- Joined
- Oct 24, 2008
- Messages
- 203
- Reaction score
- 1
Not going to give my ideas- just want to hear what everyone has to say...
Not going to give my ideas- just want to hear what everyone has to say...
Do you have a full scholarship to GW or something? If not, why in the world would you even consider such a comparison? Comparing UR to GWU is analogous to comparing UVA to University of Puerto Rico (better reputation, cheaper, not as good a location but not too bad, and I am equating stigma of being on probation with stigma of being from caribbean med school)..actually I think that analogy works pretty well!
FYI there was an article cited on SDN somewhere about GWU and how they misrepresented themselves to applicant by stating that thier probation was only due to 'administrative issues', when in fact they were put on probation for 'severe infractions' regardint their medical student training..look it up. So it would seem that GWU is:
1. So bad at medical education that the governing goard of medical school put them on probation after GWU ignored several warnings
2. So dishonest with their students that they lied straight-up to incoming and current students about their probationary status.
So i think the choice is easy.
Rochester by a mile. Much better school overall, cheaper, better rep, better location, etc. Although Rochester may not be the perfect location, it is much better than the dump that 90% of DC is.
you won't be closing any doors going to either school.
With that said, u of r is less expensive and has a better reputation. The only way i'd recommend gw over u of r for you is if you have some significant ties to dc that give you strong reasons to stick around, or if you want to be involved in politics.
I am really fed up with all the misinformation about GW. There's so much emotionally-driven comments about GW, that often time, the truth gets lost. I feel like a majority of SDNers read something bad about a allopathic program and they automatically think the school is horrible. Give me a break; get your facts straight or else your emotionally-charged comments are worthless. If, at best, they only add fuel to the mis-representation of an institution.
First of all, GW has been around for hundreds of years and has ascertained a great national reputation. No one ever questioned GW's reputation pre-probation
For a fact, many schools have been on probation before: (1) Temple, (2) Albany, (3) Finch/RFU, and a few others. If you're curious, Stanford Medical School was 1pt away from a LCME Probation in 1999 (google it if you don't believe me). See how Temple, Albany, and RFU have improved? There's all this love now for Temple, but yet no seem to appreciate the Temple's reached it's current reputation because of its LCME probation a few years back (note: LCME encouraged Temple to buidl the new med center and infuse money into scholarship programs to negate the high post-graduate indebtness).
Second, comparing GW to the carribean is ignorant. There's no comparison between the two. GW stands on solid ground and is a highly recognized academic instituion, with rich history, culture, and academic excellence. There are great schools too in the Carribean, but they do not hold the same caliber.
Third, GW's match list over the past few years have been incredible, with students matching into competitive programs in California, DC, and New England. Sure the match list is much more of an individual's performance, as oppose to the school. But do keep in mind, that the the school, GW, is preparing its students well enough that they are passing with high marks on the first try.
Fifth, do not mis-judge a school's reputation based on its MSAR stats. Yes, GW has somewhat of an average matriculant MCAT/GPA scores among applicants, but this does not mean that the school attracts "low-quality" applicant. Be mindful that GW has an undergraduate program that assures a group of student guranteed admissions into the medical school. Students in this program only has to get a certain baseline score on the MCAT/GPA; thus, their matriculant can lower the the MCAT/GPA for GW. This is something that is apparent for other schools that have early assurance MD programs, but many people fail to factor it in when judging a school by its stats.
I'll be honest, the LCME probation worried me. It made me re-evaluate whether or not I wanted to attend GW. However, I was in love with GW before the LCME probation and I am still today. It's a great school and I am particularly ecstatic that I got accepted. Yes, I interviewed at other higher ranked schools and some of them did not stack up to the environment that GW fosters. I have multiple acceptances and GW still stands out as the front runner. Lastly, I am incredibly sorry for the extra-long post, but I hate this public lynching of an instituion based on emotionally-driven merits. Get the facts then we'll compare.
And to the Op, Rochester is a great school. However, choose the school that best fits you, whether it be GW or Rochester.
PS: Anoncurious, you sound like a tool. I am sorry, but your post only ignites anger and adds nothing substantial to the op's question.
