- Take a look at the US daily cumulative totals on the COVID Tracking Project (US Historical Data), specifically the total positive cases out of the total number of tests. When increased testing is accounted for, positive cases reached a peak in mid-April and has been trending down ever since. The whole point of flattening the curve was to avoid overwhelming our medical capacity. Hospitals have not been overwhelmed. In fact, Army Corps field hospitals designed to manage overflow haven’t treated a single patient (), and the USS Comfort left NYC after treating 176 patients in 3 weeks (The 500-bed US Navy hospital ship Comfort is leaving NYC after treating just 179 patients in 3 weeks). The CDC had an existing protocol for test development during pandemics, and the US did not “refuse” tests from the WHO (Did US 'Refuse' COVID-19 Testing Kits from the World Health Organization?).
- You’re right, police aren’t literally welding our doors shut to prevent us from leaving (Sealed in: Chinese trapped at home by coronavirus feel the strain). But businesses are being forced to lock up under penalty of fine and imprisonment. The mayor of LA threatened to shut off utilities to non-compliant “non-essential” businesses. Protests are being "banned" in New York (De Blasio, NYPD commissioner: No protests allowed in NYC). Our constitutional rights are being violated, and more and more Americans are getting fed up.
- Lyme disease, Ebola, Zika, West Nile Virus, Middle East Respiratory Syndrome, etc. etc. Toponymic naming of diseases is not a new concept. Should we rename all of these diseases to be politically correct? Call it COVID if you want, but don’t call anyone racist simply for using a term the media and governments used for weeks. Media Called Coronavirus "Wuhan" Or "Chinese Coronavirus" Dozens Of Times
- Thanks
- I don’t think nursing home residents live in a bubble, but employees at nursing homes are already working. They’re “essential”. That won’t change if the rest of the economy opens. Part of the reason the outbreak at nursing homes is so high is because governors are forcing them to take COVID-positive patients (At a NY nursing home forced to take COVID-19 patients, 24 residents have died).
- What an absurd accusation. Suggesting that people be allowed to provide for their families is not being “cavalier with other peoples’ lives”. Do you consider medical workers, grocery store clerks, and nursing home employees to be worthy of sacrifice? Because allowing them to work certainly increases their risk. The answer is no because that's ridiculous. I think forcing businesses to remain closed is being cavalier with peoples’ livelihoods. Realize that after this is over, many businesses will not reopen, which means many people will be jobless. Unemployment is now at 15% (Record 20.5 million American jobs lost in April. Unemployment rate soars to 14.7%). That’s Great Depression level. How many people will die from poverty? From suicide (Mental Health an Emerging Crisis of COVID Pandemic)? From drug addiction ('Deaths of despair': Coronavirus pandemic could push suicide, drug deaths as high as 150k, study says)? How many will die from not getting their banned “elective” medical procedures (Elective doesn't mean non-essential. Skip sweeping coronavirus bans, let doctors decide.)? Flattening the curve does not change the area under it. This virus will still spread. It’s just a matter of how much economic devastation we allow to come with it.
- I’m sure many elderly people live with younger family members. Is anyone in the household going to the grocery store? To the pharmacy? To the gas station? If so, they’re being exposed. People are already taking precautions, wearing masks and gloves, using hand sanitizer, and socially distancing.
- This virus is never going to disappear. There will always be an added risk unless an effective vaccine is developed, which is no guarantee. Keeping the entire country shut down indefinitely and printing trillions in cash to send $2500 checks to some people is not a solution. It inflates the currency. That didn’t work out so well for the Weimar Republic. Don’t be surprised when prices become significantly higher.
- Public policy is multifactorial. The choice is not between keeping everyone locked at home vs. completely reversing to life as usual and “letting grandma die”. I encourage you to read this editorial about the impact this lockdown is having on our country. Opinion | The Economic Lockdown Catastrophe
You’re welcome to disagree with me, but please don’t accuse me of wanting to “sacrifice” people for my own benefit. It’s a lazy argument, and it’s untrue. And in no way am I criticizing our school's administration. Davis has done a great job in terms of communicating with us, providing several different options to accommodate the alterations in our clinical schedule, and setting up virtual rotations. They don't want to risk defying a government order, which is understandable. I'm criticizing the heavy handed responses of local and state governments, as well as the incompetence and reckless monetary policies being employed by the federal government.
1. NPR isn't a reliable source of information. I shouldn't need to tell you this but you using it as one explains so, so much. We have barely moved over the peak for maximum cases. Barely. Not to mention, we still don't have adequate testing so no one can make any claims to how many people are actually positive. I know many who've had every symptom but have been refused a test.
