Status
Not open for further replies.
Feb 20, 2011
187
0
Status
Pre-Medical
Where does this assumption come from aside from the fact that it is one of the most competitive residencies out of MD schools?

I ask this because although I used to believe the same, I have been searching for DO's to shadow and I have found a good number of DO dermatologists, even more so than surgery.

I live in southern california by the way.
 

NurWollen

Strong with the Force
10+ Year Member
Dec 27, 2007
3,427
2,365
United States
Status
Resident [Any Field]
Where does this assumption come from aside from the fact that it is one of the most competitive residencies out of MD schools?

I ask this because although I used to believe the same, I have been searching for DO's to shadow and I have found a good number of DO dermatologists, even more so than surgery.

I live in southern california by the way.
There are a lot of DO dermatologists out there. That doesn't mitigate the fact that it is an extremely competitive field and that the chances of any one individual DO student making it are small, but it can obviously be done.

Most DO dermatologists complete AOA residencies. From what I understand, the majority of AOA derm spots require applicants to have completed a residency in FM or IM 1st. This rules it out for a lot of DO's I imagine because after one residency I think most people are ready to actually start working for real. Still, it has occurred to my that as an FP in a derm residency you would certainly have the skills and time to moonlight so you can start making good money. Also, since all DO FM residencies are actually dual FM/OMM residencies, wouldn't someone who goes to such a residency followed by a derm residency be triple board certified? Pretty cool.
 

MedPR

Removed
Dec 1, 2011
18,581
44
Status
Pre-Podiatry
ACGME derm is likely out of reach for DO. AOA obviously is a different story.

Sent from my SGH-T999 using SDN Mobile
 

cliquesh

10+ Year Member
Nov 2, 2007
3,090
1,089
Status
Resident [Any Field]
ACGME derm is likely out of reach for DO. AOA obviously is a different story.

Sent from my SGH-T999 using SDN Mobile
This is true. If you were to graduate #1 in your class, get a 260 on the usmle, a 700 and an 800 on the comlex, with LORs from prominent dermatologists, and apply to all of the acgme.dermatology programs, you will still not match. (Those were the stats of a friend of mine who failed to match).


There are 28 AOA dermatology residencies. Most of them take 1 or 2 residents per year, so maybe there are 42 AOA derm spots offered each year. There were 4600 DO graduates last year.

By the way, you never see dermatology matches on schools' match lists because you match into AOA dermatology after your intern year. So those interested on derm, apply for a traditional rotating internship, or in some cases a family medicine residency, and then during their intern year they apply for derm.

Additional, maybe 30 to 50% of the derm positions are unfunded, which means you don't get paid during your residency.
 

SpecterGT260

Catdoucheus
5+ Year Member
Feb 1, 2012
8,223
82
Status
Medical Student
Where does this assumption come from aside from the fact that it is one of the most competitive residencies out of MD schools?

I ask this because although I used to believe the same, I have been searching for DO's to shadow and I have found a good number of DO dermatologists, even more so than surgery.

I live in southern california by the way.
The AOA has its own residencies. They put out their own derm and ortho docs.

Go look up the nrmp match data and get cozy with it. It is all in there

Sent from my DROID RAZR using SDN Mobile
 
OP
C
Feb 20, 2011
187
0
Status
Pre-Medical
According to that data, it looks to me like DO's are not much better for matching than the Caribbean schools as far as specialities... Someone please correct me if I am wrong.

Why then all the bash on Caribbean schools? Is it just more convenient to go to a DO school in the US despite the chances of getting into more competitive residencies being similar?
 

MedPR

Removed
Dec 1, 2011
18,581
44
Status
Pre-Podiatry
According to that data, it looks to me like DO's are not much better for matching than the Caribbean schools as far as specialities... Someone please correct me if I am wrong.

Why then all the bash on Caribbean schools? Is it just more convenient to go to a DO school in the US despite the chances of getting into more competitive residencies being similar?
Ugh.

Sent from my SGH-T999 using SDN Mobile
 

SpecterGT260

Catdoucheus
5+ Year Member
Feb 1, 2012
8,223
82
Status
Medical Student
According to that data, it looks to me like DO's are not much better for matching than the Caribbean schools as far as specialities... Someone please correct me if I am wrong.

