Florida State Univ COM

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

pedsid

Member
5+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Apr 12, 2004
Messages
89
Reaction score
0
Hey everyone,
There has been some discussion regarding FSU on SDN. I thought I’d provide you with some first hand experience from an M4 perspective. There have been some assertions from one other student on here that I completely disagree with …

Pros:
FSU is a relatively new place (five years old now). The best evidence of their merits is in their students. I really think this is reflected in how the students are treated. We are the focus … people here are completely dedicated to teaching students. Especially in the clinical years … since they are all private practice docs they don’t teach unless they want to. Clinically this has lead to incredible autonomy that I don’t think exists anywhere else. Think about this … when I was on surgery, I was the only student in the entire hospital on surgery. It's really is incredible. In the basic science years I think we have a superior education as well. If you look at students entering MCAT scores –v- their step 1 scores I think you would see the proof in the pudding there. My guess is that our entering MCAT scores are lower than some other schools, because we focus on a lot more than numbers. Our step 1 scores are above the national average, in my class of 38 we only had one person fail and that was by 2 points. One of the things that attracted me here too was the desire of the basic science faculty to change medicine. There is a passion for making better doctors … doctors who are both clinically superior, but also are superior in the doctor-patient relationship. To be aware that there is more going on when you meet the patient than just a disease process … The school is also on the cutting edge of technology. Our clinical learning center is completely state of the art. Those of you who have interviewed there can attest to it … its awesome! We are also all given laptops and pdas from the first year. We’re trained in the technology from the beginning, with a slant towards evidence-based medicine. I also forgot to mention something that’s probably more important than all of this … my classmates. My classmates worked together more than any other group that I’ve ever encountered. There’s no curve here, so no motivation to do anything other than help each other learn. This is what happened with 95% of my classmates. When I compare it to friends at other schools, I think this is what made my medical education much more bearable. The school is continuing this tradition with the student communities, and continued problem-based learning.

Cons:
Well … the entire time I was in my basic science education (first two years) we were in a renovated high school watching this beautiful new building being build. We’d walk up to our student communities smelling bat guano in the halls, etc. I think this mirrors some of the other issues of the school as well. There have certainly been some tweaks to the curriculum since I got there … really most of it not focused on the basic sciences. I believe that this is because it was new … not done at a lot of other places. We have seen faculty come and go, some we liked, some not so much. But the school is much better, and I really think the curriculum is superior and stable. Of course there are going to be growing pains in a new school, and I’d be lying if I said I wasn’t mad or irritating when I was going through them. I’ve certainly sat in the deans office a few times expressing my concerns, or written letters, etc. But what school doesn’t have issues? I sincerely believe that the good far outweighs the bad.

Please feel free to PM me or reply with any questions. Good luck in your applications.
 
Thanks for putting out your opinion. So basically your cons have to do with the old building? Now that thats not a problem, what else were your cons? Does the school listen to the students problems? Are they progressive in that sense? I thought the faculty that I interviewed with was very down to earth and in touch with today's medicine. And the new building was amazing. I thought my experience there was really great.
 
DrMike24 said:
Thanks for putting out your opinion. So basically your cons have to do with the old building? Now that thats not a problem, what else were your cons? Does the school listen to the students problems? Are they progressive in that sense? I thought the faculty that I interviewed with was very down to earth and in touch with today's medicine. And the new building was amazing. I thought my experience there was really great.


Sorry ... guess I made it clear as mud. My cons were more with the growth expereince. We certainly had some growing pains, and I'm sure there will continue to be some. From my part, I very much feel that the adminstration listens. For example, there was a class that the students were very upset with. It was handled internally until the complaints became more persistant. They hired outside consultants to have focus groups with the students to see what the problems were. The consultant made recommendations and we saw change. Another point, they hold a focus groups at the end of many classes to get input from students.

Tell me how many other schools in the coutry do you walk by the dean of the school and say hi and he says hi back and asks how your family is doing by name. I've had dinner at his house (so has every other student here) ... again, I think it's a great place.
 
Hey peds, two questions:

I'm curious as to how the library is coming together? I recall it being a big issue at the start (basically creating a medical library from scratch). I guess it becomes less of a big deal as more content is made available online, but sometimes there's no substitute for heading in and tracking down a hard copy of that article you're hunting for.

Second, are there plans afoot to establish additional "affiliated" residency programs at TMH or TCH? As far as I'm aware (and I may well be wrong), the FP program at TMH is the only local one. I think it would be nice for the community and the school if GME became more of a presence there in Tally.

I'm glad to hear about your positive experiences there. As an FSU (undergrad) alumnus, I'm certainly pulling for the program to do well.
 
