Doctor-related shows....

shaky_k

Junior Member
10+ Year Member
Jul 5, 2006
8
0
  1. Pre-Medical
    I was wondering if anyone else feels as irritated as I do when I hear someone watch something like Gray's Anatomy or ER and be like "Man, that is one of the reasons I want to be a doctor omg lolzzzzzzzzzzzzz"

    I just annoys me, those shows make the profession seem more glamourous, which can actually be quite deceptive.

    Just had to have a quick vent about that...
     

    LizzyM

    the evil queen of numbers
    Verified Expert
    15+ Year Member
    Mar 7, 2005
    25,766
    44,392
    1. Academic Administration
      shaky_k said:
      I was wondering if anyone else feels as irritated as I do when I hear someone watch something like Gray's Anatomy or ER and be like "Man, that is one of the reasons I want to be a doctor omg lolzzzzzzzzzzzzz"

      I just annoys me, those shows make the profession seem more glamourous, which can actually be quite deceptive.

      Just had to have a quick vent about that...

      I'm sure the cops, lawyers, crime scene investigators, and casino operators have the same complaint. It's TV people.

      However, some med schools use (have used) episodes of ER to teach medical ethics (maybe cases of what not to do??).
       

      Wackie

      Inappropriate, always
      10+ Year Member
      5+ Year Member
      Mar 20, 2006
      674
      15
      Home with the Armadillo
      emt2doc.blogspot.com
      1. Pre-Medical
        I know I'd be the bestest doctor because of Grey's Anatomy. You remember the episode when Dr. Stevens and Dr. Yang did that autopsy in the first season? You know, on the guy who died suddenly? Because of a genetic problem with his heart? And the family didn't authorize it? But they did later?

        Well, I knew it was wrong. Even before they were caught.

        I'm going to be the bestest.
         
        About the Ads

        doctordutch

        Member
        10+ Year Member
        Jun 23, 2006
        39
        0
        Texas
        1. Pre-Medical
          I knew I was going to be a doctor before Grey's Anatomy came out. But now that it is out, I say reap the benefits of people thinking doctors are sexy. So what if it's not real. Why would anyone be entertained by what residents actually do? It's television, not residency preparation.
           

          baylormed

          On the Search
          10+ Year Member
          5+ Year Member
          Dec 4, 2005
          4,286
          53
          Right behind you
          1. Post Doc
            There is no reason to get irritated....it's just a TV show. Nothing less, nothing more.

            Oh, it isn't accurate??
            Who cares?, if I wanted to watch reality/accuracy I would turn on the news or discovery channel, or better yet, I would go stand in the waiting room of the local hospital (now, THAT is real and live entertainment.

            Oh, you don't like it and think it's stupid???
            As simple as not watching it.

            As far as people who want to be doctors for that show...they'll be disappointed when they try taking the pre-reqs and studying for the MCAT. Why do you think 80% (approx in my school) of pre-meds eventually drop the program? Because they realize it's not that easy, most give up along the way. So don't worry about them, life and the curriculum will weed them out eventually, and so will adcoms.
            :love:
             

            Beau Geste

            yah mo b there
            10+ Year Member
            Jun 10, 2005
            22,166
            159
            Between Heaven and Hell, benching like crazy
            1. Resident [Any Field]
              Wackie said:
              I know I'd be the bestest doctor because of Grey's Anatomy. You remember the episode when Dr. Stevens and Dr. Yang did that autopsy in the first season? You know, on the guy who died suddenly? Because of a genetic problem with his heart? And the family didn't authorize it? But they did later?

              Well, I knew it was wrong. Even before they were caught.

              I'm going to be the bestest.

              I want to have sex in storage closets like they do in GA. That's why I want to be a doctor. :rolleyes:
               

              Dr Durden

              Full Member
              10+ Year Member
              Jun 16, 2006
              4,259
              1
              The Dirty South
              1. Medical Student
                megboo said:
                I want to have sex in storage closets like they do in GA. That's why I want to be a doctor. :rolleyes:

                When the supply closet's rockin, don't come a knockin.

