A couple of questions to consider:
1. Is the scholarship at Finch guaranteed for all four years? Or do you have to reapply- and conceivably lose it- after the first year?
2. Is the scholarship adjusted for tuition increases, i.e., if tuition goes up 2K next year, does the scholarshop go up proportionately?
3. Most importantly- would you be happy at Finch? What did you think of the students you met there, compared to those at Georgetown? Also- a smaller factor- will it bother you to tell people you went to Finch, knowing that many consider it a lower-tier school? Will you regret not having gone to the higher-ranked school?
Myself, I turned down a top-20 private school to attend a small unranked state school- I just couldn't find a good reason to spend all the extra $$$, particularly since I knew I wanted to do primary care. Now it's a year later and I'm still happy with my decision. Of course, I'd be a liar if I said I've *never* doubted my decision- each school has a few things that get bothersome and my school is no exception. On a bad day, I've occasionally thought "Gee, if only I'd gone to the other school, I wouldn't have to deal with this." However, no school is perfect - you just have to find a place that YOU will feel comfortable with (assuming you're fortunate enough to have a choice!)