You forgot the most serious con of all: having to hear that stupid Seminole chant every fall for four years. I don't think I could take it.
 
Peds,
I was wondering if you could tell me more about the average scores at FSU and residency matching. I tried to find out online but I couldn't find anything about it. At the interview, the only thing I was given was who was interviewing me and at what time. There were no slide shows with graphs of the scores or anything like that. Any info about this or where to find it would be great.

Another thing, where did you do your rotations? What did you think about your location and did you like moving there?

What made you choose FSU over other schools?

Thanks for your input. You have been very helpful.
 
G'ville Nole said:
Hey peds, two questions:

I'm curious as to how the library is coming together? I recall it being a big issue at the start (basically creating a medical library from scratch). I guess it becomes less of a big deal as more content is made available online, but sometimes there's no substitute for heading in and tracking down a hard copy of that article you're hunting for.

Second, are there plans afoot to establish additional "affiliated" residency programs at TMH or TCH? As far as I'm aware (and I may well be wrong), the FP program at TMH is the only local one. I think it would be nice for the community and the school if GME became more of a presence there in Tally.

I'm glad to hear about your positive experiences there. As an FSU (undergrad) alumnus, I'm certainly pulling for the program to do well.

The library is not huge and that's on purpose. The focus on the library is essentially to make it all online. This is important because of the regional campuses ... each campus has a small library ... but it's important to be able to access articles if you are in Perry, or Gretna or Orlando. There's also a focus on studing happening in the student communities ... so there is some study space but most of the study space you will find is in the student communities.

Yes there are residencies comming aboard from what I hear. I think the first will be the OB/Gyn residency in Pensacola ... more to follow I'm sure. Don't forget there are a ton of residency programs with "major" affiliations with us. Two in Pensacola, one in Tally, and lots in Orlando.
 
little_late_MD said:
You forgot the most serious con of all: having to hear that stupid Seminole chant every fall for four years. I don't think I could take it.

No kidding ... I still drove around campus with my gator tag and wearing my Gator stuff. We were members of the alumni association as well, apparently it's the biggest in the state. I think a slight majority of my class went to Florida.
 
DrBlonde said:
Peds,
I was wondering if you could tell me more about the average scores at FSU and residency matching. I tried to find out online but I couldn't find anything about it. At the interview, the only thing I was given was who was interviewing me and at what time. There were no slide shows with graphs of the scores or anything like that. Any info about this or where to find it would be great.

Another thing, where did you do your rotations? What did you think about your location and did you like moving there?

What made you choose FSU over other schools?

Thanks for your input. You have been very helpful.

I'll do my best ... I'll actually see if I can get some solid numbers ... here's what I know.

For step one our averages are typically slightly above the average 218 or so ... for step two they tend to be significantly above ... 230s 235s. That's generalized from the first two classes. Again, there's a ton of diversity in everyway here ... I know people with crazy high MCAT scores coming and and I know some with some pretty low ones as well. One of the guys I know who had a pretty low score on the MCAT got something like the 11th highest score on step one in the nation.

I don't think anyone has failed step two ... either CK or CS. Step one, again we had one fail.

Residencies ... everyone matched. A few had to scramble ... but from what I hear those were pretty explainable. A few folks trying for really competitive fields or some not ranking enough programs. We had folks go to great places to do great things. ENT at LSU, Uroro at UNC, gen surg at UConn ... to name a few. I'm taking off the year to work on an MPH but my classmates are getting ton of interviews ... I think they'll will have a great match. Will that do? Or do you want something more solid? I'll actually see if I can get a match list.
 
pedsid said:
No kidding ... I still drove around campus with my gator tag and wearing my Gator stuff. We were members of the alumni association as well, apparently it's the biggest in the state. I think a slight majority of my class went to Florida.

Don't be hatin' now...

In fairness, I did the same thing with my Seminole tags for five years at UF. I loved the program there, but they can't sway my football loyalty!
 
Thanks so much for your input Peds!

Maybe this is a stupid question but can you go into dermatology from FSU?
 
Hi

Could you guys more or less say how long after submitting your AMCAS did you hear from FSU med? thanks.
 
medhacker said:
Hi

Could you guys more or less say how long after submitting your AMCAS did you hear from FSU med? thanks.

I submitted the last week of june, got a secondary 7/22
 
DrBlonde said:
Thanks so much for your input Peds!

Maybe this is a stupid question but can you go into dermatology from FSU?


You can go into ANYTHING from FSU ... one of my classmates is applying to derm now. I mean ... if you really like skin that much 🙂.
 
pedsid said:
You can go into ANYTHING from FSU ... one of my classmates is applying to derm now. I mean ... if you really like skin that much 🙂.