                But House isn't alone in ripping off books. Grey's has "borrowed" plenty of material as well from memoirs like "When the Air Hits the Brain" and "Hot Lights/Cold Steel". Though I certainly don't mind having that material reread to me in a smoky voice-over from Meredith :love: .
                 
                About the Ads

                mychelle774

                Full Member
                10+ Year Member
                5+ Year Member
                Mar 22, 2006
                431
                0
                Houston, TX
                1. Pre-Medical
                  Dr.Acula said:
                  Scrubs = Best show created by man in the history of the world.

                  Yeah! Finally some love for Scrubs. All this hype for GA, which has only been on what, two seasons? Scrubs has stood the test of time even if it's not sensationalist. I must admit I resisted GA as long as I could but got hooked because it's actually entertaining and it has hot people. However, that's all it is - entertaining. GA doesn't even begin to touch the genius Scrubs has while being damn entertaining to boot (without racy romances every three seconds I might add). Hooray for Scrubs, I can't wait till next season!! :D Besides, if anything Scrubs has shown me there's room for humor in medicine, if you keep it on the inside mostly.
                   

                  sentrosi

                  INTARWEB USER
                  10+ Year Member
                  5+ Year Member
                  Jun 28, 2004
                  290
                  1
                  TEH INTARWEB
                  1. Medical Student
                    Dr.Acula said:
                    Scrubs = Best show created by man in the history of the world.
                    "That is an awesome ending!"
                    "Thanks for telling me what I already know."

                    Yes, Scrubs is best. There's a fair amount of good lessons in it too.

                    Dr Durden said:
                    When the supply closet's rockin, don't come a knockin.
                    EMTs say the same except "supply closet" replaced with "truck"...which can actually rock, I've seen it before. :rolleyes:
                     

                    MonkeyNuts!

                    Even Kal has bad days...
                    10+ Year Member
                    Jun 23, 2005
                    3,646
                    14
                      I haven't read those books so I dunno how House is a ripoff. But its more of Hugh Laurie being a total jackass that makes me watch the show... you can't learn how to be that much of a jerk from a book.

                      Grey's sucks. The first season was really good. And the second season was great up till after the Code Black eps. Then things got really stupid. I really hoped that the shooter in the season finale had shot Meredith.
                       

                      sentrosi

                      INTARWEB USER
                      10+ Year Member
                      5+ Year Member
                      Jun 28, 2004
                      290
                      1
                      TEH INTARWEB
                      1. Medical Student
                        eternalrage said:
                        I haven't read those books so I dunno how House is a ripoff. But its more of Hugh Laurie being a total jackass that makes me watch the show... you can't learn how to be that much of a jerk from a book.

                        Grey's sucks. The first season was really good. And the second season was great up till after the Code Black eps. Then things got really stupid. I really hoped that the shooter in the season finale had shot Meredith.
                        Why not...we are posting on forums...which is more similar to a book than a show. You can really craft some jerk replies over the internet on a forum. You have to think quickly when talking to someone.

                        Yeah, I stopped watching immediately after the Code Black thing too. I wasn't really even seriously watching for a while leading up to that too.
                         

                        MonkeyNuts!

                        Even Kal has bad days...
                        10+ Year Member
                        Jun 23, 2005
                        3,646
                        14
                          sentrosi said:
                          Why not...we are posting on forums...which is more similar to a book than a show. You can really craft some jerk replies over the internet on a forum. You have to think quickly when talking to someone.

                          Yeah but its also tone of voice, facial expression, body language - it exudes a sort of aura about a person. I don't think just any actor or person could do it, and he must obviously be able to work with the actors around him which is also important for timing and delivery.

                          Grey's has an extremely good group dynamic I think, probably one of the better ones since Friends. But the problem is that it operates sort of on the Sex and the City group dynamic where you have a central character (Meredith or Carrie) and other characters around them that play into their own little stories and also bigger dramas. And when the central character starts to get really annoying (think Carrie in Season 5), it just brings the show down a notch. That would be Meredith, gradually declining over the second season until coming to a complete crash at its close.

