No, the "idiot village" would be a group thing.
Why?
Beat me to it
I've done similar. I'm also not really a good example for anything though.
So it looks like y’all are wanting explanation for a number of things. I’ll oblige because I’m sure I’m at the top of people’s suspicious list and I don’t want to be lynched because of a last minute waffle-fest.
1. My search for the ability user.
I want to find them so I have a little more information to the game (and cuz I’m mad I was a target haha). I don’t want the whole village to know because once we are sure that person is a villager, they become wolf-bait because the wolves know that the villagers won’t lynch someone they know is a villager, and the only way to get rid of them now is to kill them at night. I personally would like to avoid that and am being intentionally vague. As for “future scenario” thought process, if I can identify that person as a villager, then I can stop us from lynching another villager.
Another reason I won’t say is because if I come right out and say “x happened to me” its far to easy for a wolf to say “oh yeah that was me, I did that” whereas if I just ask simply for the person who used it on me, they now have the burden of proof to tell me what happened so I can confirm they are who they say they are.
Now if it WAS a wolf, they’ll probably just ignore me and move on, and I’ve gained/lost nothing and at that point I can be a little more confident that revealing what happened last night won’t hurt us.
2.Addressing Mama’s concerns
So you want to lynch me over vibes and a WIFOM scenario? I’m actively trying to gamesolve and posing questions that are only going to help ferret out wolves.
3.My analysis after my first post.
I gave you my two cents, you’re welcome to take it or leave it as you see fit. Its worked before so I’m willing to give a chance to work here, but I agree playing this in person and online are two different beasts as I've quickly learned.
Did I miss any questions/concerns? (Not sarcasm, asking so that I can address them)
I’m just trying to collect info without absolutely having to reveal it until the right time. If my way of going about that is abrasive then fine, because ultimately I’m a villager. If it comes down to the wire, the info I gather will make sure I have better cases for why someone else is a wolf than the cases set against me.
As for my vote, I’m sticking with Sheltermed because of the reasons I listed a couple posts ago, and I’m not willing to commit to LotF because (although she is sketchy) my evidence-for-wolf threshold hasn’t been met and I think it would be a mistake to lynch her just yet.
Dios Mio, @DocEspana I didn’t mean to fuel your already god-like, blimp crashing ego haha but I’ll put protoman and all stars on my list of to be read.
Beat me to it
I'm not even a good example of that anymore. I used to be the king of memes, but my memetics have atrophied as medical school has marched on. I realized I had like, less than a dozen memes saved from the last three months the other day, and they were pretty much all depression memes lol.
I just get a read on the way zhe thinks about things. And since I now know favorite book and how that has influenced them, plus the way they presented those ideas, it makes me pretty confident after the last few posts that Mel is village. Maybe 75%.
Yes, because that is how that works. "Answer my questions, how dare you suggest there isn't time to do more than answer the accusations and not go reread the thread?"
Vanillager with hope? Yup. That is a walk back from vanillager... with hope to be more. Yup.
Firstly I think LotF is at the top of the suspicious list since she's in the lead for lynching. Secondly I think it's wierd to want info for yourself but you don't want the whole village to know (and yes I read your reasoning). Thirdly (and I think you maybe talked about this already) have you read any previous games on this forum?So it looks like y’all are wanting explanation for a number of things. I’ll oblige because I’m sure I’m at the top of people’s suspicious list and I don’t want to be lynched because of a last minute waffle-fest.
1. My search for the ability user.
I want to find them so I have a little more information to the game (and cuz I’m mad I was a target haha). I don’t want the whole village to know because once we are sure that person is a villager, they become wolf-bait because the wolves know that the villagers won’t lynch someone they know is a villager, and the only way to get rid of them now is to kill them at night. I personally would like to avoid that and am being intentionally vague. As for “future scenario” thought process, if I can identify that person as a villager, then I can stop us from lynching another villager.
Another reason I won’t say is because if I come right out and say “x happened to me” its far to easy for a wolf to say “oh yeah that was me, I did that” whereas if I just ask simply for the person who used it on me, they now have the burden of proof to tell me what happened so I can confirm they are who they say they are.
Now if it WAS a wolf, they’ll probably just ignore me and move on, and I’ve gained/lost nothing and at that point I can be a little more confident that revealing what happened last night won’t hurt us.
2.Addressing Mama’s concerns
So you want to lynch me over vibes and a WIFOM scenario? I’m actively trying to gamesolve and posing questions that are only going to help ferret out wolves.
3.My analysis after my first post.
I gave you my two cents, you’re welcome to take it or leave it as you see fit. Its worked before so I’m willing to give a chance to work here, but I agree playing this in person and online are two different beasts as I've quickly learned.
Did I miss any questions/concerns? (Not sarcasm, asking so that I can address them)
I’m just trying to collect info without absolutely having to reveal it until the right time. If my way of going about that is abrasive then fine, because ultimately I’m a villager. If it comes down to the wire, the info I gather will make sure I have better cases for why someone else is a wolf than the cases set against me.
As for my vote, I’m sticking with Sheltermed because of the reasons I listed a couple posts ago, and I’m not willing to commit to LotF because (although she is sketchy) my evidence-for-wolf threshold hasn’t been met and I think it would be a mistake to lynch her just yet.
Dios Mio, @DocEspana I didn’t mean to fuel your already god-like, blimp crashing ego haha but I’ll put protoman and all stars on my list of to be read.
Beat me to it
at some of the justifications I'm seeing. Here's the ones I'd like to hear more about.To whom would that information be useful, except for the wolves?
How would we know that the person who steps forward is a villager?
How does how someone talking about their favorite series clear them?
Definitely not talking about the people who have limited availability but are contributing when they can, as evidenced by the fact that I stood up for Zen (and you) today from a schedule perspective. Particularly when I know some of you guys signed up to get the game going. I'm talking about people who have posted like 3 lines total so far and can't seem to be bothered to vote. That's not a scheduling conflict issue, in my mind at least. But also, /end grump because I ate some dinner and now feel less inclined to hrmph
Ehhh. Getting eerie deja vu flashbacks to your last wolfy turns around the dance floor with some of this wording. Free pass for rn because you're kind of cramming a lot into a late lynch vote post, but...there are things about this that give me a minor case of the heebie jeebies, and I'm just putting that out there.
I feel like that "play the game" comment had to be sarcasm.
Lynch hmoo for not understanding how DDS plays
So you may have already talked about this but why don't you like the LotF vote? (I'm on my phone and it's a pain in the ass to search for previous quotes)
The more the day goes on the less I'm against voting for her, but since I'm pretty sure she's going to be lynched, I'm trying to explore other avenues.
I see you trying to kick start a bandwagon. Also, I like how you quote my lynch justification immediately prior to my lynch decision post and claim I offered no reasons. Since when is it a requirement to write a treatise to lynching each time you participate in the deed? I've seen many a vote with decidedly less examination proclamation.
That's not what she said, or why she said she's doing it.
What "reasons"? It barely even classifies as justification. You've literally thrown out useless lynch votes with no explanation and say that's not wolfy?
I'm not "wasting" a vote just because I'm not lynching someone in the lead. I'm voting for who I think is a wolf.
Wait why shelter? They were voting for LIS before dds (right?)
See two posts above. I misread "The more the day goes on the less I'm against voting for her" for the opposite.
I remember that one time I was a wolf, and I openly reflected on the nature of wolves trying to elicit the confusion about roles and such. This very pointedly outed me as what I was - a wolf. This isn't my first rodeo, clown.
My guess is he was blocked and upset about it... It is how raf got a wolf accidentally last game... Idiot savant?