Why then all the bash on Caribbean schools? Is it just more convenient to go to a DO school in the US despite the chances of getting into more competitive residencies being similar?
:laugh::laugh::laugh::laugh::laugh::laugh:

I was wondering if you were another sneaky Caribbean sympathizer who was going to sneak in a carib discussion under the guise of DO matchability.

According to that data, DOs match much (i.e. drastically...) better than carib grads. They also have their own match which can accommodate about 50% of their grads which carib students do not have. If you disagree you are not looking at the data correctly. I'm not aware of the last time a carib grad went to any competitive field...... I am aware how often it has happened for DOs over the last 5 years. You shouldnt concern yourself with ROADS in the ACGME as either IMG or DO for at least a few years after the AOA acquisition happens. If you are carib, just cross your fingers that you can match IM, and then cross another set and hope that you will be one of the minority lucky enough to even graduate making that first cross not just a wasted exercise in manual dexterity :thumbup:
 

JGimpel

Say what?
5+ Year Member
Oct 11, 2012
698
115
Rahhther Far Away
According to that data, it looks to me like DO's are not much better for matching than the Caribbean schools as far as specialities... Someone please correct me if I am wrong.

Why then all the bash on Caribbean schools? Is it just more convenient to go to a DO school in the US despite the chances of getting into more competitive residencies being similar?
Another Pre-med SENIOR MEMBER.

Dermatology is tough for anyone from any school to get into. Most fields are closed to Caribbean school graduates. Look at how many start a quarter/semester then how many are left at graduation, then make a percent out of that and the 1 or 2 per competitive field that made it in and you're well into the fractions of a percent. Use the search function for the same stuff with all the numbers behind it that gets posted several times a year. This is what gets pre-meds bashed a lot on SDN.

/interest
 
OP
C
Feb 20, 2011
187
0
Status
Pre-Medical
:laugh::laugh::laugh::laugh::laugh::laugh:

I was wondering if you were another sneaky Caribbean sympathizer who was going to sneak in a carib discussion under the guise of DO matchability.

According to that data, DOs match much (i.e. drastically...) better than carib grads. They also have their own match which can accommodate about 50% of their grads which carib students do not have. If you disagree you are not looking at the data correctly. I'm not aware of the last time a carib grad went to any competitive field...... I am aware how often it has happened for DOs over the last 5 years. You shouldnt concern yourself with ROADS in the ACGME as either IMG or DO for at least a few years after the AOA acquisition happens. If you are carib, just cross your fingers that you can match IM, and then cross another set and hope that you will be one of the minority lucky enough to even graduate making that first cross not just a wasted exercise in manual dexterity :thumbup:
Ohhhh that makes more sense. I am not promoting the caribbean schools and whatnot, for myself I would retake my MCAT for 2 more years and get rejected from both US MD/DO schools twice before I consider the Caribbean schools. On a positive note, my general surgeon who did my appendectomy was a Caribbean graduate. She must have had to pull so many strings to work in southern california.
 
OP
C
Feb 20, 2011
187
0
Status
Pre-Medical
Gee I guess my name gives it away huh.

You guys got me.

Still want to become a physician? You could interview next week!!
 

Mr Kenobi

Jedi Member
7+ Year Member
Jul 10, 2012
1,478
930
Tatooine
Status
According to that data, it looks to me like DO's are not much better for matching than the Caribbean schools as far as specialities... Someone please correct me if I am wrong.

Why then all the bash on Caribbean schools? Is it just more convenient to go to a DO school in the US despite the chances of getting into more competitive residencies being similar?
 

113

Removed
Jan 20, 2013
569
11
Cheshire Bridge, ATL
Status
According to that data, it looks to me like DO's are not much better for matching than the Caribbean schools as far as specialities... Someone please correct me if I am wrong.

Why then all the bash on Caribbean schools? Is it just more convenient to go to a DO school in the US despite the chances of getting into more competitive residencies being similar?


Seems legit.
 

NontradCA

American Hero
5+ Year Member
Sep 19, 2012
4,992
4,143
Trump Tower
Status
Medical Student

Mr Kenobi

Jedi Member
7+ Year Member
Jul 10, 2012
1,478
930
Tatooine
Status
Didn't those movies start coming out when the kids were into that emo garbage. Disney...Now that they have Star Wars, Han Solo will probably be rocking some lensless Ray Bans or some hipster sh!t.
 

