- Joined
- Aug 12, 2004
- Messages
- 3,049
- Reaction score
- 6,409
CRNAs should lead “their” departments. Oh lord these are some funny delusions of grandeur. That is downright hilarious
AANA words not mine
CRNAs should lead “their” departments. Oh lord these are some funny delusions of grandeur. That is downright hilarious
No one has a right to demand labor. But that is an absolutely stupid argument to attempt to assert in times of a viral pandemic. Is says so much about you, and nothing about those around you. Is that how you want to be viewed? Maybe you don’t care. You should.
In my mind it’s very simple. Patients are sick and need the skills of CRNAs and Anesthesiologists. It’s been a time to come together, push differences aside, and simply do what’s right for patients. It’s not a terribly complex issue. My guess if I were to read everyone’s med school or nursing school essays they’d allude to things like ‘helping people’.
In my department roughly 5% of CRNAs volunteered to help in the ICU. 100%
of anesthesiologists said they’d do whatever is asked of them by the hospital.
The AANA said CRNAs should ‘lead their departments working from home’.
Believe me. I’ve been side by side with rank and file janitors, RTs, and RNs helping patients with covid19. Ive not seen a CRNA.
I know the score and I won’t forget. Is it right to DEMAND service? No. But to hell with your philosophical argument. When it hits the fan and patients need care, you provide it. Plain and simple. It’s not complex.
Someone above was linking the crna Independance argument to them not wanting to be icu nurses...that’s how it startedI guess I missed the post where someone said ‘So and So DEMANDED the crna be an icu nurse and they refused....how awful!’.
Quite the contrary - most hospitals have called out for volunteers. The CRNAs either pitched in or they didn’t. But hospitals and their physicians moved on with their duty.
No offense I just don’t see the need for the extremely predictable libertarian viewpoint insert.
Nope. You are saying no one has a right to demand, and then you drop an emotional demand
You are correct that it isn’t complex though, if you want staff to show up you offer the combination of pay/ppe/workload that it takes to make them want to come in
Someone above was linking the crna Independance argument to them not wanting to be icu nurses...that’s how it started
Nope. You are saying no one has a right to demand, and then you drop an emotional demand
You are correct that it isn’t complex though, if you want staff to show up you offer the combination of pay/ppe/workload that it takes to make them want to come in
Need more info here. Are the CRNA’s salaried employees of the hospital? Salaried by the group? Were they laid off by the group and then the hospital asked them to volunteer? If so was it with or without pay? Are you guys a PP or salaried? Did 100% of the docs agree to “volunteer” for the hospital because it is profitable contract that you want to keep ?No one has a right to demand labor. But that is an absolutely stupid argument to attempt to assert in times of a viral pandemic. Is says so much about you, and nothing about those around you. Is that how you want to be viewed? Maybe you don’t care. You should.
In my mind it’s very simple. Patients are sick and need the skills of CRNAs and Anesthesiologists. It’s been a time to come together, push differences aside, and simply do what’s right for patients. It’s not a terribly complex issue. My guess if I were to read everyone’s med school or nursing school essays they’d allude to things like ‘helping people’.
In my department roughly 5% of CRNAs volunteered to help in the ICU. 100%
of anesthesiologists said they’d do whatever is asked of them by the hospital.
The AANA said CRNAs should ‘lead their departments working from home’.
Believe me. I’ve been side by side with rank and file janitors, RTs, and RNs helping patients with covid19. Ive not seen a CRNA.
Yup. That’s exactly what it is. It’s because there is little to no liability for COVID care 1) because of state mandates and 2) because the family is not allowed in to see what is going on.Then, when they decided to pay for the help they needed, how many took in the ed and floor nurses that offered to come help because it was cheaper? All I can say is I see tons of unqualified ed and floor nurses in the icu and I bet the cost has something to do with it.
Emotional stories don’t change the principlesYou should tell that to the family of the 47 year old guy who died because the bag of Epi running at 4 ran out and the Levo running at 10 had an upstream occlusion and stopped infusing and the Vaso was hung but never confirmed. He coded quite sometime before the ed nurse with 6 vented patients got back to his room to notice the pumps were alarming.