Correct me if I am wrong but applying is one thing and getting accepted to a derm residency is another. On a side note, I hear that three 4th year students are not graduating with your class. That can't possibly be a good thing. 🙁 To me, it shows a lack of support from the faculty/staff/administration.
 
jj08 said:
Correct me if I am wrong but applying is one thing and getting accepted to a derm residency is another. On a side note, I hear that three 4th year students are not graduating with your class. That can't possibly be a good thing. 🙁 To me, it shows a lack of support from the faculty/staff/administration.

Yep, your right ... people certainly aren't always going to match ... that wasn't the question.

The only 3 people I know who aren't graduating are 2 people doing MPHs (one at harvard one at hopkins) and someone who "took off the year" for personal reasons.

Glad to hear you're such a freaking expert about my school ... people drop out of schools everywhere ... i as talking to a first year at Duke last week at the AMA meeting ... they've had several already drop out. In my experience the school has gone above and beyond to accomidate students. Students who "failed" were given the opportunity to repeat the year. Not a lot of schools do that. Don't talk about the administration here if you don't know what the heck you are talking about. If you know of something that I don't please enlighten me.
 
pedsid said:
Yep, your right ... people certainly aren't always going to match ... that wasn't the question.

The only 3 people I know who aren't graduating are 2 people doing MPHs (one at harvard one at hopkins) and someone who "took off the year" for personal reasons.

Glad to hear you're such a freaking expert about my school ... people drop out of schools everywhere ... i as talking to a first year at Duke last week at the AMA meeting ... they've had several already drop out. In my experience the school has gone above and beyond to accomidate students. Students who "failed" were given the opportunity to repeat the year. Not a lot of schools do that. Don't talk about the administration here if you don't know what the heck you are talking about. If you know of something that I don't please enlighten me.

Just to let you know ... if you want to see the match list from last year its one the web site med.fsu.edu and then click on FSU MED the magazine. It's page 29.
 
pedsid said:
Yep, your right ... people certainly aren't always going to match ... that wasn't the question.

The only 3 people I know who aren't graduating are 2 people doing MPHs (one at harvard one at hopkins) and someone who "took off the year" for personal reasons.

Glad to hear you're such a freaking expert about my school ... people drop out of schools everywhere ... i as talking to a first year at Duke last week at the AMA meeting ... they've had several already drop out. In my experience the school has gone above and beyond to accomidate students. Students who "failed" were given the opportunity to repeat the year. Not a lot of schools do that. Don't talk about the administration here if you don't know what the heck you are talking about. If you know of something that I don't please enlighten me.


I never claimed to be an expert on your school... I was voicing an opinion (much like you were by starting this thread to give your OPINIONS about your school) and all the sudden you jump down my throat! I really don't understand why you are being so testy...has it ever occurred to you that perhaps I might have several friends in your class? AND I was not talking about matching... I am talking about RE-DOING their third or fourth year. It's your opinion that "the school has gone above and beyond to accomidate students," and that's perfectly fine. I am not gonna jump down you're throat b/c I don't agree with you... There are positive and negative aspects to everything but it's just funny that whenever a negative aspect comes up about your school you blow a friggin gasket. I don't believe in sugar coating. If you can highlight all the wonderful things, I can highlight all the not-so-wonderful things...it's called PERSPECTIVE.. geesh...
 
I figure I would take a look at the forum and I am glad to see that there is debate on FSU. I agree that the initial training facility was subpar but it was fine- an old high school with all high tech and renovated. The students were very cool and friendly. Pepsid is a great guy and passionate about his school, however, needs to tone it down a bit :meanie: . Opinions are welcomed on SDN and it is just info. Pepsids class started with 39 people. One dropped in the first semester because of family problems and poor performance as a result of family issues. Another student was held back in 2nd year because she recieved a C in a course and she had to make a 3.0 because she was on probation for subpar grades the prior semester. That is ok also. The problem is that in 3rd year, another student was forced/asked to leave the school as she was unable to score high on her shelf exams. Again, no so bad if you cant hack it, but questionable. The real problem is now 3 students out of the remaining 36 are repeating the entire 3rd year. In addition, at least 6 other students have been required to repeat rotations. that is 25% of the class having bad comments on the deans letter. It states in every deans leatter if you have been on probation, and you tell me if that hurts your chances of matching at non-primary care specalities. I am sure a few students in this situation had questionable issues, but should the faculty work this out prior to ending the rotation so that improvements can be made. To force a student to repeat is unreal. Other school might have 1-2 students repeat(out of 100 students). To fail them and force them to remediate a year (that is what they call it; should be called punishment)does nothing to help a student. The students who are repeating have aced all but one rotation and therefore can get along with everyone, but that one person. I admit, I cant get along with everyone as peoples personalities are different. If you get an old school doc, you might clash with him. Most schools dont have this problem because they care about the students and the students come first. At FSU, the faculty are "gods" and are attempting to gain position within the administration by having countless meetings on how to screw students. I have advised in the past to not go here unless you have no other alternative.
One last thing. Pepsids class had a step 1 off 212 initially and then 217 after the single student who failed retook it-which is avg in the nation. The prior year was about 208- saved only by 2 students who recieve 98 and 99% in the country. smart mofos. The last class did extremely well- though I think not because of FSU. They study like crazy. What pepsid did say was true-step 2 scores well above nat avg. Unfortuantely, programs really only consider step 1 since many students dont take step 2 until after match. But it is a positive. You can study at FSU and do well. You probably wont have any issues. Bu what if you do. I dont want to repeat a year or be forced into primary care unless that is what I love. Dont tarnish a student to improve your chances of getting an administrative position.