                          The real problem with House isn't House or House's voice (as previously commented), but the fact that every episode is nearly identical. Someone comes in with strange symptoms. There's a blurb at the beginning of how one of the characters gets it to House's attention. Then they brainstorm and try incorrect treatments all episode long, putting the patient on the brink of death, while House makes questionable calls and raids the patients' homes until finally Wilson or Cuddy or one of the characters (possibly one in clinic) says something that causes an epiphany for House and they cue the dramatic music and he rushes in (sometimes argues with his staff about the validity of his eureka) and saves the day. And they weave in about 5 minutes here and there of background drama, sometimes a background storyline that may last 2 or 3 episodes (like his exwife).

                          The good thing about that repetition is that House really can't change. So he can't turn into a babbling whiny annoying spineless fruitcake like Meredith, and the show survives until it bores everyone to the point where they might contemplate going back to reality shows or those stupid singing dancing talent shows.
                           

                          mintendo

                          Full Member
                          10+ Year Member
                          5+ Year Member
                          Jun 29, 2005
                          502
                          1
                            Depakote said:
                            Agreed.

                            It's the only medical show that's even worth watching.

                            I love Scrubs! But I think season 5 got a little out of hand. About 3 quarters of the episodes had nothing to do with the hospital or medicine. And what's up with everyone getting pregnant?
                             

                            Matth52

                            Senior Member
                            10+ Year Member
                            Jun 29, 2006
                            117
                            0
                            West Lafayette/Naptown, IN
                            www.mdapplicants.com
                            1. Pre-Medical
                              mintendo said:
                              I love Scrubs! But I think season 5 got a little out of hand. About 3 quarters of the episodes had nothing to do with the hospital or medicine. And what's up with everyone getting pregnant?
                              That is a really good question, but it should make the next season interesting.

                              But I must also show my support for Grey's, I mean if it wasn't for that show girls couldn't call me Dr. McDreamy (made my week when they said it). By the way nice avatar
                               

                              Dr.Acula

                              Senior Member
                              10+ Year Member
                              5+ Year Member
                              May 17, 2006
                              363
                              0
                              1. Pre-Medical
                                mintendo said:
                                I love Scrubs! But I think season 5 got a little out of hand. About 3 quarters of the episodes had nothing to do with the hospital or medicine. And what's up with everyone getting pregnant?

                                Your bordering on blasphemy here mintendo, watch yourelf... :laugh:
                                 

                                baylormed

                                On the Search
                                10+ Year Member
                                5+ Year Member
                                Dec 4, 2005
                                4,286
                                53
                                Right behind you
                                1. Post Doc
                                  MJB said:
                                  I'll take this problem over actual shows than all the crap that's on TV these days (Idol, Survivor, Factor, etc..)

                                  So True...^^

                                  On a completely different topic (non-doctor-related), does anyone else Prison Break is an awesome show??? My roomate and I got addicted...it might be some of the few non-crap shows on TV today.
                                   

                                  mychelle774

                                  Full Member
                                  10+ Year Member
                                  5+ Year Member
                                  Mar 22, 2006
                                  431
                                  0
                                  Houston, TX
                                  1. Pre-Medical
                                    mintendo said:
                                    I love Scrubs! But I think season 5 got a little out of hand. About 3 quarters of the episodes had nothing to do with the hospital or medicine. And what's up with everyone getting pregnant?

                                    I will still defend the show to the death blindly, but yeah Zach Braff himself said the writers went a little zany as of late.

                                    baylormed said:
                                    On a completely different topic (non-doctor-related), does anyone else Prison Break is an awesome show??? My roomate and I got addicted...it might be some of the few non-crap shows on TV today.

                                    YES! Why is the main guy so sexy? Oh yeah, because he's a frickin genius. With balls. :rolleyes:
                                     
                                    About the Ads
                                    This thread is more than 15 years old.

                                    Your message may be considered spam for the following reasons:

                                    1. Your new thread title is very short, and likely is unhelpful.
                                    2. Your reply is very short and likely does not add anything to the thread.
                                    3. Your reply is very long and likely does not add anything to the thread.
                                    4. It is very likely that it does not need any further discussion and thus bumping it serves no purpose.
                                    5. Your message is mostly quotes or spoilers.
                                    6. Your reply has occurred very quickly after a previous reply and likely does not add anything to the thread.
                                    7. This thread is locked.