CHOOSE YOUR OWWN IV - Game Thread

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Aff claims:
12/8 9:04 PM - shorty, miller
12/8 9:07 PM - Zenge, vengeful townie
12/8 9:08 PM - fruit, town vanilla cop
12/8 9:16 PM - samac, town mason
12/8 9:22 PM - CeeGee, town cop/lover
12/8 9:22 PM - apop, vanillager
12/8 9:25 PM - genny, town reloader
12/8 9:32 PM - alissa, evangelistic town
12/8 9:38 PM - Spurs, town inno child
12/8 9:52 PM - Dubz, town enabler
12/8 10:09 PM - beans, town nurse
12/8 10:26 PM - kitz, town fruit vendor
12/8 10:35 PM - Clem, town tourist
12/8 11:35 PM - rae, vanillager
12/8 11:58 PM - Barky - town tracker
12/9 8:14 AM - SAR, town seer
12/9 9:45 AM - PSV, vanillager

I do also have numbers for how many exist on the role list and how many would be possible in the game if everyone is being truthful, however, since the exercise didn't catch any obvious slip-ups this game, I'm not going to post those at this time unless someone wants it, and then I'll take a screenshot of my spreadsheet or something.
 
Aff claims:
12/8 9:04 PM - shorty, miller
12/8 9:07 PM - Zenge, vengeful townie
12/8 9:08 PM - fruit, town vanilla cop
12/8 9:16 PM - samac, town mason
12/8 9:22 PM - CeeGee, town cop/lover
12/8 9:22 PM - apop, vanillager
12/8 9:25 PM - genny, town reloader
12/8 9:32 PM - alissa, evangelistic town
12/8 9:38 PM - Spurs, town inno child
12/8 9:52 PM - Dubz, town enabler
12/8 10:09 PM - beans, town nurse
12/8 10:26 PM - kitz, town fruit vendor
12/8 10:35 PM - Clem, town tourist
12/8 11:35 PM - rae, vanillager
12/8 11:58 PM - Barky - town tracker
12/9 8:14 AM - SAR, town seer
12/9 9:45 AM - PSV, vanillager

I do also have numbers for how many exist on the role list and how many would be possible in the game if everyone is being truthful, however, since the exercise didn't catch any obvious slip-ups this game, I'm not going to post those at this time unless someone wants it, and then I'll take a screenshot of my spreadsheet or something.
I want pls
 
1765291733029.png


A lot of people claiming aff vanillager, and a lot of confirmed discards of vanillager. I suppose it is probably the most common rand, however.
 
Vanillager is also the safest thing to claim if not being entirely truthful because of how many of them could exist.

That does NOT mean I am sussing people who claim vanillager for aff, but it is an observation.
 
Aff claims:
12/8 9:04 PM - shorty, miller
12/8 9:07 PM - Zenge, vengeful townie
12/8 9:08 PM - fruit, town vanilla cop
12/8 9:16 PM - samac, town mason
12/8 9:22 PM - CeeGee, town cop/lover
12/8 9:22 PM - apop, vanillager
12/8 9:25 PM - genny, town reloader
12/8 9:32 PM - alissa, evangelistic town
12/8 9:38 PM - Spurs, town inno child
12/8 9:52 PM - Dubz, town enabler
12/8 10:09 PM - beans, town nurse
12/8 10:26 PM - kitz, town fruit vendor
12/8 10:35 PM - Clem, town tourist
12/8 11:35 PM - rae, vanillager
12/8 11:58 PM - Barky - town tracker
12/9 8:14 AM - SAR, town seer
12/9 9:45 AM - PSV, vanillager

I do also have numbers for how many exist on the role list and how many would be possible in the game if everyone is being truthful, however, since the exercise didn't catch any obvious slip-ups this game, I'm not going to post those at this time unless someone wants it, and then I'll take a screenshot of my spreadsheet or something.
Okay but my spreadsheet has colors 😡
 
View attachment 412558

A lot of people claiming aff vanillager, and a lot of confirmed discards of vanillager. I suppose it is probably the most common rand, however.
It's Enabler. My tired brain just remembered it was something with an "En" and then I was like "maybe I should double check" and then I did and realized I'd errored

I believe Enforcer exists as a thing but I'm not sure if it does in this setup lol
 
There's a slash between them, it's a real role
Not according to Shorty, I didn't
This progression actually feels a little weird to me? The "according to shorty" bit I understand is meant to be a joke, but it feels more like "haha see, it's real! Phew..." idk. I mean, I see it's a real role, but... hm.
i can't believe so many people discarded vanillager.
Why be basic when you could be ADVANCED?
Well.... there it is
Hmm?
 