Speaking of rankings--take a look at the second paragraph in the article..GWU is ranked Number One!!! The only school on academic probation..beat that Harvard!
Don't apply to GWU..
lol, it's kind of funny that this post has no replies..
Some students have mentioned that GWU will emerge stronger from this probation. My question is how? The school gets very little state financial support, it's alumni endowment is scarce, it's NIH research money is ranked 85th etc.....
So I'm not sure how they'll come out bigger and better without raising the tuition( which already one of the most expensive in the nation) or cutting financial aid.
I am not sure that their alumni endowment is scarce and isn't GWU one of the few teaching hospitals that is FOR-profit? If the hospital makes profits that money will be invested into the medical school therefore making it stronger. Just a thought.
If this is true, why wouldn't they have invested in the med school before, thereby avoiding this whole probation fiasco? Also, just because it's for-profit, doesn't mean it actually makes a profit. I have no idea what the hospital's finances are like, but I doubt they make enough profit to dump millions back into the med school. It's probably worth doing a little research on that.I am not sure that their alumni endowment is scarce and isn't GWU one of the few teaching hospitals that is FOR-profit? If the hospital makes profits that money will be invested into the medical school therefore making it stronger. Just a thought.
According to the Washington post:"In the 1990s, GWU's hospital was losing so much money it was starting to eat into the school's relatively small endowment, in part because the patient population includes many uninsured District residents."
To your other point: GWU sold it's teaching hospital and now has only a 20% financial stake in it. Is a 20% shareholding enough financial impetus to turn a medical school around? Remember that GWU has owned that stake since 1997( 12 years now). What were they spending it on before? Will they re-direct the money back to the medical school now that they are on probation ? I hope so.....
If this is true, why wouldn't they have invested in the med school before, thereby avoiding this whole probation fiasco? Also, just because it's for-profit, doesn't mean it actually makes a profit. I have no idea what the hospital's finances are like, but I doubt they make enough profit to dump millions back into the med school. It's probably worth doing a little research on that.
Also, is GW pass/fail? Rochester has a totally pass/fail for the lecture courses.
P.S. Is there a mercy rule for these polls?
OP, it looks like you want to justify going to GW over UR. If that's the case, don't look to us for any personal self-validation or anything. If you like GW better, go. If you don't, don't go.
False. I am leaning towards Rochester I just wanted to get a poll to see what the masses would do. I figured more people would choose Rochester, but I had no idea it would be this overwhelming. I am merely trying to defend GWU on the probation issue because I think it is relatively unimportant because it will be old news in a few months. I made this more to get a feel of why people like UR more (like the second yr clinical rotation, the pass/fail, the research). I am also glad to see most people are like me and think it is smart to sacrifice location for the program. So no, not trying to justify something here- just trying to get rid of the probation debate that has been had 1000 times already.
False. I am leaning towards Rochester I just wanted to get a poll to see what the masses would do. I figured more people would choose Rochester, but I had no idea it would be this overwhelming. I am merely trying to defend GWU on the probation issue because I think it is relatively unimportant because it will be old news in a few months. I made this more to get a feel of why people like UR more (like the second yr clinical rotation, the pass/fail, the research). I am also glad to see most people are like me and think it is smart to sacrifice location for the program. So no, not trying to justify something here- just trying to get rid of the probation debate that has been had 1000 times already.
I would pick U of Rochester since IMHO and based on what I saw during residency interviews there and have heard about the two schools, I believe U of Rochester is stronger. I was extremely impressed with their medical center and faculty. However, if you just want to live in DC and/or are interested in politics and/or health care policy, that might be a reason to go to GWU. I'm sure they'll get off of probation. I know someone who went there and got a good ER residency. However, my general impression is that the teaching will be better at Rochester, and you likely will have an overall better educational experience. It's cold as hell up there, though.
...It's cold as hell up there, though.
I interviewed at GW.
When I was trying to convince my student interviewer how much I liked GW, she said
"I know you'll have multiple acceptances in the end (even though you don't have one now), THINK LONG AND HARD ABOUT WHICH SCHOOL YOU WOULD LIKE TO ATTEND, wink, wink.
I did not choose GW.