- Joined
- Jan 17, 2005
- Messages
- 418
- Reaction score
- 0
Doesn't it kill the soul? I've been doing some OR shadowing and I'm starting to see the "glorified plumber" angle.
to me thats when it will become fun, i hopeDoesn't it kill the soul? I've been doing some OR shadowing and I'm starting to see the "glorified plumber" angle.
Doesn't it kill the soul? I've been doing some OR shadowing and I'm starting to see the "glorified plumber" angle.
Doesn't it kill the soul? I've been doing some OR shadowing and I'm starting to see the "glorified plumber" angle.
Its a little more fun actually doing the operation than watching one.
Yes, some days you feel like you'd rather be doing anything but your 500th Lap Chole but this is true for any job. Show me a career which doesn't have repetition and drudgery.
This is a valid point I agree. Unless you are something exceptional like a CEO or the president, you're going to have repetition. I think repetition is a fact in medicine and other mechanical professions where practice makes perfect.
I would venture that even those jobs have their fair share of repetition and drudgery. Unless you've been in business meetings, you have no idea how much of the stuff discussed has been talked about at length in prior meetings.
I'd rather spend the rest of my life doing lap choles than sitting in meetings discussing the same old crap over and over.
Fair points. I just think in surgery the problem and the solutions are virtually the same for every procedure. A CEO, for example, would face new problems (shifts in the industry, new competition) and would have to come up with new solutions (product development, hr work). Theres quite a bit more analysis, creativity, and risk involved.
Doesn't it kill the soul? I've been doing some OR shadowing and I'm starting to see the "glorified plumber" angle.
So, please, before you tell us what it's like to be a surgeon, try holding the knife in your hand and saving a life with it and then tell me how you really feel. I think it's a far superior feeling to do that than to make another million or two. (OK, maybe a billion or two would cut it?)
Its a little more fun actually doing the operation than watching one.
... I think it's a far superior feeling to do that than to make another million or two. (OK, maybe a billion or two would cut it?)
Don't get defensive man.
It depends on the personality I suppose. Bill Gates could never be Harvey Cushing. Cushing could never be Gates.
Don't get defensive man.
Fair points. I just think in surgery the problem and the solutions are virtually the same for every procedure.
We get it, we get it: Your **** is huge.
No need to keep waving it around all the time.
We get it, we get it: Your **** is huge.
No need to keep waving it around all the time.
Just wait until a radiologist is able to do your procedure less invasively or some new guy in your town is willing to do it for 25% less. Economics could care less how big your ego is.
Just wait until a radiologist is able to do your procedure less invasively or some new guy in your town is willing to do it for 25% less. Economics could care less how big your ego is.
I agree with the point that there are tradeoffs to every profession and surgery by nature requires repetition to master it. There is no "superior profession" and certainly no one is (or should be) above the market. Its all about personality. Like I said there is no way in hell bill gates or michael dell or whoever would have the patience to work in an OR for most of the day. Some people like systematic procedures better.
I've been doing some OR shadowing and I'm starting to see the "glorified plumber" angle.
I think repetition is a fact in medicine and other mechanical professions where practice makes perfect.
I just think in surgery the problem and the solutions are virtually the same for every procedure.
A CEO, for example, would face new problems (shifts in the industry, new competition) and would have to come up with new solutions (product development, hr work). Theres quite a bit more analysis, creativity, and risk involved.
Don't get defensive man.
Just wait until a radiologist is able to do your procedure less invasively or some new guy in your town is willing to do it for 25% less. Economics could care less how big your ego is.
Just wait until a radiologist is able to do your procedure less invasively or some new guy in your town is willing to do it for 25% less.
From what shoddy internet source did you pull this garbage data out of your butt?
Perhaps neither being a surgeon nor a CEO of a major multinational is in your future. Sounds to me like you'd be an excellent politician.
From what shoddy internet source did you pull this garbage data out of your butt?
Perhaps neither being a surgeon nor a CEO of a major multinational is in your future. Sounds to me like you'd be an excellent politician.
Just wait until a radiologist is able to do your procedure less invasively or some new guy in your town is willing to do it for 25% less
Maybe it's hearing you whine about how the "procedural" medicine specialties are stealing all your cases with good reimbursement?
This is what happens when a lay person reads a "medical website" and thinks he's now a physician.
Awesome that you've obtained this point of view as a pre-med. Despite the alternative point of view given here by actual practicing surgeons, you, as an apparent pre-med, presume to judge the whole field and simply it by saying essentially "it's plumbing and all problems are the same". Again, why are you here?
"Lay people" are actually quite a bit smarter than physicians. You know all that equipment in the OR? The things that actually saves lives? Those were invented by the "lay people".
I've followed top surgeons, seen procedures, sat in med school courses, I've started and run my own company. I think I have the exposure to make judgements. I make these conclusions and trust my intelligence, which has been quite reliable in the past. I was willing to challenge them by posting here. Good luck to you as well.
"Lay people" are actually quite a bit smarter than physicians. You know all that equipment in the OR? The things that actually saves lives? Those were invented by the "lay people".
I've followed top surgeons, seen procedures, sat in med school courses, I've started and run my own company. I think I have the exposure to make judgements. I make these conclusions and trust my intelligence, which has been quite reliable in the past. I was willing to challenge them by posting here. Good luck to you as well.
I've followed top surgeons, seen procedures, sat in med school courses, I've started and run my own company. I think I have the exposure to make judgements. I make these conclusions and trust my intelligence, which has been quite reliable in the past. I was willing to challenge them by posting here. Good luck to you as well.
I've followed top surgeons, seen procedures, sat in med school courses, I've started and run my own company. I think I have the exposure to make judgements. I make these conclusions and trust my intelligence, which has been quite reliable in the past. I was willing to challenge them by posting here. Good luck to you as well.
You sat in on random med courses, shadowed some surgeons, watched them perform some procedures and you think you've got medicine all figured out?
I thought he could be a troll myself, but the guy's been registered since 2005 and has a few hundred posts. He's a lurker to be sure and has come to one of the most stupidly presumptuous conclusions I've ever read about surgeons and surgery.
I'm almost thinking this could be a Wiccan incarnate of Cheisu. Has anyone seen his MySpace page recently? Perhaps he's gone from wanting to be nothing but a surgeon to wanting to be a corporate raider.
Yeah, he definitely lost cool points for admitting that.
When he said that his motivation for becoming a surgeon was watching Gray's Anatomy, I don't think he had any "cool points" left to lose.