Originally posted by jargon124:
•DJ W.R. - This is the exact dillemma that has been on my mind lately.
I have acceptances so far to NYU and my state school (Arizona). At this point I am going to Arizona, but the ease of this decision is due to the fact that I didn't really like NYU too much when I was there. Now, if somehow I got into Columbia or Sinai (the two best schools I have interviewed at), I would have a very difficult time deciding what to do. On the one hand, my family, friends, and girlfriend are in AZ. On the other, Columbia, for example, is so great a school I almost think it would be foolish to pass up the opportunity to go there. The same holds for Sinai, perhaps, but to a lesser extent. Bottom line, even if I got into Columbia or Sinai, I don't know that I would go. My girlfriend and family are big considerations for me, and cost is also an issue (tuition at Arizona is about 10K). This is sort of personal, but I just don't know if I could live with the fact that I turned my back on such a great relationship (been together for almost 2 years now) just so I could go to a prestigious school. Thoughts on this would be appreciated.
Does anyone think I would be crazy to turn down Columbia (or Sinai)? (I know this is probably just an excercise in the hypothetical, since it's highly unlikely I will get into P&S...but Sinai is a better possibility...and I liked the school alot when I was there)
I think you have to go where you think you will be happiest. That's not so easy to know, of course, so things like location, cost, prestige, curriculum type, match results, etc. must be weighed and balanced according to your personal likes/dislikes.•••
Jargon,
I am faced with a very similar situation. In my opinion, friends, family, and significant others should play a vital role in this decision. After all, they can be the lifeline that keeps you grounded during this insane process!
I think when it comes down to it, you have to go with the place that will provide the most nurturing environment for YOU...not the people on SDN or other neurotic pre-meds!
This is easier than it sounds because those schools with "big" names can really bias your thought process. Forget all of the people that will call you crazy for not going to Columbia or Sinai...YOUR thoughts on the matter are the only ones that count! I guarantee that you will be a great physician regardless of where you end up going...