NontradCA

American Hero
5+ Year Member
Sep 19, 2012
4,992
4,143
Trump Tower
Status
Medical Student
Didn't those movies start coming out when the kids were into that emo garbage. Disney...Now that they have Star Wars, Han Solo will probably be rocking some lensless Ray Bans or some hipster sh!t.
Han Yolo
 

NeuroLAX

Discere faciendo
Apr 17, 2012
2,914
322
Status
Medical Student


Seems legit.
Proud to say that I can do this whenever I feel like it, and I go to a US school. Winning :thumbup:
 

Mr Kenobi

Jedi Member
7+ Year Member
Jul 10, 2012
1,478
930
Tatooine
Status
Proud to say that I can do this whenever I feel like it, and I go to a US school. Winning :thumbup:
Don't miss class tho...wouldn't want to violate that attendance policy:naughty:


Edit: I don't know if NSU actually has an attendance policy...I just know that my school doesn't so I wanted to attempt to rustle the ol jimmies...and I will be jelly of your weather when I move to the Midwest and freeze my Jedi balls off.;)
 
Last edited:

NontradCA

American Hero
5+ Year Member
Sep 19, 2012
4,992
4,143
Trump Tower
Status
Medical Student

NontradCA

American Hero
5+ Year Member
Sep 19, 2012
4,992
4,143
Trump Tower
Status
Medical Student
 

NeuroLAX

Discere faciendo
Apr 17, 2012
2,914
322
Status
Medical Student
I will be jelly of your weather when I move to the Midwest and freeze my Jedi balls off.;)
You should consider getting one of these.



edit: here is the rest of it

 

Mr Kenobi

Jedi Member
7+ Year Member
Jul 10, 2012
1,478
930
Tatooine
Status
You should consider getting one of these.



edit: here is the rest of it

No joke, I want this haha. Do they have it in Jedi size, or just youngling like the photo shows? Ill have to see if the wife is down to switch out our current bedding...
 

cabinbuilder

Urgent Care Physician
10+ Year Member
Nov 21, 2005
4,531
2,357
Texas
Status
Attending Physician
There are a lot of DO dermatologists out there. That doesn't mitigate the fact that it is an extremely competitive field and that the chances of any one individual DO student making it are small, but it can obviously be done.

Most DO dermatologists complete AOA residencies. From what I understand, the majority of AOA derm spots require applicants to have completed a residency in FM or IM 1st. This rules it out for a lot of DO's I imagine because after one residency I think most people are ready to actually start working for real. Still, it has occurred to my that as an FP in a derm residency you would certainly have the skills and time to moonlight so you can start making good money. Also, since all DO FM residencies are actually dual FM/OMM residencies, wouldn't someone who goes to such a residency followed by a derm residency be triple board certified? Pretty cool.
You would be incorrect. You do an intern year, not an entire residency. CMS does not pay for a doctor to do 2 residencies.
 

NeuroLAX

Discere faciendo
Apr 17, 2012
2,914
322
Status
Medical Student
No joke, I want this haha. Do they have it in Jedi size, or just youngling like the photo shows? Ill have to see if the wife is down to switch out our current bedding...
Tell her you guys can enter hyperspace whenever you want :naughty:
 

CopToEM

Livin' the Dream
5+ Year Member
7+ Year Member
Jun 3, 2009
1,362
46
Southeast US
Status
Medical Student
My dermatologist is a DO - she did her residency at Mayo Clinic. However, I think she's a true outlier. As mentioned, the odds of any one DO pulling that off are slim.
 

Temperature101

Membership Revoked
Removed
May 27, 2011
3,487
80
Status
Medical Student
Where does this assumption come from aside from the fact that it is one of the most competitive residencies out of MD schools?

I ask this because although I used to believe the same, I have been searching for DO's to shadow and I have found a good number of DO dermatologists, even more so than surgery.

I live in southern california by the way.
Derm is almost out of reach for everyone (MD/DO). Period.
 
May 11, 2012
1,018
43
Status
Medical Student
You would be incorrect. You do an intern year, not an entire residency. CMS does not pay for a doctor to do 2 residencies.
This. I've met some interns who were rotating at the FM residency clinic I shadow at that were going into derm.

