- Joined
- Apr 4, 2012
- Messages
- 2,120
- Reaction score
- 551
So, I'll be starting med school next fall and have been reading this board for a long while. I see polarized comments that probably leave me more confused than before I came, such as one of you saying that money will only be made in medicine if you go into a high paying specialty, then another doc swearing that high paying specialties like ortho will get drastic cuts due to ACA and therefore is the worst.
So I got to thinking about something very basic : the problem of mid level encroachment. Yes I know that there are a zillion threads on this but I never see this argument: crna's are cheaper and can "sometimes" do the job just like a reals anesthesia physician. So since CRNA's can do a "fair" job, it seems as though they will be taking over anesthesia. But what does that say about the pride of our US healthcare system ? It speaks pretty poorly to me. It's like the government is actually okay with CRNA's taking over. It would be status quo. But status quo isn't good enough. Do CRNA's advance the field of anesthesia? Do they make innovative additions to the field? No, isn't it the anesthesia physicians that do that? The ones who went to medical school and busted their asses to learn everything about anesthesia. The ones who have dedicated their lives to research. Well, do we see CRNA research changing the field of anesthesia for the better? Someone please enlighten me, because it seems that this country is becoming complacent with lesser quality healthcare, and there is less pride and respect for docs than there used to be. How can anesthesia or any field with mid levels make discoveries and change the field for the better if the CRNA's are just doing the technical aspect of anesthesia with having only a fraction of the education? I don't think our current system is trying to be the best . I could be wrong and some doc on this board will say that mid levels will never take over.. But it's just the principle that instead of making innovation the priority and leading to better healthcare, the gov only cares about costs. Surely this field can't grow if there is a status quo
Too long, didn't read?
Question: why isn't innovation and top notch healthcare the main priority in all of medicine? Why do we allow much less quality by letting CRNA's eventually take over? It's the anesthesia docs/PhD who make innovations to this field.. NOT CRNA's.
So I got to thinking about something very basic : the problem of mid level encroachment. Yes I know that there are a zillion threads on this but I never see this argument: crna's are cheaper and can "sometimes" do the job just like a reals anesthesia physician. So since CRNA's can do a "fair" job, it seems as though they will be taking over anesthesia. But what does that say about the pride of our US healthcare system ? It speaks pretty poorly to me. It's like the government is actually okay with CRNA's taking over. It would be status quo. But status quo isn't good enough. Do CRNA's advance the field of anesthesia? Do they make innovative additions to the field? No, isn't it the anesthesia physicians that do that? The ones who went to medical school and busted their asses to learn everything about anesthesia. The ones who have dedicated their lives to research. Well, do we see CRNA research changing the field of anesthesia for the better? Someone please enlighten me, because it seems that this country is becoming complacent with lesser quality healthcare, and there is less pride and respect for docs than there used to be. How can anesthesia or any field with mid levels make discoveries and change the field for the better if the CRNA's are just doing the technical aspect of anesthesia with having only a fraction of the education? I don't think our current system is trying to be the best . I could be wrong and some doc on this board will say that mid levels will never take over.. But it's just the principle that instead of making innovation the priority and leading to better healthcare, the gov only cares about costs. Surely this field can't grow if there is a status quo
Too long, didn't read?
Question: why isn't innovation and top notch healthcare the main priority in all of medicine? Why do we allow much less quality by letting CRNA's eventually take over? It's the anesthesia docs/PhD who make innovations to this field.. NOT CRNA's.