Aff claims:
12/8 9:04 PM - shorty, miller
12/8 9:07 PM - Zenge, vengeful townie
12/8 9:08 PM - fruit, town vanilla cop
12/8 9:16 PM - samac, town mason
12/8 9:22 PM - CeeGee, town cop/lover
12/8 9:22 PM - apop, vanillager
12/8 9:25 PM - genny, town reloader
12/8 9:32 PM - alissa, evangelistic town
12/8 9:38 PM - Spurs, town inno child
12/8 9:52 PM - Dubz, town enabler
12/8 10:09 PM - beans, town nurse
12/8 10:26 PM - kitz, town fruit vendor
12/8 10:35 PM - Clem, town tourist
12/8 11:35 PM - rae, vanillager
12/8 11:58 PM - Barky - town tracker
12/9 8:14 AM - SAR, town seer
12/9 9:45 AM - PSV, vanillager

I do also have numbers for how many exist on the role list and how many would be possible in the game if everyone is being truthful, however, since the exercise didn't catch any obvious slip-ups this game, I'm not going to post those at this time unless someone wants it, and then I'll take a screenshot of my spreadsheet or something.
Im sussing all vanillagers cause thats BORING /lh
 
@GoSpursGo I feel like last game, you were suspicious of Clem pretty quickly and strongly, whereas right now, you're town reading him. Can you talk to me about the difference you're seeing from this game to last game?
Well first of all, he's immune to my vote for today as I said previously.

But also, the string of snap early reads that happened in the 7-8am ET hours feel more like the town Clem I remember from early days in SPN and holloww's end (I can never decide how to describe that game). I went back to the good pWWace and most of his early posts in that thread were ****posts. So I get a more genuine "trying to feel the vibes" read here.
 
Worth noting that I haven't liked my phrasing in column G since I made this sheet for CYO III, but its current iteration is what makes the most sense to my brain.
I like how you make a complicated spreadsheet then expect us to actually read in depth enough to have criticisms of your headings 😂
 
Well first of all, he's immune to my vote for today as I said previously.

But also, the string of snap early reads that happened in the 7-8am ET hours feel more like the town Clem I remember from early days in SPN and holloww's end (I can never decide how to describe that game). I went back to the good pWWace and most of his early posts in that thread were ****posts. So I get a more genuine "trying to feel the vibes" read here.
Why am I immune to your vote today lol
 
I think my unease is more that 2 people who I would not consider historically shining beacons of towniness seem to be (very early and admittedly with most of the game not commenting specifically on this) consensus town, but I also am reading them both that way.

I'm just trying to decide what that means to me when it comes to other people coming to those reads.
 
Well first of all, he's immune to my vote for today as I said previously.

But also, the string of snap early reads that happened in the 7-8am ET hours feel more like the town Clem I remember from early days in SPN and holloww's end (I can never decide how to describe that game). I went back to the good pWWace and most of his early posts in that thread were ****posts. So I get a more genuine "trying to feel the vibes" read here.
What if I told you....

I believe none of those reads
 
I think my unease is more that 2 people who I would not consider historically shining beacons of towniness seem to be (very early and admittedly with most of the game not commenting specifically on this) consensus town, but I also am reading them both that way.

I'm just trying to decide what that means to me when it comes to other people coming to those reads.
Thread spewed town babay
 
Is that so much to ask :sorry:
Granted imo you should have D1 yeet immunity (more or less) since you were the D1 misyeet last game, so you can breathe easy-ish for at least one moment.
I agree, I don't like waffling but I also detest having half of the players completely off the board until 8:06pm ET and then all hell breaks loose in the last hour. So, since I'm just going on vibes anyways I decided to just put down a vote on the first sus thing I saw. I may move once, maaaaaybe twice tomorrow, but I'll almost certainly stay where I am for the night.
In fairness, this is a busy time and a lot of people have work/school. Sometimes you gotta crack a few eggs to make a last minute scramble.
I gave up mafia cupid for my ability because it wouldn't have worked well with the other 2 roles I was given.
...
Cupid can only be mafia, yes?
 
I mean, if it's not clear, it's not affecting my own read of either you or alissa, but it may affect my reads of other people.
I think I also typically read Alissa scum but it's also been forever since we've played together so 🤷‍♀️ she just feels very pure on vibes today
 
@GoSpursGo I hmmm'd that post because I'm not sure your assessment of fruit's voting behavior is correct? Hasn't he jumped around like that before for seemingly no reason?
I'd have to go back and really check this out.

My recollection is that he sometimes places votes on players who haven't posted in a while to force their hand to weigh in, or he'll vote quickly in response to something he doesn't like. But to do it just to create noise is unhelpful at best, to trying to create a smokescreen of "normal fruits" at worst.

That said, his apop vote and then sticking to it does feel like the "vote quickly in response to something he doesn't like" kind of vote. So idk. Mostly just a note to myself that early "normal fruits" is actually very easy for fruits to manufacture. I probably can't really read him until a few more days go by.
 
I laughed at this because it definitely still means you could be 3p and don't dispute that
I thought about how to reply to that for a while before I did because I couldn't think of a good way to phrase it around that :laugh:
 
Top