I'm curious though, do these guys match a TRI the first time through and then re-enter and match derm, or do you rank derm as an M4 and then just have to find an internship after you match?
 

kami333

10+ Year Member
Aug 15, 2007
1,454
27
Status
Medical Student
My dermatologist is a DO - she did her residency at Mayo Clinic. However, I think she's a true outlier. As mentioned, the odds of any one DO pulling that off are slim.
Same here, last time I was at the OSU derm clinic there was a DO resident there. Hard to imagine what her stats must have been like.
 

NontradCA

American Hero
5+ Year Member
Sep 19, 2012
4,992
4,143
Trump Tower
Status
Medical Student
Jul 28, 2012
683
4
The best place ever.
Status
Pre-Medical
Don't miss class tho...wouldn't want to violate that attendance policy:naughty:


Edit: I don't know if NSU actually has an attendance policy...I just know that my school doesn't so I wanted to attempt to rustle the ol jimmies...and I will be jelly of your weather when I move to the Midwest and freeze my Jedi balls off.;)
Here they're, sir!

 

sterlingh87

Future Two-Hat Doc
5+ Year Member
Oct 18, 2012
657
112
Utah
Status
Medical Student
I am curious, because I have never heard anything about this, but does doing a derm or ortho residency that is AOA accredited limit you in any way? Like is the accreditation only good for osteopathic hospitals or clinics or can you pretty much practice derm or ortho wherever an MD can?
 

MedPR

Removed
Dec 1, 2011
18,581
44
Status
Pre-Podiatry
I am curious, because I have never heard anything about this, but does doing a derm or ortho residency that is AOA accredited limit you in any way? Like is the accreditation only good for osteopathic hospitals or clinics or can you pretty much practice derm or ortho wherever an MD can?
Some fellowships won't take you if you didn't do an ACGME residency. Otherwise there are no limitations.
 

sterlingh87

Future Two-Hat Doc
5+ Year Member
Oct 18, 2012
657
112
Utah
Status
Medical Student
Some fellowships won't take you if you didn't do an ACGME residency. Otherwise there are no limitations.
Good to know. I think I saw a similair thread where someone made a comment that some AOA residencies are only accepted at certain hostpitals that accept AOA residencies and not others. I never questioned because I didnt know and the thread was old and inactive, so I am glad I could finally ask the question to people actively discussing it. Thanks MedPR
 

SpecterGT260

Catdoucheus
5+ Year Member
Feb 1, 2012
8,223
82
Status
Medical Student
Some fellowships won't take you if you didn't do an ACGME residency. Otherwise there are no limitations.
I'm not sure this is accurate.... that is what was on the table which is what prompted the new resolution in which the ACGME will absorb the AOA programs and give the AOA a seat at the table in determining how they are governed, but I am not aware that any fellowships were currently closed to DOs who had not taken an ACGME intern year.

Good to know. I think I saw a similair thread where someone made a comment that some AOA residencies are only accepted at certain hostpitals that accept AOA residencies and not others. I never questioned because I didnt know and the thread was old and inactive, so I am glad I could finally ask the question to people actively discussing it. Thanks MedPR
By 2015 (estimated per their press releases) this will not be an issue at any rate as all AOA programs will be accredited by the ACGME.
 

Mosonik

5+ Year Member
Feb 1, 2012
663
72
Status
Resident [Any Field]
" I'm not sure this is accurate.... that is what was on the table which is what prompted the new resolution in which the ACGME will absorb the AOA programs and give the AOA a seat at the table in determining how they are governed, but I am not aware that any fellowships were currently closed to DOs who had not taken an ACGME intern year. "


I was just thinking this. The only way it would be possible (if what MedPR says is true) is if it was done unofficially
 

SpecterGT260

Catdoucheus
5+ Year Member
Feb 1, 2012
8,223
82
Status
Medical Student
I was just thinking this. The only way it would be possible (if what MedPR says is true) is if it was done unofficially
Yeah, and that may happen. Same wiht some residencies though. However for fellowship (in an unofficial sense) I doubt they care a whole lot about your intern year. That is your "bitchwork" year, for all intents and purposes.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.