Sorry for the length
Good luck,

A truly unhappy FSU med grad 🙁 - and i succeed without all these troubles I have spoken about; other friends were not so lucky

One last thing, Pepsids class did add 2 people. They were the 2 who were forced to repeat 4th year. That is 2 out of the initial 30. Scary to me-that is an opinion, the other is truth 😉

pedsid said:
Yep, your right ... people certainly aren't always going to match ... that wasn't the question.

The only 3 people I know who aren't graduating are 2 people doing MPHs (one at harvard one at hopkins) and someone who "took off the year" for personal reasons.

Glad to hear you're such a freaking expert about my school ... people drop out of schools everywhere ... i as talking to a first year at Duke last week at the AMA meeting ... they've had several already drop out. In my experience the school has gone above and beyond to accomidate students. Students who "failed" were given the opportunity to repeat the year. Not a lot of schools do that. Don't talk about the administration here if you don't know what the heck you are talking about. If you know of something that I don't please enlighten me.
 
jj08 said:
I never claimed to be an expert on your school... I was voicing an opinion (much like you were by starting this thread to give your OPINIONS about your school) and all the sudden you jump down my throat! I really don't understand why you are being so testy...has it ever occurred to you that perhaps I might have several friends in your class? AND I was not talking about matching... I am talking about RE-DOING their third or fourth year. It's your opinion that "the school has gone above and beyond to accomidate students," and that's perfectly fine. I am not gonna jump down you're throat b/c I don't agree with you... There are positive and negative aspects to everything but it's just funny that whenever a negative aspect comes up about your school you blow a friggin gasket. I don't believe in sugar coating. If you can highlight all the wonderful things, I can highlight all the not-so-wonderful things...it's called PERSPECTIVE.. geesh...

Didn't mean to jump down your throat ... i've just seen people trash FSU with no evidence. I'm not sugar coating, I'm telling my PERSPECTIVE. Maybe I'm completely missing something ... maybe there is this grand conspiracy that I've just completely missed. I've asked nogoodfsu several times to PM me with some actual facts ... nothing.

So ... here's my experience which has been good. The negatives are obvious to me ... new school, not a lot of reputation, have to work harder to get your name out there and get LORs for residency. Other than that, I can't imagine going anywhere else. I don't get why there's a problem with that or that I'm somehow lost perspective ... I've lived it for 4 years, not you ... I don't care who you know ... you have no first hand information.

Maybe all the students in Tallahassee were just the bomb ... but no one there had problems execept for one guy having to redo a rotation that I know of.

Hey, I'm certainly open to negative remarks ... all of the negative remarks I've heard, I've really not heard anything concrete to back them up.

Seriously, enlighten me ...
 
pedsid said:
Hey, I'm certainly open to negative remarks ... all of the negative remarks I've heard, I've really not heard anything concrete to back them up.

Seriously, enlighten me ...

So let me get this strait... you want me to give you facts as in the names of the students that are not graduating with your class...on a public forum? I don't think so. Maybe everyone at the talle campus is peachy keen but did you ever think that students at the pensacola or orlando campus might be experiencing difficulties with the administration? Did you even read nogoodfsu's response? I think he/she provides a pretty good account of what is going on with the students at the other regional campus without disclosing their identity.

You might have had a good first hand experience at FSU but that is not the all-encompassing experience for the FSU COM students...you had a small class to begin with and to have 3 students repeat an entire year, i think, reflects badly on the school.

I'm just letting perspective applicants know that it is not all peaches & cream at FSU like some people would like them to believe.
 
Top