Or maybe you tell that to the lady got extubated but probably ends up with ptsd cuz she had roc running and no sedation. Review of the monitor stored vitals shows she was systollics of 180-200 and hr 140s for as far as I could scroll back.
Need more info here. Are the CRNA’s salaried employees of the hospital? Salaried by the group? Were they laid off by the group and then the hospital asked them to volunteer? If so was it with or without pay? Are you guys a PP or salaried? Did 100% of the docs agree to “volunteer” for the hospital because it is profitable contract that you want to keep ?
We have quite a few CRNA’s and docs that are sitting this out. Some are older, more financially secure, and want no part of this. Some don’t want to do ICU care. Some are pregnant. Whatever. That is their choice and they are on leave without pay. It’s still a free country last I checked. This is a JOB. Your only reward is a paycheck. Your “selfless heroics “ will be forgotten in the blink of an eye by the hospital the moment this is over.....
Emotional stories don’t change the principles
you want more staff? Pay and treat them appropriately. No one has a right to someone else’s labor
Your “selfless heroics “ will be forgotten in the blink of an eye by the hospital the moment this is over.....
“You” was the generic pronoun for society in my statement. Some were making a pitch for volunteers. I was saying if that hospital is short handed, they need to payYour post lacks relevance. @anes121508 is posting examples of how good nursing care would make a difference. You are posting libertarian diatribes that have nothing to do with it. Do you think @anes121508 has a say in nurse staffing for the ICU?
When times are good, you get normal pay, praise, hours, and "normal" experiences. The moment things get a bit tight, it's everyone for themselves. You will have your hours cut, your position furloughed, and your retirement plan contributions will be halted. Don't like it? Go pound sand.
I also feel like the CRNAs would probably do much better than ED nurses and especially floor nurses.My friends who are crnas say the statement by their governing body is dissapointing and puts them in a position that makes them look bad.
Judging by the crnas I know and the crnas I’ve seen bust their butts to lend a helping hand in any way shape or form, I don’t think the majority of the crnas out there support the aana statement.
Many crnas I know have commented that they wish there was a more organized manner and opportunity to help. I’m seeing crnas floating around icus painfully watching floor and ed nurses flounder. They are trying to be polite and not step on toes but they are jumping in to help.
To be honest I think I’ve read many people on this site disagree with the Asa leadership. Just interesting how leadership can misrepresent the boots on the ground.
It’s not just about money. People are scared and want nothing to do with this no matter how much money you throw at them.“You” was the generic pronoun for society in my statement. Some were making a pitch for volunteers. I was saying if that hospital is short handed, they need to pay
Absolutely right. I wonder how much money it would take for him to offer his services, since you know. It’s all about the hospitals needing to pay a premium.Just a friendly reminder for everyone who keeps pointlessly trying to reason with sb247:
He is a person who literally said he would give up his own sick child for adoption to a wealthier family before seeking taxpayer-funded healthcare.
One can have reasonable discussions with run of the mill libertarians-the insane quasi-anarchist ones merely exist to annoy people on the internet by shtting up threads with nonsense they wouldn’t dare utter out loud in real life
In real life (particularly the more “progressive” folks) try to end careers of people who disagree with them, one must be a little more selective of their conversations there.Just a friendly reminder for everyone who keeps pointlessly trying to reason with sb247:
He is a person who literally said he would give up his own sick child for adoption to a wealthier family before seeking taxpayer-funded healthcare.
One can have reasonable discussions with run of the mill libertarians-the insane quasi-anarchist ones merely exist to annoy people on the internet by shtting up threads with nonsense they wouldn’t dare utter out loud in real life
Residents get told they don’t get to moonlight and we’ll be quarantined without pay if we travel on our vacation time. Otherwise there is a number that would get me there. There are laid off and reduced hour rns/pas/nps/docs all over the country right nowAbsolutely right. I wonder how much money it would take for him to offer his services, since you know. It’s all about the hospitals needing to pay a premium.
In real life (particularly the more “progressive” folks) try to end careers of people who disagree with them, one must be a little more selective of their conversations there.
