Destroyer q- which H is most acidic

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

510586

Full Member
7+ Year Member
Joined
Dec 24, 2014
Messages
1,056
Reaction score
290

Members don't see this ad.
Can someone explain why it isn't the (2) H? I was always taught that a higher degree was more acidic when comparing two alpha h's. Like nah would turn the second one into enolate bc more substituted.
1439078488695-793107012.jpg
 

DAT Destroyer

Dr. Romano and Nancy
Lifetime Donor
Sponsor
Vendor
15+ Year Member
Joined
Mar 12, 2005
Messages
4,694
Reaction score
3,428
Can someone explain why it isn't the (2) H? I was always taught that a higher degree was more acidic when comparing two alpha h's. Like nah would turn the second one into enolate bc more substituted. View attachment 194867

You have brought up a very important concept. We have narrowed it down to either alpha proton 2 or alpha proton 1. Abstraction of proton 2 gives a very stabilized enolate.....more than the enolate in 1, as you say.

HOWEVER......the critical parameter here is kinetics.....the rate of abstraction. The proton on the outside is EASIER to remove. We now have a contest... Thermodynamics vs Kinetics. Kinetics wins ! Kinetics also wins out out in reactions such as Diels Alder. Thus....proton 1 is the most acidic.

If you want to see another example of this, go to any text book in organic chemistry and look up the Haloform reaction. You may have done the Iodoform reaction in lab. What is the first move ? We have 2 alpha protons.......The OUTERMOST proton is removed in preference over the innermost alpha proton. Kinetics wins.

Now,,,,,if a double alpha was present, such as that seen in reactions like AcetoAcetic ester synthesis, the double alpha would easily trump the outermost proton due to resonance stabilization.

This is not too tough.....You can do this !!!!:)

Dr. Romano
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users

510586

Full Member
7+ Year Member
Joined
Dec 24, 2014
Messages
1,056
Reaction score
290
You have brought up a very important concept. We have narrowed it down to either alpha proton 2 or alpha proton 1. Abstraction of proton 2 gives a very stabilized enolate.....more than the enolate in 1, as you say.

HOWEVER......the critical parameter here is kinetics.....the rate of abstraction. The proton on the outside is EASIER to remove. We now have a contest... Thermodynamics vs Kinetics. Kinetics wins ! Kinetics also wins out out in reactions such as Diels Alder. Thus....proton 1 is the most acidic.

If you want to see another example of this, go to any text book in organic chemistry and look up the Haloform reaction. You may have done the Iodoform reaction in lab. What is the first move ? We have 2 alpha protons.......The OUTERMOST proton is removed in preference over the innermost alpha proton. Kinetics wins.

Now,,,,,if a double alpha was present, such as that seen in reactions like AcetoAcetic ester synthesis, the double alpha would easily trump the outermost proton due to resonance stabilization.

This is not too tough.....You can do this !!!!:)

Dr. Romano
Oh yea the haloform reaction is a great example of this thank you! Makes it a lot easier to understand. Methyl ketones are better than others other than double alpha. So if we used the haloform reagent for a double alpha, it would form an enolate not a typical haloform reaction? ?
 

DAT Destroyer

Dr. Romano and Nancy
Lifetime Donor
Sponsor
Vendor
15+ Year Member
Joined
Mar 12, 2005
Messages
4,694
Reaction score
3,428
Oh yea the haloform reaction is a great example of this thank you! Makes it a lot easier to understand. Methyl ketones are better than others other than double alpha. So if we used the haloform reagent for a double alpha, it would form an enolate not a typical haloform reaction? ?


If a compound had a double alpha, it would NOT do the Haloform reaction. The Haloform reaction is reserved for methyl ketones or methyl carbinols. But, yes,,,,,you have the idea !!!!! Rock on !!!!!
 

510586

Full Member
7+ Year Member
Joined
Dec 24, 2014
Messages
1,056
Reaction score
290
If a compound had a double alpha, it would NOT do the Haloform reaction. The Haloform reaction is reserved for methyl ketones or methyl carbinols. But, yes,,,,,you have the idea !!!!! Rock on !!!!!
Oh ok. Just to clarify, wouldn't a methyl ketone still be possible in a double alpha? Like two ketone's next to each other one being methyl? Thank you for helping
 

DAT Destroyer

Dr. Romano and Nancy
Lifetime Donor
Sponsor
Vendor
15+ Year Member
Joined
Mar 12, 2005
Messages
4,694
Reaction score
3,428
Oh ok. Just to clarify, wouldn't a methyl ketone still be possible in a double alpha? Like two ketone's next to each other one being methyl? Thank you for helping

Yes.....but it would not be a Haloform reaction. Once treated with base...we would set up the anion from the double alpha abstraction ...yes ? Once formed.....we can react this with a halide in an SN2 process,,,,,,,We see this in an AcetoAcetic Ester synthesis !!!
 

510586

Full Member
7+ Year Member
Joined
Dec 24, 2014
Messages
1,056
Reaction score
290
Yes.....but it would not be a Haloform reaction. Once treated with base...we would set up the anion from the double alpha abstraction ...yes ? Once formed.....we can react this with a halide in an SN2 process,,,,,,,We see this in an AcetoAcetic Ester synthesis !!!
Oh ok so what you meant in the earlier post is the haloform is reserved for methyl ketones that are not part of a double alpha orientation. Got confused sorry
 
Top