Yes, I do.
If you think the floorplans look crappy, wait until you see the real thing! It's a matter of convenience for most of us who choose to live in campus housing, but if we had a choice, we wouldn't.
Park Slope is a short TRAIN ride away. You can walk it in about 45 minutes, but you're gonna be passing through some rough neighborhoods on the way in and out.
A subway ride is about 20-25 minutes, depending on the day.
Most of the rooms are designed to be doubles, and you're told as first-years that it's tough to get singles. This simply isn't true. I know a ton of first-years who have singles. Because the rooms are on the small side, most studnets opt for singles to give themselves some space.
Mill Basin isn't too far away. If living at home isn't a problem, as you've indicated that it might be, I'd live at home. Living in campus housing honestly won't bring you any closer to your classmates. The dorms aren't very social dorms. At some colleges there's the social, social dorm where everyone on a floor knows each other and there's the really introverted dorm where no one knows anyone else. Our dorms are like the latter rather than the former, for the most part.
I've heard that only about 60% of the MS1 class lives in campus housing. Almost everyone else lives in Park Slope. I know you think commuting to med school is ridiculous, but when you consider the alternative, commuting doesn't seem so bad!
The one thing cool about the dorms is that you can roll outta bed and be in class within 10 minutes. But is that worth the price tag? The frequent elevator breakdowns? The hot-water being turned off without much advance notice?
You'll get to see the dorms for Second Look day. If you haven't already, I'd try to set up a sleep over with someone to see what the dorms are like. You won't be disappointed that you did.
W.