You want to keep going back to that issue we can rabbit trail the whole thread, your callPersecution complex, much? Lighten up, snowflake, cause it isn't your employer being "progressive" that's gonna predispose them to weird looks if you ever shared your 'give away my sick kid cause taxation is theft' hot take. They're not gonna wonder if you're too libertarian- they're going to wonder if you're mentally ill.
Residents get told they don’t get to moonlight and we’ll be quarantined without pay if we travel on our vacation time. Otherwise there is a number that would get me there. There are laid off and reduced hour rns/pas/nps/docs all over the country right now
I’m not arguing to go, I understand and follow my rules. I was asked if a number existed that would make me want to, yes there is.I’m sorry but everyone doesn’t get to do whatever they want, whenever they want. Life is full of rules. My 4yo gets that. Why is it so difficult for you?
That’s not to say there isn’t a nuanced point buried in your hardline lib views. There is. But you lose it with your approach.
The money is there. If one looks. In some hospitals. So why aren’t all these laid up people there? Why is NY still struggling?In real life (particularly the more “progressive” folks) try to end careers of people who disagree with them, one must be a little more selective of their conversations there.
Residents get told they don’t get to moonlight and we’ll be quarantined without pay if we travel on our vacation time. Otherwise there is a number that would get me there. There are laid off and reduced hour rns/pas/nps/docs all over the country right now
You are welcome to continue to disagree as this is a matter of opinion, but a lot of folks just started getting their hours cut and the differentials might not yet be to the point where they all feel it’s worth the hassle.The money is there. If one looks. In some hospitals. So why aren’t all these laid up people there? Why is NY still struggling?
From someone who’s been there, it’s not just about the money. You are naive.
I’m not arguing to go, I understand and follow my rules. I was asked if a number existed that would make me want to, yes there is.
it seems like your ideological disagreement with me has you reacting to things I’m not saying
I am not talking of the ones who just “started” getting their hours cut. Plenty of people have been sitting around for weeks even months. When this thing was hot and heavy. Why didn’t they all flock up there to the hospitals that were paying?You are welcome to continue to disagree as this is a matter of opinion, but a lot of folks just started getting their hours cut and the differentials might not yet be to the point where they all feel it’s worth the hassle.
No amount of staff differential can make a hospital bigger though which is a different infrastructure conversation altogether, likely for another thread at a later date
Since you’re asking, most docs and even nurses should have a few weeks of money saved up, many got some sort of furlough pay, and many might be thinking if it kicks off in their current location there will be plenty of money here soon. There is also the fact that some hospitals have been saying that traveling out of their network to work is not allowed in the contract they have and they would be quarantined on return.I am not talking of the ones who just “started” getting their hours cut. Plenty of people have been sitting around for weeks even months. When this thing was hot and heavy. Why didn’t they all flock up there to the hospitals that were paying?
Exactly. Plenty of people aren’t going up there for a multitude of reasons. You just proved my point.Since you’re asking, most docs and even nurses should have a few weeks of money saved up, many got some sort of furlough pay, and many might be thinking if it kicks off in their current location there will be plenty of money here soon. There is also the fact that some hospitals have been saying that traveling out of their network to work is not allowed in the contract they have and they would be quarantined on return.
for enough money, people will go to afghanistan on contract. They will go to ny too
No. There is a price point that will have enough staff willing to make the trip, we just aren’t there yet or are not willing to pay that number.Exactly. Plenty of people aren’t going up there for a multitude of reasons. You just proved my point.
No matter how much money is being paid, plenty of people don’t need it or don’t want it or can’t take it.
So your solution of throwing a bunch of money at the problem, where there aren’t enough takers for that money is not really a solution then is it?
So stop.
So just out of curiosity, what is that price point? You seem to have a number in mind. Please let us know.No. There is a price point that will have enough staff willing to make the trip, we just aren’t there yet or are not willing to pay that number.
it’s ok for us to just disagree
My price would have to cover 14 days of mandatory isolation when I return, so an additional 2+ weeks without pay. Add in missed family time and the discomfort of travel to a strange city with a legendary history of poorly staffed hospitals...So just out of curiosity, what is that price point? You seem to have a number in mind. Please let us know.
