- Joined
- Feb 12, 2006
- Messages
- 133
- Reaction score
- 0
at Alameda/Highland per SAEM website.
For those in need of a spot...give them a shout.
For those in need of a spot...give them a shout.
if we're matched already, can we switch into this spot?
I'm imagining those that didn't scramble into an EM spot may have a better chance by explaining that a spot is open in EM, the field they really want. Don't remember if you were one of the lucky/unlucky ones in the scramble, so sorry if this is not relevant.
I applied this past year and did not match into EM. Upon signing my contract (prelim spot in medicine), I asked the PD if I can get out of it if a miracle happens and an EM spot becomes available and the PD said a firm NO. I would apply for the open EM-1 spot but that would be shady given that I would not have permition from my current PD.
Shady or not. I would apply. It is your future not his. By definition a prelim spot does not lead to completion in any field. Any reasonable program director should realize this and be willing (not necessarily happy though) to help.
It's permission, not permition. At any rate, if you apply without your PD's permission and Highland tells you no, then your life will be a nightmare where you are doing your prelim year. That PD will be ticked that you applied anyway after he specifically told you that you couldn't.So in this case does this mean that I can apply without permition from my soon-to-be PD?
According to SAEM website, Highland requires prior approval from your current PD. So if you apply without your PD's permission, I highly doubt that Highland would take you, and most likely, your current PD would find out about it.
If you really want to apply, try talking to your PD again.
I agree. Last time, you asked 'What if'. If you go to him now with proof of an open spot and your desire to apply with the part underlined must have current PDs permission..... I think any decent human being would allow you. I would certainly argue the 'professional' thing to do is to allow you to apply. If he refuses, all I can say is that is a sad and crappy situation to be in. I would certainly make the chairmen of the department in the know if the PD refuses...unless they are one in the same. It's likely he will stand behind the PDs decision, but you never know...
Just explain to him the situation, and ask him again. If he says no he says no, but you will never know unless you ask.
So you can void your NRMP contract if your current PD decides to allow you to change programs?
I do not have an NRMP contract as I scrambled for my position. If I would have matched into a spot then there would be no discussion as NRMP rules say that I must start the year at the residency who matched me. If I would be a PD and I had a prelim that wanted to pursuit his/her dream career, regardless of how it might inconvenience me or my program, I would let them at least apply. Still, I understand that the PD has to look out for his/her program especially this close to the start of another year and that a possibility of a resident leaving in may or june will give them headaches and panic in the near future. I am a bit biased in my opinion though.
Regarding voiding NRMP contracts, it can be done theoretically. This is very unlikely as you would have to have two incoming residents that would agree to switch to each other's residency programs, two understanding PDs who will agree to this headache and then you would still need NRMP to agree to it.