You are talking about the ER doc that gives a Rx for 180 oxycontin for back pain for a patient that now has to come to the Pain Clinic with the expectation that we need to refill his oxycontin?
Although your post is rife with jabs at EM (and I can counter each one - just like I don't have anesthesia in-house, so there's no one to "save" failed tubes - and, in my career? Zero), I shall take issue with this one.
Oxycontin #180? Really? For back pain? Even if a doc in the ED was dumb enough to do that, if the patient was opiate-naive, that would kill them; the chances of that naivete is slim, though, meaning someone else would have had to start the patient on that. Any clue as to whom that might be?
There is a pain guy here in town, but I don't know from which initial specialty he came to arrive at pain. He was on vacation for 2 weeks earlier this month, and his patients came out of the woodwork. How many times in your life have you lost your keys? Do I ever forget my insulin? Yet, the recurring theme of pain patients is "losing" their meds, or their meds were "stolen" (with a staunch refusal to call the police). It's remarkable how someone who is dependent on narcs can lose their lifeline - really remarkable. I had one of the pain doc's patients, who gets #240 MS Contin 30mg AND #390 (correct - nearly 400) Oxycodone IR 30mg per month. He "lost" his meds. The numbers he was Rx'd were backed up by a fax from the office. We have the option to fill all, half, or none of the patient's meds. This guy got a Utox and an Rx for #23 MS Contin - I told him he could either leave empty handed, or get his Rx for one day's worth, and the drug screen (+ for opiates and cocaine - despite his stating he hadn't had his meds in 5 days, and said the cocaine was just "wrong") faxed to the office. He chose the Rx.
Why this long damn story? Because that would happen each time if I was a candyman giving out nearly 200 Oxycontins for unsubstantiated complaints, and the place would be filthy with drug-seeking "patients". The pipeline is robust, and when a doc in the ED has a loose pen, the seekers come out like locusts.
I don't fault the EM doc for wanting to do pain management. I don't know why he would, but that's his choice. In areas I've worked, anesthesiology-pain have predominated in one, and PM&R-pain in another. Clients with Cluster B disorders were lacking in neither. I want as little to do with them as possible.
Oh, and even though I said I wouldn't, I'll swing at one more of your pitches in the dirt. When I was a resident, I saw the neurology resident try >10 times for an LP - the pt's back looked like the top of a salt shaker. If I can't get it in 2, I don't keep sticking. And I don't call anesthesiology (because I don't have them, and they don't generally do diagnostic tapping, as far as I know - isn't a "wet tap" a bad thing?).