- Joined
- Dec 4, 2006
- Messages
- 140
- Reaction score
- 0
Does going to grad school for a few years (in a scientific field) boost one's chances of getting into med school? While the classic answer is not necessarily, I think it very well might.
Consider: John graduates college with a GPA that's sub-par for medical school (<3.5.) He does post-bacc for a year (and does very well), but he's still weighed down by his low UG gpa. Even if we assume a decent MCAT (>32), he will still have a hard time getting into ANY medical school. Best case: he will get into a bottom-tier med school.
Alternative: After doing his post-bacc, John enters a PhD program in a scientific field at a top tier university. He does very well in his studies, is able to participate in advanced-level research, etc. After 1-3 years in the program , John applied to medical school. Instead of being a subpar student desperate to get into med school, he has demonstrated his ability to excel in a difficult scientific field. His chances of getting into medical school are now significantly enhanced. Also, if his graduate program is closely affiliated with his own school's medical school, it's not hard to imagine him gaining serious consideration there, due to connections, etc.
Now obviously, this scenario only makes sense if the applicant LIKES the idea of going to graduate school in the selected field, etc. If he can't stand the thought, then maybe an SMP would be better for him. But in my analysis, John is someone who has a long-term goal of going to medical school, but is also interested in graduate studies.
Its interesting that of all the PhDs who go to med school, I don't think you'd find many Ivy League PhDs sitting at Nova Southeastern D.O. school. Graduate studies at a top-tier school seem to mark you as a top caliber student. But, you may well find some kids at Nova who had the potential to do graduate studies at an Ivy League school.
It's exponentially easier to gain admission to a top-tier science graduate program as opposed to a top-tier medical program. Thus, for someone who likes the field, it may be a good decision to put in some years there, to greatly boost chances of admission to med school (as well as to learn material they love and enjoy.)
I realize that the scenarios I've discussed may apply to only a small subset of med-school aspirants. But they seem to make sense for that group. What do you guys think of my analysis?
Consider: John graduates college with a GPA that's sub-par for medical school (<3.5.) He does post-bacc for a year (and does very well), but he's still weighed down by his low UG gpa. Even if we assume a decent MCAT (>32), he will still have a hard time getting into ANY medical school. Best case: he will get into a bottom-tier med school.
Alternative: After doing his post-bacc, John enters a PhD program in a scientific field at a top tier university. He does very well in his studies, is able to participate in advanced-level research, etc. After 1-3 years in the program , John applied to medical school. Instead of being a subpar student desperate to get into med school, he has demonstrated his ability to excel in a difficult scientific field. His chances of getting into medical school are now significantly enhanced. Also, if his graduate program is closely affiliated with his own school's medical school, it's not hard to imagine him gaining serious consideration there, due to connections, etc.
Now obviously, this scenario only makes sense if the applicant LIKES the idea of going to graduate school in the selected field, etc. If he can't stand the thought, then maybe an SMP would be better for him. But in my analysis, John is someone who has a long-term goal of going to medical school, but is also interested in graduate studies.
Its interesting that of all the PhDs who go to med school, I don't think you'd find many Ivy League PhDs sitting at Nova Southeastern D.O. school. Graduate studies at a top-tier school seem to mark you as a top caliber student. But, you may well find some kids at Nova who had the potential to do graduate studies at an Ivy League school.
It's exponentially easier to gain admission to a top-tier science graduate program as opposed to a top-tier medical program. Thus, for someone who likes the field, it may be a good decision to put in some years there, to greatly boost chances of admission to med school (as well as to learn material they love and enjoy.)
I realize that the scenarios I've discussed may apply to only a small subset of med-school aspirants. But they seem to make sense for that group. What do you guys think of my analysis?