Well, to be fair, I took the following courses having the following course descriptions:
1. Humanities 1: "A" at School 1 (old)
-- Description: "Introduction to the art, architecture, history, literature, music, religion and philosophy from the ancient through the medieval."
http://www.sierracollege.edu/_files/resources/academics/catalog/catalog-13-14-web.pdf
(pp 195)
2. Humanities 2: "A" at School 1 (newest)
-- Description: "Introduction to the art, architecture, history, literature, music, religion and philosophy of the Western World from the Renaissance to the present."
http://www.sierracollege.edu/_files/resources/academics/catalog/catalog-13-14-web.pdf
(pp 195)
3. Humanities 1: "D" at School 2 (new)
-- Description: "A broad introduction to the major forms and types of artistic expression: sculpture, architecture, painting, philosophy, literature, drama, dance, film, and music."
http://www.siskiyous.edu/academics/classes/hum1001/vancil/
**Added Bonus!
4. Humanities 1: "B" at School 3 (between the old and new)
-- Description: "An introductory survey of influences on Western culture, historically structured from classical Greece to the Renaissance, presenting enduring works of art, drama, literature, music, and philosophy."
http://www.gocolumbia.edu/catalog_schedules/courses.pdf
(pp 46)
So, according to my research, I have not 2 but 3 Humanities 1 courses. Further, Humanities 1 and 2 at School 1 cover the same material (but in different time frames) as Humanities 1 at school 2, so technically, I think that AACOMAS should split the difference and do some math weighting.
But then again, there's the counfounder bonus Humanities 1 at School 3; it sounds similar to Humanities 1 at school 1, am I right? It covered the influences on Western Culture, though, which is admittedly different than 1. - 3. above.