Only a true perfectionist can give you a good answer at this...so here comes the perfect answer
(kidding!)
Seriously though, I know exactly what you're talking about. Here are the problems I have with being ultra competitive: 1) it can really upset or annoy other people, and 2) you can end up being what's known as a defeated (or discouraged) perfectionist.
On the first, I personally always try to do my very best at everything; although realizing that I can't, I certainly give it my best shot. I wouldn't want to do anything halfway and wouldn't be happy with myself if I did; however, if you are outwardly competitive, it becomes a different issue. People do not like it when they sense competition in everything. It's fine to compete with yourself, but when you start involving others, you will most likely end up frustrating them--or you if they "win." For example, my best friend and I are both very, very competitive people, and we also both really like tennis. Because of this, instead of actually playing tennis, we just hit the ball around and practice--which ends up being lots of fun (instead of one of us losing and feeling lousy). I save my competition in sports to the soccer field against non-friends.
Another example is grades: I don't share them with anyone. It doesn't matter where I stack up against my friends or anyone else as long as I am happy with myself and feel like I did my best. There's nothing worse than the people in med school who feel the need to share their grades all the time, especially if it's done in a boastful way.
Becoming frustrated or defeated/discouraged is very easy in med school, because for many people, it's the first time they ever face failure. From the very start of first year, you have to decide if getting perfect grades is still as important as it was for you undergrad; if it is, plan to study a lot more than you ever have. If you are content with having a balance of activities, then do your best at the things you do. Everyone who is not a perfectionist will tell you that you can't achieve it and will not understand the real need and drive you feel to always try. The problem becomes if you start hating yourself or becoming depressed or simply giving up and not trying anymore if things don't go your way.
That's just my opinion...of course, if I'm wrong, I'm just never going to post again and am going to go dig a hole and crawl in.
Good luck to ya!
--Brendan--
<"}}}}}><