2. You aren't being oppressed. Your liberty ends where you risk another human beings life. I'm damn glad somewhere is not allowing protests.. showing up with assault rifles, spitting in the cops' faces, the protests have been nothing short of damn shows off terrorism. Every damn one of them that couldn't show up, wearing a mask, staying 6 feet apart, and calmly discuss about job loss should've been arrested. I've yet to see one protest that actually abided by the laws of peaceful protesting. It is written into the constitution that yes, the government can do what they're doing. Your right aren't being violated, you've just not lived during a time this part of the constitution needed to be implemented. No other country in the world is bitching about stay at home orders. They care about their fellow citizens. And, yes, their economies are also taking a hit. When can I execute my right to self defense against these protesters? They pose a direct threat to myself and my family. It is my right to protect myself.
3. Yes the hospitals have been overwhelmed. I'm friends with human doctors, they're struggling. Quit reading the news and talk to doctors in New York, New Jersey, Washington or California. It is bad. Constant codes. Constant pages for a new person needing a ventilator. It has been awful. Yes you're right, many other hospitals haven't been overwhelmed, but that was the whole damn point. They aren't overwhelmed because we did the stay home orders not in spite of them. This is like the most basic damn concept not sure why you can't comprehend it.
4. Cool, we've named viruses from locations in the past. Yes, we all realize that. We didn't have a president back then who actively encourages terrorism and racist attacks. I have friends of Asian decent who can't even ****ing go to the store without being called horrible names. They're scared. Besides, the fact that the virus has a different name. The ONLY reason one would insist on calling it the Wuhan virus or Chinese virus is if their a racist. Period. There's legitimately no other reason to refuse to call it by what I was named.
5. You're missing the point. If things open that nurse is at an exponential increase of coming in contact with others who have been mingling out and about. It increases the chances the nurse brings the virus into the nursing home. Again, you don't seem to comprehend basic things. I can't explain it to you any simpler.
6. Yes, we've treated essential workers like crap. I'm not going to disagree there. There should've been numerous protections put into action for them that weren't. It was handled horribly. Yes, it sucks to lose your livelihood. My parents lost everything a few years back and were diagnosed with serious life threatening conditions on top of that. It was insanely difficult. I do get it. But please point to the time in history where the economy took a hit and didn't recover. You can't reopen your business if you're dead. If your business reopens too quickly and a bunch of your employees get sick, some end up on ventilators and some die, well your business won't reopen either. You won't have the staff to operate it. The virus is currently killing more people every day than heart disease, cancer, accidents, suicides, etc. It is the leading cause of death in the US today. You want the economy to really tank....open quickly without precautions the body count and medical bills will cause a greater strain than this is. Also saying people are being cautious is hysterical. A damn security guard was shot and killed because someone didn't want to follow the rules and wear a mask. People are proving we aren't anywhere near ready to open since they can't simply wear a damn mask without bitching that they're "being oppressed".
7. Yes going to the store is a risk. But one individual going to the store, buying enough for 2-3 weeks and coming straight back home is less risk than every individual going to work, then the store, then gas station because they're driving more now. And well, crap forgot to bring lunch I'll just eat out, etc etc. Again, this is the basic idea of more people leaving, going to more places = increased risk compared to one person leaving to do one thing. I don't understand why this concept is difficult to grasp.
8. Again, no one ever has said to shut things down indefinitely. Why is this complicated to ascertain? They're asking people to wait until curve has flattened for a period of time then slowly reopen with appropriate testing and tracing. We don't have appropriate testing. Why aren't you upset about that? Why aren't you upset that those could have been much better if the US handled it back in January when we were first warned about it? Huh? We could've saved thousands of lives and jobs. Prices have been increasing since the invention of money. I'm never shocked that they increase every year. And helping citizens monetarily during a crisis is exactly what a government is for. We pay them to keep us safe and provide for us as a whole. The US is actually falling behind the help it has provided us compared to every other industrialized nation and even some non industrialized nations. Oh and a vaccine has been developed and given to the first few test people. If it goes well, it'll be available around this time next year. No I'm not suggesting we stay closed until then, I'm just pointing out a vaccine is likely.
9. Yes, we've been saying this all along. That things should open at an appropriate time with the proper precautions in place. We don't have those precautions. Want to open sooner....demand those precautions be met. No one anywhere has said that the ebony isn't taking a hit, we see it. We get it. No one anywhere has said everyone stay inside forever. We're saying if this isn't done right, the economy will see a second, likely larger hit in a couple months due to dead bodies and too many medical bills because we still can't be sick in America without going bankrupt.
Sorry but anyone arguing things to be normal right now without being angry that we don't have the tools to do so, doesn't care if others get sick. Anyone who thinks our current responses are heavy handed doesn't comprehend that we've done very minimal to put a stop to this compared to other countries. They don't get that really, every member of our government who ignored the warnings in January are guilty of thousands upon thousands of negligent homicide. We could've been on an upswing from this had things been handled in a strict shut down with testing, contact tracing and quarantine from January. We could've prevented so much loss of life, jobs and possibly not had as extreme of a hit on the economy. But no, they're mad that they can't get their nails did out their hair cut or sit in a restaurant. The loudest complainers aren't those that lost jobs, it is the entitled group that wants a damn hair cut.