane, though I am not interested in attending there given my other choices.)
Curriculum
The curriculum is completely different when comparing these two programs. CCLCM, on the one hand, is primarily PBL in a seminar setting (groups of 8) with no grades, no exams, etc. UW-Madison, on the other hand, is lecture-style with pass/fail the first year and A/B/C/D the second year (IIRC). I don't like the idea of a graded system the second year at Madison. As a graduate student in the humanities with a bachelor's in both a social science and a natural science, I enjoy both seminary-style learning and lecture-style learning; however, I am not really sure what seminar style, PBL learning looks like for a field like medicine.
CCLCM is 5 years, and UW-Madison is 4 years; however, I plan to pursue an MA at both institutions so the 4yr vs. 5yr situation is somewhat irrelevant, though the master's degree would be covered by the scholarship at CCLCM and not covered by the scholarship at UW-Madison. I'm not sure, though, if this is really a deal breaker at the moment. CCLCM gives a free computer and long white coat to its students, but that's not really important to me in the grand scheme of things and not a reason to choose a medical school.
In terms of other clinical factors, CCLCM, I hear, offers privileges tantamount to interns in a lot of situations around the Cleveland Clinic (also, no grades for rotations, right?), but UW-Madison's placement of 3rd-yr and 4th-yr med students around the states for a total of 4-5 months means a lot more one-on-one interaction with Attendings in private practice, rural clinics, etc, which, I've been told, results in a pretty cool "hands-on" approach as opposed to being at a place with a LOT of attendings, residents, fellows, etc.
Research
Ultimately, I want to be a physician practicing at a teaching hospital for a number of reasons I delineated in both application essays and interviews, but without going into any detail and pertinent to this post, I want to both practice medicine and research/teach (the details of which are still murky). I'm interested in public health and medical anthropology research, and I have a strong affinity for the history of medicine and ethics. CCLCM seems more geared towards laboratory and clinical research, but it is possible to get degrees in either public health or bioethics, and they have some cool opportunities in medical humanities, too. Of course, I think the 2.5 months of lab-based research to start off medical school at CCLCM pretty cool!! UW-Madison seems to have a much stronger research emphasis on public health and a general multi-disciplinary approach to medicine in the context of public health (medical anthropology, medical sociology, etc), though I could always get a master's in med anthro at Case Western (though not paid for). So, both offer research opportunities and additional opportunities to study disciplines pertinent to medicine that interest me.
Rankings
Honestly, rankings and the name of the school don't really do a lot for me and are not really determining factors. Cleveland Clinic hospital is clearly a top-4 U.S. hospital, and UW-Madison as a medical school is top-22 or so in research rankings and top-10, I think..., in primary care (a pretty solid balance!). My guess is that I will probably "see" more at Cleveland compared to UW-Madison? Also, the population of Madison seems fairly homogenous compared to Cleveland. Both Madison and CCLCM have impressive match lists (as far as I can even comment on this process, which I really can't) in areas that I am potentially interested in (IM, EM... though that is always bound to change, right?).
City and People
I was not a huge fan of Cleveland in general, but I really loved Madison. I am an avid runner, and it seems like there is better areas for running in Madison compared to Cleveland, though the Emerald Necklace in Cleveland seemed nice.
As for people, I honestly had very pleasant experiences at both schools with interviewees, current medical students, and faculty! Both places seem like they have incredible people. CCLCM seems like it fosters a more intimate environment since there's only 32 students, and on interview day Dean Franco seemed to know everything about every medical student we passed. That was cool! UW-Madison, though, seemed like a less intimate environment than CCLCM, and the students I talked to said they did not really know a number of their classmates. On the one hand, all the attention a student gets at CCLCM seems pretty freaking awesome (!!), but it seems like it has the potential for that "I'm really being micro-managed" feeling (which I am not opposed to). On the other hand, it seems like one is far less managed at Madison and not forced to learn a certain way, which can be a good thing or bad thing depending on how you look at it. I'm neutral to both, which makes it difficult to choose which I would like more.
Miscellaneous
CCLCM students have access to all-things Case Western Reserve University, two mentors, the Cleveland Clinic hospital (amazing), etc. Madison students have access to all of Wisconsin to learn medicine, a lot more outdoor activities from what I can ascertain (again, I'm a runner), and the city (amazing).
Thankfully, I don't really have to decide until mid-April, but it's still a tough decision. Do any of you see something that I am saying or not saying that I might be missing? Honestly, I love both programs despite the fact that both programs are so different. Both excite me! But I can't attend both....