@pjl nailed itSo just out of curiosity, what is that price point? You seem to have a number in mind. Please let us know.
I agree. We are dumb. We need to learn something from the nurses and their unions.My price would have to cover 14 days of mandatory isolation when I return, so an additional 2+ weeks without pay. Add in missed family time and the discomfort of travel to a strange city with a legendary history of poorly staffed hospitals...
I don’t think any of those places would want to afford me.
our hospital is paying all the nurses and staff an extra 15/hr for caring for covid people, and some bonus for just being there. They offered 130/hr for CRNAs to be ICU nurses.
Physicians have been asked to volunteer. Later they offered to pay whatever the MGMA hourly rate is for your specialty.
There are still more physician volunteers than CRNA/nurses, because we are dumb.
That poster above looked good to me if I was allowedI agree. We are dumb. We need to learn something from the nurses and their unions.
I have heard there are people negotiating a nice sum because of the quarantining after it.
Certainly no one should be “volunteering” for free. That’s bull.
However there are people negotiating over $500 an hour out there from what I am hearing.
I just want to know from the young resident what his fee is. To make it worth while.
Quite frankly, what’s to prevent one from going back to work immediately, after coming back there as long as you keep your N95 on at all times?
And it’s just not the city that is hurting. The suburbs and other cities in NY state are hurting as well. So their ratios may be better. I was not in the city than God and had about 10 patients daily.
@nimbus; What were they offering for MD/DOs? Or are our services free? HAHAHA
AANA words not mine
I’ll be honest, the whole CRNA/AANA gaining more power throughout this whole thing has really pushed me (second year about to take boards) away from anesthesia. You guys have convinced me. I don’t want to deal with the CRNA bs or the NP bs. I think I’m gonna pursue radiology.
There have been people (on here specifically) and other places who have been sounding the alarm for at least 8-10 years. The interesting thing is we CAN reverse course. It's going to take thinking outside the box, and the eliminating the concrete thinking which is so prevalent amongsts the people in the ASA and who support the ASA.It is a legit concern. For the first time in my 5 year academic career I am concerned.
I’ll be honest, the whole CRNA/AANA gaining more power throughout this whole thing has really pushed me (second year about to take boards) away from anesthesia. You guys have convinced me. I don’t want to deal with the CRNA bs or the NP bs. I think I’m gonna pursue radiology.
Radiology is not immune either. I have staffed IR biopsies done by PAs.....
Surgeries, perhaps.
Also agree with @46Long. Outside of box should also include patient education. However at the same time, you have board members who will advocate for ACT model. So it’s not an easy task.
People are close to trusting computers...My understanding is that no one would ever trust a NP or PA to do their diagnostic radiology. Seems like that’s a pretty safe field to me.
A mix of DR and IR looks really appealing to me. I can’t imagine PAs are doing IR stuff past the very basic.
Who? I haven’t done a formal study, but I have informally talked to people about it and I have yet to talk to someone who would be okay with AI reading their images without collaborating with a radiologist if at all.People are close to trusting computers...
People are close to trusting computers...
No its similar to the icu docs or the er docs call us for an IV or central line... DO you own work.. Intubation shouldnt be "Only anesthesia does them"Guys are on here complaining about crna's shirking their responsibility to help, and even other MD colleagues. And saying that those in abstentia will get their just desserts when this thing is all over.
Well i do respect your opinion on this and other things but that is just naieve. We have loads of those dog fvckers around my neck of the woods, and those toads just seem to keep on, keeping on.
When it all started we were assured that in ED, emerg would tube their covids, & the medical ICU would tube theirs too. But they're not. Thats no different to not showing up. Ive done 4 in the last week for these w@nkers. Its no different. 'Oh he's difficult airway - bmi 31 and mp3' wtf
Its sh1te, but its the way the world is. Its the way the world always has been. Just because im/we are the fools that cant say no in a smart enough way to get out of harms way
Is it any different to having to do every grotty vascular case or ****ty hip just because the last dickhead colleague of mine thought he heard a murmur, and i know echo! wtf? Its no different