Agreed that they are overused in a lot of places. The only ones I do here are for actively dying type folks. Even that guy with the nonsalvageable Charcot foot would actually get a formal BKA if he opts in soon enough. The infection is only in the foot and we could get clean planes. But with the creatinine of 4.5 (baseline normal) and leukocytosis 25 and pressures in the 80s the foot has to go at some point. It’s three times the size of his other foot and not doing him any good.
And agreed on taking the time with some so-called “nonsalvageable” limbs to salvage them. If the patient is willing to put the work in and be compliant, you can do a lot.
I’ve also come around to the idea that a Lisfranc or Chopart are better options for some who need more than a TMA but maybe not a BKA. It’s best if there’s a high quality prosthetist you can rely on but even still, some of my patients use it like a peg leg if they aren’t very mobile anyway and, as previously referenced, like that they don’t lose control of their bladder before getting to the bathroom at night. I was taught in residency that those kinds of amps were only for special cases in the very young patient but now I agree they have a role in vascular limb salvage too.
Of course, patient selection is key.